I consciously avoid making up my mind after the first seconds or minutes (which is an atavistic reaction) but after an hour or so I usually have an idea of "no", "yes", "not sure" (for the "will fit in" perspective).
Since the teams are already quite diverse, there are no obvious bias that would pop up. I want to have people of all kinds (everyone can provide something different) so i am very open by definition. But I need to feel that they will be a good fit.
This is of course completely arbitrary and based on gut feelings.
I am not sure about which blindspots you have in mind, though?
Not trying to throw shade, but in my experience people who are confident that they have no bias usually do, often heaps of it, and are just not that much aware of it.
Especially when it comes to 'gut decisions' ('chemical fit'?).
Bias is human and we are all biased in one way or another. Saying that you’re not is a red flag, quite frankly, at least for me.
It has a lot with you behaving in a way that will be acceptable/enjoyable to the team.
This does not mean that you have to be like them! I have all kind of personalities in several teams and they differ vastly. The thing that binds them is that they like to spend their time at the office together (and for some of them - outside the office too).
Of course this is not measurable and some people are just a "chemical fit", and some others are not. This does not mean that there is something wrong with you (or them, or us) - we are just different in the way we want to be together.