Same thing that happened on the construction of the "corporation as a person", built on top of rulings made to protect African Americans.
We've achieved AGI, it's just yet a baby. Only a few years ago, if you wanted a model that could complete a task, you'd have to train a model specific to that task. GPT-4 can do a large variety of tasks without being specifically trained on them, i.e. it's suitable for a wide range of general tasks. Yeah, it sucks at some of them, but focusing on that is short-sighted. Look at the progress made from just a few years ago and where it's going, especially with multimodality and increased compute power.
This thing is a machine intelligence. My point is that a machine intelligence to be equivalent to humans in every law is curiously never mentioned, except when it is advantageous to the owners of said machine.
Or are we saying that we can't turn off GPT-4 at this point, because following your metaphor, we would be committing murder or abortion?
Again, you can't reason using metaphors and inferences and analogies. It's not helpful.
> except when it is advantageous to the owners of said machine.
That's just not true. You're ignoring vast amounts of discussion on the topic, particularly the discussions had when Blake Lemoine claimed that LaMDA was sentient. There's no reason to dismiss all that just because you're dead set on assuming everyone involved in AI is up to no good.
A perfectly reasonable view for humans, since you shouldn't be able to copyright a brain.
Not at all a reasonable view for a computer, until we also get to freely use all the copyrighted works ourselves. The problem here is that AI training is asymmetric: the people training an AI use works in violation of their licenses, but don't let their own works be used in the same way. For instance, Microsoft uses code on GitHub to train Copilot, but you still don't get to freely the source code of Windows or GitHub.
I am absolutely in favor of eliminating copyright and patent law. I am not in favor of keeping it around while letting AI become a laundering mechanism to get around it. AI training should not get to uniquely ignore copyright; copyright should cease to exist.
2. Despite the differences, the similarities are rhetorically convincing for many.
I recon there will be a lot of bad analogies for the next decade at least.
For the purpose of creating new art from experiencing previously created art, why should we treat them differently?
If AI training should be fair use has nothing to do about how it works (search engines fall under fair use regardless of if they think or not) but the effects it have on the original author.
So when people talk about humans and AIs "doing the same thing", AIs are not legal entities like humans are to begin with, the entire premise is moot.
If you put your "work" out in the world, anyone who views it, is automatically training their brains on it. Viewing is training.