I think the real dispute is how the opcode space and code density will evolve when more and more extension will need to be added. Will more 32 opcode space and 64 bit instructions but no 16 and no 48 bit instructions in the longterm be a better choice than fewer 32 bit insrructions, but 16/48/64 bit instructions?
On the flip side, a 48-bit instruction takes FIVE bits just to specify the length which is a massive amount of overhead.
I think 64-bit instructions which contain between 1 and 4 instructions (not VLIW as no ILP is specified) would be a better solution offering more compressed instructions and much lower length encoding overhead for 48 and 64-bit instructions while still leaving a potential opening for very long instructions composed of several 64-bit groups. This beats out the Qualcomm proposal in terms of cache, code density, fusion, jumping, and many more without losing any of the benefits of compressed instructions (in fact, it increases the compression benefits).