Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress...
by roryokane on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:04AM
(#38124368)
Maybe they was intending to say that “they” is painful when paired with singular verbs like “is”, “are”, and “was”? I, at least, find that previous sentence painful.
Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress...
by tayo42 on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:17AM
(#38124461)
Is "they is" actuslly a correct thing to say? I'm not much a grammar person, that sounds odd to me.
Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress...
by defrost on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:34AM
(#38124571)
It's odd and it's not considered correct in either the US or the UK today.
I doubt it was ever "correct English" but it may well have been common in some parts of the UK in times past.
Re:Hearing 'bad grammar' results in physical signs of stress...
by Terr_ on Friday November 03, 2023 @12:54AM
(#38124684)
> is painful when paired with singular verbs
True, but I'd say that's a "bad grammar" problem, not a "singular they" problem.
SA is not a naive word-swap of "he/she" with "they (and "him/her" with "them") while keeping everything else the same, but a style which demands a certain internal consistency. You use various words which cover the "one or more" case, even though some other context establishes it's just one.
Otherwise... well, that usage is so common--and ancient--that I don't think they know what they are talking about.