News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by fsflover on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:28PM (#38090179)
> and a big reason why I gave up on smartphones entirely

This is not necessary: my Librem 5 doesn't rely on blobs in kernel and runs FSF-endorsed GNU/Linux, PureOS.

Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by fifteen1506 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @04:16PM (#38090739)
Pixels may also be an option -- though Librem 5 is, in this context, better.

Pixels Pro have now... 7 or 8 years support.

Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by dawidpotocki on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:56PM (#38092513)
Because Purism cheated and just moved the blobs into a chip that you can't update and made it go through a separate processor[1]. FSF-endorsement is meaningless. This is worse than having a loadable blob from a kernel.

[1]: https://puri.sm/posts/librem5-solving-the-first-fsf-ryf-hurd...

Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by fsflover on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:59PM (#38092542)
I don't see how it's worse. As a consequence, it's the only phone that can run fully free OS and have lifetime updates.
Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by dawidpotocki on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @08:09PM (#38093048)
You can't update the firmware at all and you are still running it.

Librem 5 has very dated hardware that barely runs. It has only Cortex A53 cores @ 1.5 GHz that were released in 2012. You will see it even lag in Purism's videos.

Modern Android phones have better OS, hardware security, battery life and will be useful for longer and cheaper.

Librem 5 now costs 1000 USD, the same price that Google Pixel 8 Pro costs which also has guaranteed 7 years of OS support. Will you want to use Librem 5 in 7 years?

Also let's not forget how Purism took forever to ship the devices and was declining refunds from people that didn't even get sent the device and waited way over a year.

Oh and there are Android phones that can run on mainline kernels.

Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by fsflover on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:26AM (#38096156)
> Will you want to use Librem 5 in 7 years?

Yes: Librem 5 is a full desktop, with my full control, "Thinkpad T400 in mobile". It will always run latest Linux and all desktop apps. I can use it as a full desktop connected to keyboard/screen. On the other hand, Android is not a general purpose computer, which only runs what Google allows you to run.

You should try SXMo if you want to see how smoothly Librem 5 and even Pinephone can work if the software is optimized.

> You can't update the firmware at all and you are still running it.

Is there even theoretically an attack vector here?

Yes, Purism has been having problems with refunds. It doesn't affect security or freedom of they devices. Don't buy from them if you will want a refund.

Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by forty on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:25AM (#38096524)
How will you fix it in 4 years? I don't see were they sell spare parts.
Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by fsflover on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @08:51AM (#38097533)
They don't have spare parts in the online shop, but people on the forum were able to buy them or repair the devices by contacting Purism directly. AFAIK in case of a larger demand, Purism promised to provide spare parts more explicitly.
Re:Upstream Linux support available for Qualcomm Snapdragon ... by HappyDaoDude on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @08:11PM (#38093064)
It is the closest we have to a freedom respecting device. The baseband processor is still a closed blob but it is a lot better than pretty much everything else out there. Maybe Pinephone eventually will get there as well.