News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by nsxwolf on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @09:40AM (#3822102)
In the age of immortality, everyone eventually dies in a car crash or something similar. There is no escaping death.

The common objections don't change this. "Uploading your brain" is an unsolved philosophical conundrum that may or may not continue the existence of "you".

The universe eventually dies, too. 10 billion years is not immortality. Escaping to a newer younger universe is a pure speculation.

Everyone will die.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by lbo on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @10:50AM (#3822387)
The notion of so-called uploading is an interesting one. From a philosophical and practical point of view, I think it's actually pretty simple. If you uploaded my brain into a robot and we both woke up, he'd say he was the real me and I'd say I was the real me. An outside observer could not tell the difference--it would be theoretically impossible to. If you killed one of us, one of use would feel like he died, the other wouldn't. Both of us would feel like we'd lived an entire lifetime before this moment because we'd share the same memories. This is the farthest one can ever dig into this problem. An ego is a side-effect of a functioning mind, it's not something with a unique physical location or material continuity. I think it's highly unsatisfying from our ego's perspective to think of uploading like this, but our ego also wasn't designed to think of itself in these terms any more than it was designed to visualize 4+ physical dimensions.
Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by batista on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @11:11AM (#3822513)
>This is the farthest one can ever dig into this problem.

No, I think the whole problem can be bypassed, check my answer above.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by lbo on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @01:46PM (#3823420)
Amazing the lengths we'll go to just to satisfy our simple evolutionary incentive to live, no matter how ludicrous from an outside perspective :)
Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by batista on Wednesday April 11, 2012 @09:37AM (#3827431)
>Amazing the lengths we'll go to just to satisfy our simple evolutionary incentive to live, no matter how ludicrous from an outside perspective :)

"Lengths" like, err, making a thought experiment like the above in a HN thread? I've went further than that just to get a bag of Pringles.

And it's not like it's a "simple evolutionary incentive" anymore. That might hold true for a lizard or a deer, but a human has more complex rational to want to live. It might be evolutionary still, but it's far from "simple" when you can think about it.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by lbo on Thursday April 12, 2012 @11:01AM (#3832585)
I don't mean discussing it, I mean that doing it would be. In particular, it seems like a dramatic length to me because an outside entity would never be able to tell the difference between your theoretical swap and a 'standard' upload/copy in terms of the resulting individual. The only difference would be that the person would go into it perhaps more confident that his ego wouldn't 'die'.

But no, I don't agree with you that humans' desire to live is any more real or special than a lizard's, or a tree's, or a rock's desire not to break apart for that matter. It's a natural extension of physical laws combined with the circumstances of our evolution as a system--in this case linked directly to our basest subconscious instincts. To say that your desire to live is fundamentally stronger or more complicated than that of a deer reeks of geocentrism of the ancient world to me.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by batista on Friday April 13, 2012 @02:47AM (#3835659)
>But no, I don't agree with you that humans' desire to live is any more real or special than a lizard's, or a tree's, or a rock's desire not to break apart for that matter. It's a natural extension of physical laws combined with the circumstances of our evolution as a system--in this case linked directly to our basest subconscious instincts. To say that your desire to live is fundamentally stronger or more complicated than that of a deer reeks of geocentrism of the ancient world to me.

You say "more real or special" here, though, whereas you said "simpler" in your previous comment.

You get back to the same argument at the end though: "To say that your desire to live is fundamentally stronger or more complicated than that of a deer reeks of geocentrism of the ancient world to me."

It might not be more "real or special" or "stronger" (I never argued that it was anyway), but it SURE is more complicated.

And to deny that reeks of obsessive reductionism to me. The desire to live as expressed and felt by some billion (trillion?) neurons of a human, is more complex than the desire to live as expressed by the primitive brain of a lizard, or even a "rock's desire not to break apart" (!). I don't even think we can call the latter "desire".

We can feel everything a deer can feel about the desire to live (horror, survival instinct, etc --we're animals after all), but ON TOP OF THIS we can write poems, sing songs, make movies and have deep conversations about it. Including massive institutions on the matter, such as religion.

I'd call that more complex --calling it anything else would be delusional.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by UnFleshedOne on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @12:23PM (#3822936)
10 billion years should be enough for anybody.
Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by batista on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @11:08AM (#3822502)
>The common objections don't change this. "Uploading your brain" is an unsolved philosophical conundrum that may or may not continue the existence of "you".

In the naive way of making a copy of it, yes.

But consider this: with some future procedure, each neuron of your brain is replaced by a mechanical one, one at the time. You maintain your consciousness at all times.

In the end of the process, you now have a fully mechanical brain.

No philosophical conundrum this way, right?

>The universe eventually dies, too. 10 billion years is not immortality.

Yeah, I don't care, 100-200 million years sound enough for me until I get bored.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by datr on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @11:16AM (#3822550)
>No philosophical conundrum this way, right?

I wouldn't be so sure: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ship_of_Theseus

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by majma on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @11:57AM (#3822780)
as batista already pointed out, this already applies to biological humans due to cell death and regeneration, so it's a very pressing philosophical problem!

how old do i need to be before holding a funeral for my past self?

what about special ceremonies for people coming out of medical sedation or comas or just waking up in the morning? a "fractional welcome to the universe party" seems in order, as the person is not really the same one that used to exist.

if upload tech like batista describes is ever created, we will probably give the resulting person the same common sense benefit of the doubt we give to people in the above cases.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by batista on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @11:40AM (#3822677)
This is about whether something that had it's parts replaced remains the same "thing" - but we were talking about consciousness here, and there would be no copy nor consciousness gap with the described process.

Plus, this problem is solved in practice for us humans anyway: all of our cells are regenerated and replaced by new ones every few years, yet we consider ourselves to be the same persons.

Re:Sixty Years Old - is my future short and messy, or long a... by nooneelse on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @02:09PM (#3823531)
Not all of our cells are replaced as you describe. Some cells in the brain, heart, and eyes last throughout our lifetimes.

I'm not making any particular claim that our identity as minds hinges on these three types of cells (though such a case for the brain cells seems, prima facie, like a possible good direction), but if you are going to make claims about what our identity as minds does not hinge on, you should take more care to get the facts straight.

ref1: http://www.thenakedscientists.com/HTML/content/latest-questi... ref2: http://www.usatoday.com/tech/columnist/aprilholladay/2007-03...