> Edit: Now that I think about it, the lack of basic statistical disclosures is pretty damning evidence that nothing significant has happened.
No.
New value: 80.3. It's a record high, but is it an extreme value? i.e., are record highs extreme values by definition?
From a casual glance at the graphs showing past hot years (each one shows 5), NOAA appears to have records for most cities going back to the 1950s (probably 100 years in some cases).
So, in a set of 63 (1950-2012) values, which are themselves average temperatures (and thus representative of some kind of trend, not just a single hot day), the procedure picks out the 5 highest values of average temperature.
It's reasonable to expect that the sequences corresponding to these 5 highest values will be unusual when compared to the other 58. Nothing weird about that.
Of course, if they had only 10 years data, as in your example above, or if they weren't using monthlong averages, it would be a different story.
The raw temperature data is available at http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/temp-and-precip/time-series/index.p...
The standard deviation is 2.89.
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/special-reports/march-2012-heat-wav...
Standard deviations are not an appropriate summary when talking about extreme values.
We're basically conditioning on extreme values ("plot temperatures of all cities having their hottest March on record in 2012"). So, while the standard deviation might be a useful summary of:
P(temperature on day t),
a standard deviation would not be a useful summary of: P(temperature on day t | average temperature is highest recorded)
In general, after you condition in this way, the events ("sample paths" of the function "temperature at time t") don't look like the rest of the population.They're oddballs, and by definition, there are only a few of them -- only one March can be the hottest on record. Maybe the best comparison would be the second-hottest March, so plot that one.
There would certainly, for example, be no reason to believe this population looks Gaussian in the tail. In fact, it would probably be misleading to make any assumption about what a "typical" extreme sample looks like. This is probably why just other sample paths (temperature as a function of t) for that location were given, rather than some summary statistic. You can't average oddballs.
There are probably locales for which standard deviation is not ever a useful summary. I'm thinking of places which are subject to strong unpredictable variations, like Santa Ana winds, that are more a 0/1 phenomenon. This would result in a multimodal distribution of temperature, which would make standard deviation misleading. That is, it could be really cold, or rather warm, but unlikely to be in-between.
Look at DC. Until the last week in March, 1998 is flat or even trending down. That seems like the actual daily temps were possibly below average, no? Whatever, YTD may be pretty to look at it, but I don't think they're good for interpretation. http://www1.ncdc.noaa.gov/pub/data/cmb/images/us/2012/mar/wa...
I just mention this because "temperature at time t" is not what we're looking at.
So, while the 1998 graph and the 2012 graph look close at the end the actually daily values in 2012 needed to be significantly higher than 1998 values to create that much separation when they so recently crossed each other.
Infact it's actually 1976 that had the most comparable march from the sample given. However, because those years where chosen because their jan - march average was so far above the average it does not really show how abnormal 2012 was. Consider, where the average is and how many colder years it takes to average out to that.
If you are seriously proposing that standard deviation makes an average 8.6 degrees above normal insignificant then you are going to have to present some pretty compelling evidence. NOAA do generally know how to do some basic math.
I do understand what standard deviation is, and I do understand that it is possible that a 8.6 degrees difference would be significant. What I meant was that NOAA wouldn't be highlighting this unless it was.
Anyway, it's public data, and we can settle this pretty easily, right?
http://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/temp-and-precip/time-series/index.p... has the raw data in CSV form going back to 1895.
The standard deviation is 2.89 (assuming my calculations are correct)
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3820795 for the calculations if you insist.
I agree with the rest of your post, but come on, this is just silly. Absence of evidence (on one particular website) is certainly not evidence of absence.
"The average temperature of 51.1 degrees F was 8.6 degrees above the 20th century average for March and 0.5 degrees F warmer than the previous warmest March in 1910."
Without standard deviations, who cares?
And clicking through to the main article, I'm surprised by how many words can be written without saying anything of consequence. Even the graph showing Green Bay temperature looks like nothing more than a plot of noise.
Edit: Now that I think about it, the lack of basic statistical disclosures is pretty damning evidence that nothing significant has happened.