News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by nl on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @12:12AM (#3820647)
Do you get standard deviations when you watch the summary today's weather on the news? I think the statistical detail was appropriate.

If you are seriously proposing that standard deviation makes an average 8.6 degrees above normal insignificant then you are going to have to present some pretty compelling evidence. NOAA do generally know how to do some basic math.

Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by simonster on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @12:38AM (#3820707)
A standard deviation of greater than 4.48 degrees would make 8.6 degrees above average insignificant, assuming a normal distribution (alpha = 0.05, two-sided Z-test).
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by nl on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @01:16AM (#3820795)
sigh

I do understand what standard deviation is, and I do understand that it is possible that a 8.6 degrees difference would be significant. What I meant was that NOAA wouldn't be highlighting this unless it was.

Anyway, it's public data, and we can settle this pretty easily, right?

http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/temp-and-precip/time-series/index.p... has the raw data in CSV form going back to 1895.

The standard deviation is 2.89 (assuming my calculations are correct)

Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by bigiain on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @02:21AM (#3820981)
I other words, (again, if your calculations are correct) if this were a typical HN discussion about A/B testing a conversion goal, we'd all be ridiculing anybody who suggested a result almost 3 standard deviations from the mean _wasn't_ "statistically significant", yet climate change (sceptics|denialists) will no doubt _still_ argue the relevance of this…
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by tedunangst on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @10:46AM (#3822370)
Not quite. If this were a discussion about A/B testing, we'd be ridiculing anybody who said "I made $8.60 more with my new design."
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by lutorm on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @09:09AM (#3821967)
The bigger problem (as others have alluded to) is that we don't really know what the tail of the distribution looks like. There's no obvious reason to think it's gaussian.
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by tedunangst on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @12:35AM (#3820700)
If the standard deviation is 10, then 8.6 degrees above the mean is insignificant. Providing a number like 8.6 without the s.d. is presenting zero evidence. That's like page two of my statistics textbook.
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by scott_s on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @01:31AM (#3820844)
It's a press release. Most people don't know what a standard deviation is.
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by tedunangst on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @01:42AM (#3820872)
I was replying to the parent comment, not the story, and the claim that we could somehow determine the significance of 8.6 without knowing more. As for press releases, "It was hot" is probably a sufficient level of detail for most people. :)
Re:NOAA: U.S. Records Warmest March; More than 15,000 Warm T... by nl on Tuesday April 10, 2012 @02:43AM (#3821047)
We are talking about weather. A little common sense will let you decide if 8.6 degrees is significant.

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3820795 for the calculations if you insist.