Re:Bear Does Analytics with CSS
by arp242 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:51PM
(#38102073)
> If it was just about a simple count the host could just `wc -l access.log`
That doesn't really work because huge amount of traffic is from 1) bots, 2) prefetches and other things that shouldn't be counted, 3) the same person loading the page 5 times, visiting every page on the site, etc. In short, these numbers will be wildly wrong (and in my experience "how wrong" can also differ quite a bit per site and over time, depending on factors that are not very obvious).
What people want is a simple break-down of useful things like which entry pages are used, where people came from (as in: "did my post get on the frontpage of HN?")
I don't see how anyone's privacy or anything is violated with that. You can object to that of course. You can also object to people wearing a red shirt or a baseball cap. At some point objections become unreasonable.
That doesn't really work because huge amount of traffic is from 1) bots, 2) prefetches and other things that shouldn't be counted, 3) the same person loading the page 5 times, visiting every page on the site, etc. In short, these numbers will be wildly wrong (and in my experience "how wrong" can also differ quite a bit per site and over time, depending on factors that are not very obvious).
What people want is a simple break-down of useful things like which entry pages are used, where people came from (as in: "did my post get on the frontpage of HN?")
I don't see how anyone's privacy or anything is violated with that. You can object to that of course. You can also object to people wearing a red shirt or a baseball cap. At some point objections become unreasonable.