News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by asah on Monday November 06, 2023 @07:43AM (#38161824)
what? um no: they are paying 21B because * Apple * has a monopoly on their platform and would divert users to another search engine who paid $1 more.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by tebbers on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:25AM (#38162277)
Tell me again how I can release apps to iOS platform users without going through the Apple App Store.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:54AM (#38163413)
Sell on Android exclusively and help convince people to swap phones.

I’m only half kidding here as companies dropping Apple in mass would eventually get people to swap. Though I suspect an Android only ecosystem would quickly become even worse for developers.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by prepend on Monday November 06, 2023 @07:47AM (#38161862)
You’re not using the word monopoly correctly.

Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on their platform. They make a platform that’s part of a market. And they have a minority portion of that market.

That’s like saying Folgers has a monopoly on Folgers coffee. The sentiment is kind of right, they are the only ones who make Folgers, but it’s not the right term as being an exclusive manufacturer is not a monopoly in terms of anti trust or this conversation.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by bogwog on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:21AM (#38162242)
I'm not an expert on this in any way, but I've been following this Google case and have learned a few things. In antitrust lawsuits, a critical part is to define the "relevant market" over which a company is being accused of doing illegal anti-competitive things. This isn't straightforward or easy to define, but I do think it's very easy to make a strong argument that Apple has enough market power over some markets to justify enforcement action against them.

> Apple doesn’t have a monopoly on their platform. They make a platform that’s part of a market. And they have a minority portion of that market.

I don't think "a minority portion" means anything, since illegal activities are still illegal. I.e. collusion doesn't become legal just because you're a small company. And again, I think it'd be pretty easy to identify more than a few markets where Apple very clearly has an overwhelming market share.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by fallingknife on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:16AM (#38162859)
Can you name any of those markets? I can't think of any.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by realusername on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:42AM (#38162445)
It's not a "market" if there's no competition.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by jonhohle on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:47AM (#38163313)
How can a company not have a monopoly on their own proprietary product? Is Sony required to allow anyone to publish games to the PlayStation store? Is Comcast required to allow me to broadcast on their cables?

The delusion about Apple’s “monopoly” has to ignore all precedent and legal definition of monopoly and hinge on not liking how they run their business. Then don’t do business with them. They have a minority share in phones, tablets, computers, and effectively every other market they’re in.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by realusername on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:09PM (#38165313)
I'm not even talking about a monopoly but about competition and that's going to be very hard to argue that it exists. Antitrust lawsuits are about anticompetitive behavior, not literal monopolies and Apple defense seems pretty much impossible to make here.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by paulryanrogers on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:26AM (#38162295)
Even by your broader definition it's a duopoly, with one whose taking 90+% of the profits in the smart phone market of the US.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by jonhohle on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:37AM (#38163175)
Who is taking the majority of the other 10%? Where in the definition of monopoly is taking profits a requirement? (Hint: it’s not. It’s about price control and market capture.)
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by paulryanrogers on Monday November 06, 2023 @05:07PM (#38169752)
What defines anti-trust is up the people. We can replace ineffective obfuscating thresholds like Nixon era "consumer harm" BS.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by spot5010 on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:06AM (#38162074)
I don’t know why you are getting downvoted. You’re right.

Not justifying apples tactics though.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by qwytw on Monday November 06, 2023 @08:47AM (#38162501)
> That’s like saying Folgers has a monopoly on Folgers coffee

Not quite. We should apply a bit more nuance, yes iPhones and Android phones more or less can do the same things but they aren't entirely replaceable and not a commodity like coffee.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:35AM (#38163148)
Each coffee brand offers their own unique flavors, just as each tire manufacturer has their own trade offs, and each car … However, subtle flavor profile or minor product features isn’t enough to be considered a distinct market.

The simple fact that people swap between Android phones and Apple phones without buying both means they are in completion. Making cellphones a duopoly not a monopoly.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by jonhohle on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:39AM (#38163218)
You could say mobile operating systems may be a duopoly, but cellphones themselves are made by a dozen or more manufacturers. And the company that makes the most widely used mobile operating system is not Apple.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:45AM (#38163288)
Sorry, yes cellphone operating systems is the market I was thinking of.

