News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jsight on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:36PM (#38028068)
It doesn't seem like lithium is actually scarce. Does this help with the more tricky issues developing at the moment? For example, graphite?
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by paiute on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:41PM (#38028143)
This is a decent nerd video that talks about lithium mining. I enjoyed it. https://www.youtube.com/live/inq_ypJeiZk?si=o34J3qJVNoDJ2FBy
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by bee_rider on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:36PM (#38028974)
I did, but I think the answer was kind of jargony or, at least, I didn’t get it. It sounds like she was saying that it exists all over the place in small amounts because it doesn’t like to be a solid?

I think it is an interesting lecture if you are interested in a sort of geographical answer of where they might look for it, but at least after skipping around a bit and watching some stretches at double speed, she hasn’t gotten to the sort of economic answer of, like, do there exist sources that can turned into batteries easily (since we are mostly programmers who mostly care about whether or not the batteries will exist to power the devices we want to program).

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:57PM (#38030952)
Afaik,

> do there exist sources that can turned into batteries easily

Yes, but only a few. There aren't many high-concentration lithium deposits. (There are many more low-concentration)

Which is essentially the mining industry in a nutshell: concentration of raw mined feedstock -> economically efficient processing -> finished product (bought by consumers who don't care where it came from, and so has a single market price)

See: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_carbonate#Production

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by opencl on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:20PM (#38028725)
Lithium isn't scarce relative to current demand levels but if the automotive industry wants to transition to 100% EVs that's an enormous increase in demand.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jandrese on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:54PM (#38030906)
Isn't that just how markets work? They are sized to the demand today, so if you were to increase demand by 10x overnight of course they would be distorted. If however demand increases slowly over time then the markets react normally--suppliers increase production, new suppliers enter the market--and the price remains fairly stable.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:13PM (#38031120)
That's assuming availability at quantity of base resources.

Which has generally been a fair assumption: as demand increases and price increases, exploration is incentivized and new sources are found, and capital is invested to increase production at existing / new sources.

But... there are also other ways it can go. Copper? Cobalt? Uranium-circa-1940s? Sometimes, more just isn't found.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jandrese on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:56PM (#38031585)
In cases where supply is externally constrained the markets still work. The price of that component starts to go up so people search for alternatives. This is already happening in the battery market (as per TFA) and is natural.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:58PM (#38031607)
It's not always possible though.

Look at titanium. The US had to buy it (through shell companies) from the Soviets for their spy planes, because there were no alternatives.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by lazide on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:12PM (#38032365)
There is no shortage of titanium ore. Titanium is the 9th most abundant element in the earths crust, at roughly .5%.

There was at the time a severe shortage of usable titanium refined metal. Refining Titanium is much more difficult than aluminum.

The soviets had over invested in the ability to produce it, so it was more economic to get it from them than try to produce the capacity here.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by bsder on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:16PM (#38032396)
Actually, doesn't titanium precisely demonstrate the original point.

Ukraine now barely ranks as a producer while China, South Africa, and Australia are the primary sources.

When demand pops up, different deposits start becoming viable.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Friday October 27, 2023 @09:58AM (#38038491)
With some more research, titanium looks like a fascinating example.

Heavy mineral sands [0] seem to be the primary source, with total heavy minerals at ~1% of weight (all mineral components).

Of that, ilmenite [1] is the primary titanium ore (reduced to sand).

So essentially, natural primary physical reduction (of hard rock to sand) is required to meet the current market price for economic viability. There exist hard rock sources, but most would be too energy intensive to exploit, given the low concentration.

The South African Tormin operation is especially fascinating, as it has ore reduced to sand AND then washed over geologic timescales by wave action, separating out less valuable minerals and concentrating the remainder (~25% THM). [2]

Which I guess is the bulk of my point: 'at any cost', there are always more resources to mine; 'at reasonable cost', there can be sharp differentiations between different types of resources (e.g. in titanium: naturally concentrated heavy mineral sands, heavy mineral sands, hard rock).

Something being widespread in the Earth's crust, but at less than 1% concentration, doesn't help us a lot if we need civilization-scale quantities of it.

Or, if copper were distributed like that, we'd probably all use aluminum wiring.

[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heavy_mineral_sands_ore_depo...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilmenite#Feedstock_productio...

