News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by ben_w on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @11:19AM (#38086169)
I had a free school education; a free library; and with the exception of my final year even my university tuition was free[0]; after graduation the museums I went to were also free; I watched free educational videos from Apple Developer and YouTube, and listened to free podcasts.

This doesn't cover everything: I did, indeed, also buy books on HTML and JS, and my first C compiler, and a licence to REALbasic[1]. But that doesn't refute the fact that I did learn a lot for free.

> If AI models require human training data, then they should pay for it. Easy.

You can do that if you like, but that won't stop any of the economic issues that arise. The cost of running Stable Diffusion is so low that even if you had literal slaves, and you were spending only the UN extreme poverty threshold on keeping them alive and housed, the pro-rata cost of keeping them alive for long enough to type in the prompt dominates the total cost of making images.

Right now these models are still, despite their impressiveness, flawed: while an artist can use them to great effect, most of us will have our generations easily spotted by some flaw we have never trained ourselves to notice. If the models become good enough to fully replace all artists, the only way the profession called "artist" isn't going to go the same way as the profession called "computer" is if the arts are to humans as fancy tails are to peacocks: the effort being the point, extravagantly wasting effort to show you're fit enough to manage fine despite the penalty.

[0] UK rules at the time, thanks to my dad's early retirement and therefore "low income" status

[1] as it was so named at the time, Xojo now

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by kranke155 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:19PM (#38087210)
If we let this idea that "AI training data usage has no compensation for rights owners" to be become ensconced in the legal system, then all human endeavour will become fair game to be acquired by someone to make a Machine Intelligence out of, and remove you completely out of the profit loop of your own work.

This will happen in every industry and occupation, one by one.

Is this what you think is desirable?

The alternative is perversely simple: PAY for the right to use training data.

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by ben_w on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:34PM (#38087486)
> Is this what you think is desirable?

Post-scarcity economics, AKA "fully automated luxury communism" (not the book of the same name): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post-scarcity

Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by kranke155 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:47PM (#38087687)
is that the direction we're going in right now? Or are we moving towards techno feudalism?
Re:Artists Lose First Round of AI Art Copyright Infringement... by ben_w on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:54PM (#38087832)
More anarchy than the feudalism for the moment.

The main Stable Diffusion models themselves are licensed under Creative ML OpenRAIL-M, and freely available third-party models exist; OpenAI gets stick for not making their models downloadable (at least GPT-x does, though nobody seems to care too much about them keeping the DALL•E 2/3 models private), other players are making and distributing other LLMs of varying quality.

That said, we do also have actual reasons to be concerned about this remaining anarchic (though a lot of people very loudly scoff at them), so who knows what the future will bring on that axis.