News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by cwillu on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:40AM (#37984258)
As far as I can tell, the problem is that google surfaced posts claiming she was a stalker, when she merely lied about a psychic having caused her friend to commit suicide in posts about that psychic. Or something.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Y-bar on Monday October 23, 2023 @07:44AM (#37984305)
Google appears to be still allowed to surface content which is defamatory, but they still have a publisher's duty to remove it once notified, I think this is key from the summary (linked elsewhere in the discussion):

> […] because [Google] was on notice that the material was defamatory and refused to remove the information, it could not be found to have innocently circulated the information

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by cool_dude85 on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:37AM (#37984795)
It seems like under Australian law there's a concept of a "secondary publisher" of defamatory content, which would typically be a bookstore or library. So, the actual publisher, author, etc. can be held liable for defamation, but also, if the bookstore has been notified that it is selling a defamatory book and does not take it off the shelf, it too can be held liable.

In this case, the woman notified Google that their search results for her were defamatory, Google did not take them down, and Google was held to be a secondary publisher because their algorithm actively determined what URL to show, what snippet to show, etc.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by lesuorac on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:14AM (#37985150)
Well a bit more than that.

The second lawsuit was about the auto-complete where ever time you searched her name it'd suggest appending "psychic stalker" to it. So it'd be more akin to every time you ordered coffee from startbucks they wrote down "Dude, Physic Stalker" on your cup every time.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by fasthands9 on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:57AM (#37987560)
I don't think that would be speech that you could sue over, in the US or Australia.

You are allowed to insult people personally, just there are restrictions if you publish defamatory speech.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by Symmetry on Monday October 23, 2023 @08:32AM (#37984747)
I don't think it's reasonable for Google to remove content whenever someone just says its defamatory, in the absence of a court finding that it's actually defamatory. Otherwise we'd quickly lose every reference to Biden winning the 2020 election once it was widely known that the rule existed.
Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by colonwqbang on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:34AM (#37985371)
But the court did find that it was defamatory.

There is a world of difference, legally, between disparaging a powerful politician like Biden and a normal private person.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by caf on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:11PM (#37990899)
They don't have to remove content whenever someone just says its defamatory.

They have to remove defamatory content once someone has told them it's defamatory. Essentially the ball is put into Google's court at the point, with the question: are you willing to defend this as non-defamatory? Which is the same question all primary publishers face.

Re:Woman wins 12-year legal battle against Google by DrJaniceDuffy on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:34PM (#38005122)
please see my comments above