That’s a function of the train speed. If the train traveled at 300 mph, then LA<->SF becomes faster than Brightline’s 180 mile LA to Vegas route, which looks like it will average 100 mph.
I’ve definitely been trying to steer the conversation towards maglevs.
Even with the speed, you would have to do LA <-> SF as the crow flies. California HSR Phase 1 is 520 mi.
On the other hand, LA <-> LV is effectively flat, at least from where the Brightline leaves in Palmdale. The difference between the two projects is pretty stark.
According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-speed_rail :
While there is no single standard that applies worldwide, lines built to handle
speeds above 250 km/h (155 mph) or upgraded lines in excess of 200 km/h (124
mph) are widely considered to be high-speed.
From https://www.hsrail.org/brightline-west/ : Brightline West is ready to connect Las Vegas and the Los Angeles area at speeds of up to 180 mph.Do trains require more staff per seat? Amtrak trains seem to have 2 staff in the car and I assume 2 engineers, and roughly (5 car consist of 72 seats) 360 passengers, vs 4-6 people for 180 people on an A320.
But I would imagine it's seat density (more seats in a plane fuselage vs a train car) and sold seats vs empty seats (airlines have a pretty efficient system for filling seats based on dynamic pricing, due to the fact that the flight departures are timed and gated).
I'll try to find the article, it had numbers.
I read an article a while back about how Brightline chooses it's routes. I can't find the article at the moment, but I remember the CEO basically saying they made it work by being ruthless with strict parameters.
Specifically, Brightline won't build rail unless the following are all true:
1. The trip must be between 200 and 300 miles. Their research indicates this is the sweet spot between being more than a convenient car ride, but less then a convenient plane ride. I'll note that LA -> LV is ~180 miles, whereas LA -> SF is ~340 miles.
2. Leverage as much existing right-of-way as possible (The LA -> LV route follows the highway)
3. The market for consistent commuter travel between the destinations must pencil (Miami to Orlando / Disneyland, Los Angeles to Las Vegas)
I honestly think the US is so large and geographically diverse, you just need to be really picky when choosing high speed rail projects.
Also fun fact: I used to think that the biggest cost difference from flying vs rail travel was maintaining the rails. The biggest cost difference is actually the staff. Since flights are so much shorter and require less staff per seat, the per-hourly cost adds up.