Re:The Tyranny of the Diff
by knowtheory on Sunday April 08, 2012 @11:07AM
(#3813981)
The point is fair enough, but to call this a tyranny seems a bit much.
If one believes (as say that Literate Code movement does) that code alone isn't sufficient to convey an author's intent, why should diffs alone, which mark changes in a codebase, be any different?
Comprehensible commit messages and comments explaining the purpose of a method itself (and perhaps the mechanism around which a block of code functions if necessary) are no vice and go a long way to mitigate or counteract any such "tyranny".
If one believes (as say that Literate Code movement does) that code alone isn't sufficient to convey an author's intent, why should diffs alone, which mark changes in a codebase, be any different?
Comprehensible commit messages and comments explaining the purpose of a method itself (and perhaps the mechanism around which a block of code functions if necessary) are no vice and go a long way to mitigate or counteract any such "tyranny".