But my point is you can slice and dice markets in multiple ways, however brands themselves don’t qualify as a market otherwise every brand would be a monopoly and the word stops being meaningful. It’s the expensive watch market not the Rolex watch market.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by qwytw on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:48AM (#38164996)
I guess the thing is that there is much more to it to it than just a brand. If you're heavily invested into Apple's environment (spend a lot of money on apps, maybe media on iTunes etc. and/or you rely on their cloud services etc.) the cost for switching to Android is significant enough that you might be willing to tolerate some abuse from Apple's before you do that.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:01PM (#38166135)
Lock in doesn’t qualify as a monopoly. Camera lenses etc aren’t necessarily portable from camera to camera. However, if Company A went bankrupt, then someone would eventually by X, Y, or Z. Whatever those things are defines the market.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by seec on Friday November 10, 2023 @04:07AM (#38216712)
Yep, pretty much. I am in the process of doing that and it is a rather long and annoying. I had the argument with my cousin a week ago, he was pissed off about how bad his iMac is for the price he paid. But when everything was said, he just defaulted to : yeah but I have all my stuff here, it would take so much effort to switch I would rather pay up. I believe this is exactly what Apple knows and precisely why their behavior is so despicable even toward their most long term customers. It makes a good reason to never actually rely on Apple software for anything. I used to be an advocate for their nice and clean software, but nowadays I would rather take the "inferior" options than being locked in their extortionate pricing. The problem with Apple is clearly that they have no real competition, there are alternatives but it's not an easy quick switching like you could be doing with any other computer maker. In the end, Windows is what it is, but at least you will not be locked to a particular company and their pricing for the OS feels fair enough.

Apple approach of locking their software to the hardware supposedly gives better result, but this has not been true for quite a while and doesn't actually give many benefits to the end user (cue the refrain for ecosystem gimmicks).

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by qwytw on Monday November 06, 2023 @11:45AM (#38164952)
> subtle flavor profile or minor product features

Don't agree they are subtle or minor (it's of course a scale and coffee is objectively, based on consumer behavior and preferences, way lower on it than smartphones or PCs).

> fact that people swap between Android phones and Apple phones

Some do. Some don't, of course not's not an entirely distinct market, only partially (just like tablets vs smartphones or laptops vs tablets just too a much smaller extent).

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Monday November 06, 2023 @12:55PM (#38166034)
The definition is generally based around substitutable goods. If you’re buying coffee on a vacation in another country and the brand you like is unavailable most people would buy a different brand.

The degree to which something acts as a substitute generally defines the market. If Apple discontinued the iPhone without any substitute some people might replace it with laptops, but the vast majority are going to buy an Android phone.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by LeonB on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @02:12AM (#38174052)
Apple’s ability to wield its market power to force buyers or sellers to use its platform is firm evidence of the sort of power that anti trust laws (if they retained any teeth) are designed to prevent.

For example they were able to force banks to agree to support Apple Pay. And it’s the wielding itself that is sufficient proof of the trust violation.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Tuesday November 07, 2023 @04:17AM (#38174799)
I think you’re confusing monopoly power with the free market. Apple Pay exists in South Africa for example which has a 16% iOS market share, Mexico at 20% etc and only a fraction of that is going to use Apple Pay.

Apple didn’t force anyone to participate in Apple Pay anymore than Samsung did to get banks to Support Samsung Pay. Mobile payments also started well before Apple got in on them.

Banks got onboard because customers like the convenience, so if customers had a non mobile card and a mobile card many of them would prefer the mobile card. That’s not monopolistic power, that’s the free market at work.

Merchants don’t need to do anything it’s the 3rd parties making payment machines which needed to support Apple/Samsung/Android etc and they are competing in a market where Apple Pay is just another feature they can use to differentiate themselves. So again free market forces.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by LeonB on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#38191846)
> Apple didn’t force anyone to participate in Apple Pay

We’re on different planets.

> Banks got onboard because customers like the convenience

… Banks in Australia fought it for years.

Your point about 20% market share being enough demonstrates the point. There’s no set percentage of customers. The wielding of power alone demonstrates the issue.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:36PM (#38200377)
It’s not 20% market share it’s a fraction of that 20% that would potentially use Apple Pay. We’re talking low single digit percentages of total customers which is worlds apart from monopoly power.
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by LeonB on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:58PM (#38200568)
You’re missing the point.

There’s no magic percent of a market that proves or disproves the sort of behaviour that antitrust laws are designed to prevent.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by Retric on Thursday November 09, 2023 @10:08PM (#38214629)
Anti trust laws aren’t designed to prevent behavior abstractly. If you have a 5% market share you’re allowed to do things that companies with a 95% market share are prohibited from doing. Similarly it’s not illegal to be a monopoly. The only thing monopoly laws are there to prevent is specific behaviors by monopolies.

This is why companies argue they aren’t monopoles, because if they aren’t then the behavior is legal. This is why your car insurance company can offer discounts if you get a life insurance policy through them. The government supports insurance bundling etc because it’s actually economically beneficial as long as it’s not a monopoly trying to get into a new market.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by LeonB on Thursday November 09, 2023 @11:02PM (#38214906)
Without getting into nda territory — the minority of Australians who used iPhones in 2017 represented a figure that far exceeded 50% of wealth held in Australian banks.

Thus apple had tremendous market power in “fact”, even if the raw numbers looked much smaller.

So long.

Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by asah on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:24PM (#38166534)
what color is that bike shed ? /s
Re:Google Pays $21B for Search Monopoly: How "Free" Tech Mar... by micromacrofoot on Monday November 06, 2023 @09:15AM (#38162843)
So... Google is afraid that a company won't use them if they don't pay to be the only option? This sounds like the same thing.