News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by jdietrich on Friday October 20, 2023 @04:47PM (#37961317)
America still has an outstanding amount of industrial capacity. That's not patriotic bluster, because I'm saying that as a European. There's a two-horse race between China and America to be the global industrial powerhouse and nobody else is even remotely close. The scale, sophistication and adaptability of American manufacturing still boggles the mind. Whether you believe it or not, America is still the same country that furnished the allies with Sherman tanks and Liberty ships.

America could start an Operation Warp Speed for 155mm shells and Stinger missiles, but there isn't yet the political will to do it. The DoD are still deeply entrenched in their leaden bureaucracy, they're still doing procurement in their usual way, their processes are still oriented around providing pork barrel jobs in key constituencies.

America isn't at war, but if it wants to remain a global superpower in an increasingly volatile world, it needs to adopt a wartime mindset when it comes to industrial strategy. You have the steel mills, you have the forging presses, you have the CNC lathes, but you don't have the sense of urgency to actually use them. That doesn't require legislation or a fundamental restructuring of the economy, it just requires a bit of creative thinking about procurement. With the stroke of a pen, your president could set the wheels in motion to rapidly replenish your arsenal and resume your role as the armoury of the free world.

For the sake of Ukraine, for the sake of Israel, for the sake of all of us, write to your representatives.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by cbozeman on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:00PM (#37961459)
It isn't a race. China's already lost and has no hope of winning. The reason you don't hear about it is because entirely too many people make entirely too much money pontificating over it.

China has the oldest population in the world. The highest youth unemployment rate in the developed world. Millions more men than young women to marry them to. A leader that "disappears" anyone who tells him something he doesn't want to hear.

They're done for and they've been done for, for some time. They have no chance to turn around their situation because the Chinese people are stridently - hilariously - racist and xenophobic. How could they not be? They're bombarded with propaganda nonstop from the CCP. Buying all the real estate in America they can, loading up on US Government bonds, and stealing all the IP in the world can't save them - because they don't have enough young people to keep it all going.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by gustavus on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:20PM (#37961687)
> he highest youth unemployment rate in the developed world. Millions more men than young women to marry them to

This is actually the most worrisome part for me. A bunch of young unemployed men who have no prospect of marriage and no real stake in society. That's the kind of thing that leads to some guy declaring himself Jesus's brother and starting a nasty civil war that kills 10 of millions, especially if it spills over into neighboring countries.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by miohtama on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:20PM (#37961686)
The US does not have supply chains to to dominate anymore. Even if China's authorianship is a massive issue for everyone except CCP, they have the manufacturing base. No one can compete. It's almost twice as United States where, as the article points out, capital is allocated to inefficient stock buybacks.

Top 10 manufacturing countries in the world

China – 28.4% Global

United States – 16.6% Global Manufacturing Output

Japan – 7.5% Global Manufacturing Output

Germany – 5.8% Global

Furthermore, the life expectancy in the US is nosediving. It has massive internal problems not only on the health of its people but political coherence, which needs to be fixed before the US can get back to the growth track.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by feoren on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:23PM (#37961714)
> China has the oldest population in the world.

Source for this? Monaco and Japan have the highest median age in the world, at 55.4 and 47.3 years, respectively; the United States is 62nd at 38.5 years, with China just below at 38.4. What do you mean when you say China has the oldest population in the world?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_median_ag...

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by floxy on Friday October 20, 2023 @06:36PM (#37962248)
The OP might be referring to the fact that there are 200+ million people in China over the age of 65, meaning they have the most seniors of any country in the world, even if this is a smaller fraction of their total population than Japan.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/250753/number-of-people-...

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by spiralx on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:20PM (#37962579)
Although this issue is why the next five or six years is basically China's only window for trying to seize Taiwan, and its leadership is not so crazy as to not know that, but possibly crazy enough to think that acting on it is a good idea while they can.
Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by mike_d on Friday October 20, 2023 @04:59PM (#37961445)
> America still has an outstanding amount of industrial capacity.

Small arms ammunition manufacturing is controlled by a very small number of players that are incentivized to keep production capacity low.

There is enough production to meet government demand, but law enforcement and civilian markets are seen as a pure profit center since ammo is an at-any-price purchase. Shortages fuel increased demand and higher prices, while production costs stay flat.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by Workaccount2 on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:09PM (#37961567)
A huge problem is enticing people to take on skilled work in manufacturing.

If you like problem solving, yeah blue collar work can fill that void in spades...but so can sitting on a laptop in your living room spinning code and getting paid way more.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by nojvek on Saturday October 21, 2023 @02:39AM (#37964619)
The thing with manufacturing, at-least in the US is that it is very capital intensive.

Doves of undergrads applying to YC get funded for SaaS apps, but only a few startups building hardware.

The money isn’t there from investment or returns.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by schneems on Friday October 20, 2023 @04:51PM (#37961351)
> Operation Warp Speed

I know you’re using this as as example. It has me curious though:

I feel like this wasn’t a failure, but also could have been a lot more successful. This is just a gut feel, has there been any good quantitative retrospectives on operation warp speed?

