Politically, I personally would welcome the day that says RIP to NYT -- it would be hugely helpful in getting our political system back on the track. We desperately needed intelligent and critical oversight of the state during the past and current decade and NYTimes completely (willfully, imo) dropped the ball. (They completely lost all credibility post 9/11 in my eyes. Please show me the front page headline with pictures of the huge ("tens of thousands") anti-war demo in Washington D.C. prior to invasion of Iraq. We've all seen the one for Egyptians ...)
I'm really curious, and not trying to be snarky: how old are you?
Regardless of your stated intent, you should be aware that your query comes across as a subtle form of ad-hominum. Let's discuss "all that is fit to print" and not my white chest hair ..
It's not an ad hominem if your age has a relationship to your argument. It may or may not, we don't know because your interlocutor hasn't followed up.
I was under the impression that ad hominem is about dragging irrelevant personal qualities into the debate.
For example: the topic is water quality. Joe Bloggs is troubled by the effects of pollutants in tap water.
Not an ad-hom: "He owns a company which manufactures tap water filters".
Ad-hom: "He's an atheist".
maybe to you, but there's literally millions of people who think the other way around. Facebook is much more widely known around the world (especially to uneducated people) than the NYT is.
facebook wishes it did that. if the ny times disappeared, there would be a hole that could not be filled by the other news networks. the quality of news, as a whole around the globe, would suffer. There is no comparison.
we should remind ourselves to zoom out from the california coastline every once in a while.
[1]http://www.quantcast.com/facebook.com [2]http://www.quantcast.com/nytimes.com
My argument isn't that people would even be aware of the changes to society. I think if the NYT disappeared, many many areas of American life would be altered in important ways, as I attempt to flesh out in other comments.
As far as the NYT goes however, I don't believe that the impact would be much more than sadness based in nostalgia. The talent that exists there today would still exist, and be applying their skills at other institutions, both new and old.
How do you recreate the culture that comes from a history of unrivaled excellence and the role of being the "paper of record" for so many generations? That's not an easy mantle to pull out of thin air. How do you convince a younger organization, or even a smaller organization, to continue to devote resources to cover unprofitable stories like the continuing developments in Tunisia, for example.
Same with Apple, I would argue. Take all the people that work there and spread them out to competing companies and you don't necessarily get the same results.
Would you care to elaborate?
Another example is Wikileaks, where the NYT played a very important role on several sides of the story. The NYT is very much responsible, especially within the US, of amplifying, editing, and creating much of the narrative around the major Wikileaks dumps it was involved with. And they aren't always a force for "good", and have done a lot to damage Assange's reputation and helped marginalize Wikileaks.
I don't think everything the NYT does is great, but they are a hugely important part of many many world-scale developments.
You could write similar things about its role as an arbiter and editor of culture, about its influence on the public discourse and the ideas that permeate contemporary life, on its role in business and consumer culture (Foxconn, as a recent example). It touches so many things, and reaches so many, as those in tech might call them, "influencers," that it permeates American life, directly and indirectly.
It is a good bet that what is printed in the New York Times in the morning, goes on tv at CNN, MSNBC and even FNC for the day.
Come to think of it, didn't the last bubble start very similarly too?
One over-inflated stock begat another and another..
The deadtree papers represent the old megaphone model of information dissemination (hi capital, few speakers, many listeners). It's been obsoleted.
Again, not claiming Facebook isn't very important, nor that it doesn't impact individual people directly more than the NYT. But the NYT doesn't just reflect what's happening in the world. In doing so, they also profoundly influence what's happening.
I'm not saying Facebook isn't hugely important, it is. But I think Facebook is less important than the NYT, and also might be more easily replaced.
If instantgram shut down tomorrow, it wouldn't matter at all.
In fact, I think that if Facebook shut down tomorrow it would matter less than if the NYT did.
I have no idea if the valuations are crazy, and I don't mean to be making a point about bubbles or anything else. I just think it might be a condition of contemporary capitalism that "importance" and "value" are in many cases unrelated.