> […] because [Google] was on notice that the material was defamatory and refused to remove the information, it could not be found to have innocently circulated the information
In this case, the woman notified Google that their search results for her were defamatory, Google did not take them down, and Google was held to be a secondary publisher because their algorithm actively determined what URL to show, what snippet to show, etc.
The second lawsuit was about the auto-complete where ever time you searched her name it'd suggest appending "psychic stalker" to it. So it'd be more akin to every time you ordered coffee from startbucks they wrote down "Dude, Physic Stalker" on your cup every time.
You are allowed to insult people personally, just there are restrictions if you publish defamatory speech.
There is a world of difference, legally, between disparaging a powerful politician like Biden and a normal private person.
They have to remove defamatory content once someone has told them it's defamatory. Essentially the ball is put into Google's court at the point, with the question: are you willing to defend this as non-defamatory? Which is the same question all primary publishers face.