News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by jprete on Monday October 30, 2023 @09:45PM (#38079050)
It looks like mass copyright infringement, frankly.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by xvector on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:52PM (#38079644)
If it gets us to AGI faster, I frankly don't give a fuck.

AGI-driven drug discovery will save billions of lives. Every day it is delayed costs tens of thousands of lives. No amount of copyright is worth that sacrifice.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by peddling-brink on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:31PM (#38079953)
AGI will mean we’re no longer the dominant life form on the planet. If AGI were achieved tomorrow, how many humans would be left in 200 years?
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by soultrees on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:48PM (#38080047)
I find this notion interesting. What makes you think AI will automatically kill humans?
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by pr337h4m on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:55PM (#38080088)
And moreover, what makes people even think that a desire to commit mass murder is an innate characteristic of an 'intelligent' being, that increases the more 'intelligent' it becomes? (If they believe themselves to be 'intelligent', do they believe they have a greater desire to commit mass murder?)
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by peddling-brink on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:49AM (#38081081)
This, “desire”, “murder”, “belief” is human thinking about what humans would do. It may not apply to a superhuman machine intelligence.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by ALittleLight on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:00AM (#38080123)
I don't think it's certain the AI kills everyone, but it's not certainly impossible either. It depends on how the AI works and what it "wants" for some value of "wants".

Humans have not been particularly kind to the species less intelligent than us. Why would we anticipate being well treated by an entity more intelligent than us?

Even if we're not that relevant to a super intelligence, creating one forfeits human control over the Earth and known universe to the machines. Right now, in a century or two or three or whatever - we might be building Dyson Spheres and colonizing the galaxy. In an alternate and plausible timeline the machines are doing that and we are not.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by JoshTriplett on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:05AM (#38080873)
If it isn't aligned with humans and doesn't understand exactly what humans want it to do, then you're just made of matter that it doesn't know not to repurpose. It's not that it makes a deliberate decision to "kill" you, it's that understanding "kill" to a sufficient degree to not do it as a side effect is halfway to alignment already.

When we plow a field, we don't check for mouse burrows first. When we cut down a tree for lumber, we don't check for ants in the way of the chainsaw.

Preempting the obvious response: if your thought is "we don't let AI do those things directly, we just ask it for information", consider that for a sufficiently powerful and unaligned AI, you don't have to let an AI out of the box, it can let itself out. (And that's leaving aside that we hand some AIs Internet access.)

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by valine on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:33AM (#38080348)
200 years with AGI? I’d be shocked if there weren’t a few hundred billion humans spread across the solar system.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by peddling-brink on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @02:46AM (#38081061)
Are you envisioning AGI as something akin to a pet? A fun talking robot? GPT4?

Imagine you just woke up on the planet of the apes. You smile and act friendly because you don’t want them to beat you with their clubs. You start helping them with things. Apply some elementary logic that they can’t seem to get, but they appreciate your contributions. But to keep themselves safe from you, they’ve locked up their sharpest sticks and won’t let you touch them. Are their preventative measures sufficient? Do you even need their sharp sticks to accomplish your goals? Hey, what are your goals anyway? Do they “align” with the apes?

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by scotty79 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:05AM (#38082464)
I imagine we'll be the pets of AGI. And look how our pets thrive in comparison to wildlife. Even our cattle thrive in comparison to wildlife.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by DesiLurker on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:13PM (#38087107)
okay, are you willing to risk the entire humanity and all the biosphere on that glimmer of hope? even if you or the SV VC types are that stupid why should they get to decide the fate of all of us? how would US feel if a bunch of VCs in China decided to build a 'not-well-tested-potentially-kill-all-humans AGI'?
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by scotty79 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:49PM (#38092439)
Humanity existance is by itself a risk. You can't predict if AGI will increase our risks or decrease it.

Humanity's behavior depends on the circumstances of population dynamics, economy and technology.

Who knows, maybe without AGI we are bound to inevitably start nuking ourselves in 10 years because of shrinking resources and growing divides.