[2] https://www.mineralcommodities.com/operations-projects/south...

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by marcosdumay on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:26PM (#38028811)
Lithium is plentiful enough for grid storage, but it's so at a higher price than it has today. It's also cheap enough for mobile batteries, but not negligible, and cost is the most important metric for grid storage.

Thus, lithium looks like one of the fundamental bottlenecks for grid storage. It can kinda work on high-cost small-size pilot projects, but we probably won't be able to use it for real.

Sodium on the other hand has all of the same desirable chemistry properties, but scales much better. And iron has all the cost benefits, but undesirable chemical properties. (And there are, of course, people working on C-H vs. C-OH bonds that are completely out of the box.)

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:52PM (#38030881)
Flow batteries always seemed like the ideal solution for grid-scale storage.

You decouple the transformation (charge/discharge) from the capacity (liquid volume), with the goal of making the latter "a standard pressure, watertight tank."

But I believe last time they came up here, people said the charge/discharge still needed some work.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by marcosdumay on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:33PM (#38031344)
Yes, it looks like that to me too. Also, they make the lifetime of the active element independent from the one of the reagents, and recycling and maintenance very standard. It's just not really related to the chemistry.

Also, long-term storage will very likely use some different chemistry from short-term. High-temperature batteries have some very interesting trade-offs that I have no idea how will pan-out in practice. Things are mostly not settled on that area, it looks like a very interesting thing to work on.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by ethbr1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:02PM (#38031660)
I wonder if we (as a species) will ever get to reverse nuclear fission.

I.e. putting energy into nuclear reactors so that we can produce U-235. Although I guess technically breeder reactors, although like-to-like is less fun fantasy than solar -> fissile.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by Baeocystin on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:20PM (#38032897)
A grid-scale Vanadium-based flow battery was recently installed in Australia.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-06-23/vanadium-flow-battery...

IIRC, this particular chemistry is an Australian development, as well.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by uoaei on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:52PM (#38030890)
Grid storage doesn't need to consider weight at all. We can use heavy storage methods if they're cheap enough with enough capacity. There's some rather exotic designs for energy storage that don't use any materials that we could feasibly run out of.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jsight on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:53PM (#38032690)
I get that, but it is all relative. I'm not seeing any indication that lithium is the most difficult aspect of battery production. It seems like a short term problem compared to graphite, nickel, and (seemingly) cobalt.

It seems like time is the bottleneck in basically all cases rather than overall capacity as well.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by marcosdumay on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:07PM (#38032801)
Nickel and cobalt aren't a problem at all. Neither are necessary for current lithium batteries. Graphite is a manufacturing problem, not a material one.

Batteries have no bottleneck. Just lots and lots of things one can improve a bit with some amount of work.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jsight on Friday October 27, 2023 @11:39AM (#38039964)
True, but doesn't that negate the point of the article? "Lithium is relatively scarce and ..."

It sounds like a false premise to me.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by marcosdumay on Friday October 27, 2023 @12:55PM (#38040929)
It's not scarce enough that we couldn't use it for grid storage, but it is scarce enough that we very likely won't.

It's a perfectly fine point to make, and it's one of the things worth optimizing.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by jtriangle on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:10PM (#38029512)
Nothing is really scarce, but, costs associated with accessing it effectively make it 'scarce'. In that regard, sodium is far more abundant.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by Gibbon1 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:33PM (#38029839)
My understanding is for batteries lithium is the less tricky one because it doesn't change size during redox reactions. Sodium does and that damages the anode or cathode (can't remember which, don't care).

Yeah and the low production of lithium is due minimal demand historically. It's not like other metals with a large historic demand. Like copper.

Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by tooltalk on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:52PM (#38031554)
Well, graphite is not all that scarce either. The problem is that China has almost complete dominance in the anode material production (ie, graphite) with 90+% market share in EV battery supply-chain.
Re:Sodium batteries offer an alternative to tricky lithium by HappyDaoDude on Thursday October 26, 2023 @07:30PM (#38032987)
It seems like Lithium isn't so much quality limited by supply speed. At least for the moment.

There is some concerns in terms of total materials for stuff like Cobalt/Nickel but even then, my gut feeling is that those issues are more fear mongering rather than a real issue.