Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by alphabettsy on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:14PM
(#37993378)
That data is 20 years old. Maybe stats are the same or similar, but the makeup of vehicles on the road has certainly changed since 2002.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by Mindless2112 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:21PM
(#37993436)
The average truck/SUV driver has also changed.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by Zigurd on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:29PM
(#37993490)
Despite being old data, what they call "light trucks" are the gigantic pickups and SUVs of today. "Heavy trucks" are almost all commercial vehicles.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by sunshinesnacks on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:38PM
(#37993577)
It seems like it would be useful to show relative risk per passenger mile in addition to vehicle mile. I don’t think that’s in the study, and I can’t find average bus utilization.
For example, if cars and light trucks carry 1.5 passengers on average (made up number, but I’m sure it’s less than 2) and buses carry 20 passengers, then buses would be safer for pedestrians. Assuming you can “trade” light passnger vehicles for buses on a 1:1 passenger mile basis, which isn’t perfect, but it’s relevant.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by chefandy on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:35PM
(#37993553)
That statistic supports the obvious: hundreds of thousands of buses throughout the world constantly drive tortuous routes through extremely densely populated areas, and far fewer drive in places with more miles and few people.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by sokoloff on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:19PM
(#37993419)
Anyone care to wager that “We’re addressing this from a data-based perspective,” [words of the bill's sponsor], will not impose these proportionally higher fees upon buses?
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by snorlaxle on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:33PM
(#37993528)
If you look into pedestrian fatalities per mile travelled per pessanger, buses are most probably still far safer
than any of the vehicles listed.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by sparky_z on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:27PM
(#37993482)
It seems to me that an even more relevant metric
(if there were a reasonable way to calculate it) would be deaths "per passenger mile" rather than "per vehicle mile".
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by legitster on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:31PM
(#37993520)
You are skewing the data. The report itself says that. Buses only account for 2% of pedestrian casualties while cars and light trucks account for 90%.
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by camel_gopher on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:09PM
(#37993346)
So the term “hit by a bus” reflects reality
Re:Colorado Law Would Charge Owners for Driving Giant Trucks...
by throwaway562if1 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:52PM
(#37993673)
Note that for an appropriate relative comparison between individual and mass transit, the appropriate measure is per passenger mile. (For a truly accurate comparison, you should also normalize driving regimes; cities, where buses generally operate, have a much higher rate of incidents per mile.)
For an absolute comparison, buses are responsible for 2% of pedestrian deaths, vs approx. 90% for cars (per the same FARS data).
(all ages)
(age 0-14) (age 85 and older) source: https://injuryprevention.bmj.com/content/11/4/232