Re:Montreal Built a Blueprint for Bargain Rapid Transit at C...
by gniv on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:04AM
(#38159398)
Having grown up in a town with lots of streetcars, I don't really like them. They are awkward in car traffic, prone to accidents. And stations have to be created in the middle of the street, a hazard for pedestrians. For new projects I much prefer electric busses. Much more flexible and better integrated in traffic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Montreal Built a Blueprint for Bargain Rapid Transit at C...
by woodruffw on Monday November 06, 2023 @01:09AM
(#38159415)
> And stations have to be created in the middle of the street, a hazard for pedestrians.
Why? The NYC bus network closely mirrors the old streetcar network, and uses sidewalk dropoffs; there’s no reason why reactivated streetcars couldn’t do the same.
The point about integration with traffic is a reasonable one, but see below the point about civic value: NYC needs less traffic on its streets, and inducing behavior away from driving by taking up that space with a permanent streetcar line doesn’t seem like the worst approach to me.