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by zdragnar on Friday October 20, 2023 @04:57PM (#37961421)
Aside from the effectiveness of the vaccine, and reluctance to take it, what would you like about it to have been more effective?

What would normally have taken years took less than one- from research to production of hundreds of millions of units.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by schneems on Friday October 20, 2023 @06:21PM (#37962145)
That’s why I’m asking for a retrospective. What went well? What could be better?
Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by zdragnar on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:01PM (#37962439)
You said you felt it could have gone better. I just now noticed that you qualified that as a gut feeling.

I'd assumed there was something specific that you felt wasn't done well.

For my money's worth, I would have preferred that government officials were more honest- especially fauci.

The whole escalation of what percentage was needed for herd immunity (they knew the initial numbers they talked about were too low), the threats that Grandma would die at Thanksgiving if you didn't get it (despite it not actually preventing spread) and the assertion that it was totally safe (despite causing myocarditis in young men, about 50% or more with permanent heart damage according to a new study).

Yes, COVID was terrible, and people needed to take steps to avoid getting it. The dishonesty surrounding what those steps were (and what we did vs did not know) made making informed decisions impossible.

https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.123.0...

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by claytongulick on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:18PM (#37961668)
I'm trying to think what the missile equivalent of Operation Warp Speed would be?

100% effective missiles that no one wants to shoot, don't require thorough testing, launch in unpredictable directions, and when they detonate have surprise effects depending on the target?

Sometimes they explode!

Other times, maybe deliver a nice cup of tea, or a burst of roses.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by yogthos on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:17PM (#37961655)
What a lot of people don't seem to realize is that manufacturing accounts for only around 11% of the GDP in US

https://www.statista.com/statistics/248004/percentage-added-...

We can look at steel production volumes to get an idea of the size of the productive industry in US. According to official data, US produced 6.8 million metric tons of steel in June this year https://www.trade.gov/data-visualization/us-steel-executive-...

This is comparable to Russia, which produced 5.8 million metric tons https://www.statista.com/statistics/1079878/russia-steel-pro...

US might be the most industrialized western economy, but turns out it’s steel production is only slightly higher than in Russia. And it’s important to keep in mind that Russia has a much smaller population, so per capita production is actually higher than in US.

Meanwhile, China where 90 million metric tons of steel is produced in a month https://www.reuters.com/markets/asia/china-june-crude-steel-...

China’s productive industry is a whole order of magnitude larger than US. This shows just how absurd the notion that US is in some sort of meaningful competition with China. It's like an ant by comparison.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by gustavus on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:28PM (#37961759)
Yes but all the steel production in the world may not help when you're ports are blockaded and your country is no longer able to feed it's citizens. Remember Germany was close to the top of the world in manufacture and population in 1914, but that didn't do it a lick of good when it's citizens were starving in 1918.
Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by yogthos on Friday October 20, 2023 @05:39PM (#37961859)
If you ever look at a map, you'll realize that China has plenty of trade routes through Eurasia. This is literally the whole idea behind the BRI initiative. China can ship goods to the majority of the world without relying on shipping.

However, it's also absolutely laughable to think that US could actually blockade China effectively. Every single war game that the Pentagon ran against China they lost decisively.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by spiralx on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:26PM (#37962623)
LOL, almost all of China's oil supply runs through the Straits of Malacca which the US Navy could blockade with a carrier fleet and a few submarines. Why do you think they've been so heavily focussed on building relationships (and pipelines) with Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan and Russia and building up their deep water navy in the South China Sea?
Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by yogthos on Saturday October 21, 2023 @07:46AM (#37966014)
I think you've answered your own question here. Russia is one of the biggest oil suppliers, and they're building another big pipeline as we speak

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/russia-finalising-po...

It's not clear how US plans to block oil supply going forward here. Also, worth noting that unlike the west, China is taking alternative energy seriously. China is far ahead in terms of using renewable energy

https://www.reuters.com/markets/commodities/china-widens-ren...

They're also massively investing in nuclear https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2021-11-02/china-cli...

So, China's reliance on fossil fuels is going to keep decreasing going forward, and that will make it that much easier to fill the gap from friendly countries where US can't interfere.

Finally, it's kind of silly to think that this is a one way street. If US ever did decide to try and blockade China, it's obvious that China would retaliate. We're already seeing this with the whole chip war right now where China has stopped export of Germanium and Gallium. https://www.channelnewsasia.com/business/china-export-curbs-...

Given how dependent US economy is on China, the blowback from any sort of blockade of China would do incredible damage domestically in the US.

Re:Why America Is Out of Ammunition by spiralx on Friday October 27, 2023 @05:24PM (#38044179)
As of 2021 Russia supplied 15% of China's oil and 6% of it's natural gas, and those pipelines are a) for gas, not oil, and b) increase from 38 Bcm to 88 Bcm, while total imports via pipe are 2,000 Bcm, which c) doesn't account for LNG imports via ship.

https://www.eia.gov/international/analysis/country/CHN

In other words, Russian pipelines supply very little of China's energy needs, and that's not going to change anytime soon. The only thing that could really change that is global warming enabling Russia to ship fossil fuels from its north coast to China.