News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by elromulous on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:35PM (#38003309)
This is such a wild edge case though. So we think the vehicle should do what, keep driving, potentially causing more damage?

It's highly situation specific, and I'd expect the emergency personal to make the judgement call on how to free the person (potentially by taking control of the vehicle, or other means).

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by kelnos on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:38PM (#38003351)
Oh, I agree. You may have loaded the page before my edit where I expanded on my first paragraph.

(I have my comments appear on a several minute delay because I know I sometimes submit a comment before I've made sure my intent was clear, but I maybe I took too long this time. It's a bad habit, and I know I should slow down, but... yeah.)

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by tapoxi on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:42PM (#38003405)
Keeping autonomous vehicles on the road will result in thousands of edge cases, and without a clear safety benefit (as opposed to Level 1 systems) its better to stop everything and reconsider.

Honestly, I don't think this tech will be able to ever be fully automated without controlling the environment as well (dedicated lanes). There's just too many variables you can't account for, and too much risk.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by kelnos on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:45PM (#38003431)
Is there a way to measure the (potential) safety benefits without putting these vehicles on the road?

I'm not saying that means we should just put them on the road, consequences be damned, but I'm curious if there are alternative ways to prove them without risking bystanders' lives.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by spaced-out on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @03:42PM (#38004328)
> Keeping autonomous vehicles on the road will result in thousands of edge cases, and without a clear safety benefit (as opposed to Level 1 systems) its better to stop everything and reconsider.

True, but I bet either a Cruise or a Waymo would have stopped rather than hit that woman crossing the street, and they definitely would not have fled the scene like the human driver did.

Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by tapoxi on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:03PM (#38004644)
I mean it did hit her (again), ran her over, then stayed on top of her. That's not a better scenario at all. A Level 1 system can still avoid hitting people.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by elromulous on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:50PM (#38015807)
Did you read the whole thing? She was knocked onto its path. It might be have been physically impossible to avoid hitting her at that point.
Re:California suspends GM Cruise's autonomous vehicle deploy... by elromulous on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:52PM (#38015839)
Circling back to add some info. From this[0] page:

"But the DMV also said it was not made aware that the Cruise vehicle then tried to pull over while the pedestrian was underneath it."

Kind of proves my point. Stopping completely would have been more ok. The issue the DMV took is that it then pulled over, and that cruise withheld that information.

[0]https://spectrum.ieee.org/lta-airship-faa-clearance