Re:Ex-Kotaku staff go independent and launch Aftermath
by gurchik on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:08AM
(#38176861)
The gaming community is often delusional and will rant online about a journalist giving a game a 9/10 instead of a 10/10. Good reviews, where the journalist actually played the game and has experience to compare it to, goes unnoticed. Garbage articles, like "Nintendo used a disability slur in a song" (turns out they're speaking Japanese) get huge attention.
Re:Ex-Kotaku staff go independent and launch Aftermath
by smcl on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:20AM
(#38176999)
Yeah I’ve seen that a few people get very upset over one reviewers’ subjective take on a game to the extent that they’ll hound them online. James Stephanie Sterling’s 7/10 on Tears of the Kingdom springs to mind (though they seem to be a bit of a lightning rod for hate overall). I can’t fathom it myself, I’ll read and watch a few reviews to get an overall feel for the game and see from there. Come to think of it, most of the reviews I encounter don’t give a score.
Re:Ex-Kotaku staff go independent and launch Aftermath
by notjoemama on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @09:26AM
(#38177082)
Isn’t there a discussion to be had about journalists (and activists) needing to insert intersectionality into fantasy worlds in a genre for a demographic that didn’t ask for it?
I’m detecting an air of elevated ego in your reply. I understand the toxicity that has and does (now to a much lessor degree) exist, but can’t we recognize when social justice jumps sharks? I think we can. It’s ok to admit when activism goes too far, wandering into the territory of enforcing morals onto other people; making the same mistake the religious right has done…
Re:Ex-Kotaku staff go independent and launch Aftermath
by smcl on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @12:28PM
(#38179840)
If you want to have that discussion, feel free to find the people who think the existence of 1 (one) male character indicates sexism, like the GP described, and discuss it with them. Tbh it sounds more like you want to use the GP's hyperbole as a wedge to open up a (ugh) "culture war" debate and frankly I'm not interested.
Re:Ex-Kotaku staff go independent and launch Aftermath
by Goronmon on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @03:17PM
(#38182194)
Isn’t there a discussion to be had about journalists (and activists) needing to insert intersectionality into fantasy worlds in a genre for a demographic that didn’t ask for it?
Don't we need to have a discussion first to debate whether you should be writing comments on such topics first? I mean, I didn't ask for your opinions, so I think it's a discussion worth having.
There's plenty of great games journalism out there. I'm similarly unsure about Kotaku, but let's not get silly here.