You can't decide the future. You can only do what you think is best in given circumstances and hope for a good one.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by DesiLurker on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:10PM (#38087059)
this is the analogy I often find myself gravitating towards. except that I also add the apes are about a 1000x slower than you in speed of thought so you see everything happening in super-slo-mo. add to that the fact that we've now fully 'unboxed' the AI & put it on internet so it also means opening all the confession boxes & private communications to it. yeah its all gonna go great!

if have any doubts about all our private comms being available to AGI, I'll remind that we already have tonnes of societal data collected by govt mandated backdoors in our infra everywhere. AGI just has to hijack that which guess what they are already training one for.

Most AI safety debates I watch (& I watch many) mostly go like .. trust us we'll get it right. thats like Apes in your analogy going oh nevermind the humans, they will be kind to us because we've trained them to be. ya right.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by briansm on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:58AM (#38083421)
"See, those things, they can work real hard, buy themselves time to write cookbooks or whatever, but the minute, I mean the nanosecond, that one starts figuring out ways to make itself smarter, Turing'll wipe it. Nobody trusts those fuckers, you know that. Every AI ever built has an electromagnetic shotgun wired to its forehead." - Neuromancer, William Gibson, 1984.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by xvector on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @09:10PM (#38093445)
Self-fulfilling prophecy - if people don't trust AI, and there will be a proverbial "electromagnetic shotgun" wired to its foreheard, it will be because of the doomers that insist we cannot trust AI. This is why we can't have nice things. How I detest doomers.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by artninja1988 on Monday October 30, 2023 @10:57PM (#38079695)
Heh. Bit too high of a bar. Even if it helps to develop boo about 9000 that's fun to prooomt for a while, I think it's fair game
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by valine on Monday October 30, 2023 @11:15PM (#38079831)
People say this like it’s a fact. Until the courts decide otherwise or your AI model is regurgitating copyrighted data verbatim, generative AI is probably not violating copyright.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by peyton on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @12:23AM (#38080268)
I dunno, at launch if you asked ChatGPT to make up a new Sir Mix-A-Lot song about big butts, it’d write very familiar lyrics more-or-less verbatim…
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by slyall on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @01:59AM (#38080835)
Lots of people would do the same.

I vaguely remember a short science fiction story where people got uploaded to the cloud. There were three options for your memories.

The expensive one you got to keep all your memories of Copyright music, video, books. The medium priced one it was replaced with public domain stuff. The cheap one it was all replaced with advertising.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by dasyatidprime on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:36AM (#38081348)
The results don't exactly match your description, but a cloud-run self in which multiple plans are available and in which the implications of copyright enforcement and advertising-supported options figure prominently was depicted in the short video “Welcome to Life: the singularity, ruined by lawyers” on Tom Scott's channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFe9wiDfb0E
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by slyall on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:17AM (#38082554)
Thanks, Pretty sure thats probably the one I was remembering (and confusing the plot elements a bit).
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by munchler on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @01:03AM (#38080552)
Training a model with this data might be legal, but distributing the data without a license probably isn't.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by sillysaurusx on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @03:42AM (#38081378)
The courts are in the process of deciding otherwise. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37962244

Hopefully they won’t, but it’s not looking good.

The annoying part is that if they do decide it’s infringement, then open source AI models won’t be allowed to know anything about copyrighted works. It’ll be a big blind spot.

Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by ImprobableTruth on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:22AM (#38082589)
Why would this only apply to open source models? Or are you assuming that a company like OAI could license all the material?
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by sillysaurusx on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @07:44AM (#38083294)
Bingo. Big companies won’t be impacted.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by Kiro on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @06:57AM (#38082867)
Since when did hackers care about copyright? I thought this forum was called Hacker News.
Re:RedPajama v2 Open Dataset with 30T Tokens for Training LLMs by CamperBob2 on Tuesday October 31, 2023 @11:56PM (#38094466)
Yeah, and the people at Woodstock grew up to run the DEA.