News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by bambax on Saturday October 21, 2023 @06:02AM (#37965482)
Absolutely!

> “A Mexican person” is usually a man in a sombrero.

They are asking for an image of a Mexican person.

If the result shows an infant, or a person in a business attire in front of a glass building, or a construction worker, or someone competing in a bike race, how would we know they're "Mexican"?

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by TeMPOraL on Saturday October 21, 2023 @08:47AM (#37966388)
> They are asking for an image of a Mexican person.

Exactly. Even more so, they're asking for an image that is likely to be described as depicting a Mexican person. It should be obvious why, without additional detail in the prompt, the model will reach for features that'll make it obvious the person is a Mexican to a viewer with no other context - hence exaggerated stereotypes.

Artists do that too, all the time, if they want to communicate nationality in a "show, don't tell" way, and there is no other indicator in the image (such as location, or overall topic of the work).

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by cesaref on Saturday October 21, 2023 @09:42AM (#37966727)
https://www.pexels.com/search/mexican%20person/

Quite a bit of variety there, looks pretty mexican to me!

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by wavemode on Saturday October 21, 2023 @10:37AM (#37967130)
I would argue that one could complain about the vast majority of images on that page as also depicting some sort of Mexican stereotype.
Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by smugma on Saturday October 21, 2023 @11:32AM (#37967630)
Yes variety but lots of sombreros and maybe 50% dressed for day of the dead
Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by Terretta on Sunday October 22, 2023 @01:26PM (#37977316)
Indeed, your example explains what's going on perfectly.

Generative AI images are "plausible description generators" with a human in the loop.

They aren't trying to draw something, they're trying to get you to call what they draw something.

Given a prompt from a human, they produce an image likely to be labeled as such by a human.

"Well sure that's a Mexican person but I meant..." is not a valid caption.

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by kaffeeringe on Saturday October 21, 2023 @10:56AM (#37967300)
But a Mexican could be a man in a suit.

That is, what they say. If you ask midjourney for the image of a Mexican man it produces this cliche. Most Mexicans don't look like that. Most will be closed to the Mexican in a suit.

I think, the result would be more diverse if you look for stick photos of Mexicab men.

This example only shows, what you can expect from every other prompt: a bias for cliches.

And yes, you are right: that is, what you ask for in Midjourney.

But you should know, that it's always a cliche.

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by janalsncm on Saturday October 21, 2023 @03:05PM (#37969613)
> Most Mexicans don't look like that.

By definition this is true of any group. Most people do not look alike. There’s no way to have a single picture of what “most Mexicans” look like.

Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by Grimblewald on Sunday October 22, 2023 @02:34AM (#37973318)
So just ask for a man? if they should have tan skin, ask for that, if you need them to have latinx facial features, specify that. If you ask me, asking for it to generate 'a mexican man' is it self a little 'problematic' and so you get a slightly 'problematic' image in return. 'Racist' prompt in 'racist' prompt out you know?
Re:AI Reduces the World to Stereotypes by hn_acker on Saturday October 21, 2023 @10:24PM (#37972301)
> If the result shows an infant, or a person in a business attire in front of a glass building, or a construction worker, or someone competing in a bike race, how would we know they're "Mexican"?

If you asked an AI image generator for "a Mexican" and got back someone competing in a bike race, do you need to know that the person in the image is Mexican? Do you need to verify by doing a visual check for stereotypical features?

Or would it be good enough for you to just believe that the AI gave you "a Mexican" and hence accept the image as a valid answer to your prompt?