News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by snapcaster on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:13AM (#37943987)
So should we stop eating fruit? what's the actionable takeaway here for someone already avoiding high-fructose corn syrup?
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by BiteCode_dev on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:18AM (#37944080)
Fruits contains a lot of dietary fibers which lower the side-effect of fructose.

Also, fructose itself is not in such a high dose in an apple, you are far away from fructose syrup concentration which was added to everything pretty much at the same time the obesity epidemic has started.

Finally, fruits contains a lot of other beneficial nutrients, so benefits outweigh the harm fructose can do to you.

We metabolize fructose fine in reasonable doses and with fiber. It has been part of our diet for thousands of years.

It's not just the fructose. Any raw sugar is bound to have nasty-side effects. Our wheat flour is too processed, so the bread and pasta is not great for us as well. But a bit of whole pasta and bread will not spike your insulin level much.

We are, as usual, overdoing it.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by valenceelectron on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:24AM (#37944167)
It's unfortunate naming similar to "fat". Most fruits are really not that high in fructose, compared to stuff like high-fructose corn syrup (well, it's in the name) that's widely added to beverages and other processed food.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by vel0city on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:53AM (#37944576)
The fructose-glucose ratio of a lot of apples is almost 2:1. HFCS is usually 45-55% fructose. Watermelon has a similar ratio. Lots of fruits have a higher fructose to glucose ratio.

HFCS is called high-fructose not because its some incredibly high level of fructose compared to most everything else, its because compared to regular corn syrup it is high. Regular corn syrup is nearly 100% glucose, so a mixture of 45% or 55% fructose is extremely high in that context. Table sugar is 1:1 fructose/glucose, but we don't call it high-fructose table sugar.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by everybodyknows on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:36PM (#37945110)
[delayed]
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by vel0city on Thursday October 19, 2023 @01:22PM (#37945729)
I don't doubt there's a lot of metabolic differences between sucrose and HFCS. Given they're free instead of bound I imagine it hits the body differently, and some studies do suggest this. Gastric acidity easily breaks the bond though, it rapidly converts to glucose and fructose in the gut. So I imagine most changes would be with our body's early detection in the eating process, such as the taste buds and other senses like that.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by vel0city on Thursday October 19, 2023 @03:38PM (#37947652)
I realize I never really answered your other question. Its tricky sticking the two sugars back together into sucrose, as heating it will generally carmelize it. After all, when you carmelize sucrose you're breaking that bond and oxidizing the glucose and fructose, so heating HFCS will ultimately yield the same thing in an oxygen environment. You'll generally need some kind of chemical process to link it together, it takes a bit of extra energy to join the two sugars back together.

Sucrose will hydrolize and break apart in water on its own, but it does take some time. Adding a little bit of acid will rapidly break it apart.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by BiteCode_dev on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:58AM (#37944647)
It's not the ratio that hurts you but the absolute dose you ingest.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by vel0city on Thursday October 19, 2023 @01:06PM (#37945513)
They were probably talking ratio, not total amount.

> Most fruits are really not that high in fructose, compared to stuff like high-fructose corn syrup

An apple is going to have like 19g of sugar. So a little over 12g of fructose. A serving of Buffalo Wild Wings Asian Zing sauce (2tbs) has 19g of sugar. I don't know what variety of HFCS, so we'll assume HFCS 55. That's 10.45g fructose.

So an apple has more fructose (total) than a few buffalo wings with HFCS-based sauce.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by valenceelectron on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:59PM (#37945408)
HFCS is available in ratios with up to 90% fructose. Granted, I don't know what the average is in the food industry. But like other commenters said, it's mostly about the absolute amount. You can't realistically eat enough apples to reach a fructose intake equivalent to that of a sugary drink. And even if you do, you also ate lots of fiber and other good nutrients.

Therefore, worrying about fruits because of fructose is unwarranted. Well unless you have fructose intolerance.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by vel0city on Thursday October 19, 2023 @01:14PM (#37945624)
> Granted, I don't know what the average is in the food industry

The average is usually 45-55. By far the most common variety is HFCS-55.

I'm not disagreeing with the idea its easier to pound a lot of sugar drinking sweet beverages. I'm just disagreeing with the concept "fruits don't have much fructose" and people thinking HFCS means its generally way higher fructose content than other common sugars. An apple has more fructose than a serving of BWW Asian Zing sauce, as I pointed out in another comment. I'm not arguing wings are healthier than apples, I'm just pointing out the raw numbers of sugar. A cake made with sucrose will have a similar amount of fructose ratio as cake made with HFCS, assuming similar amounts of total sugar content.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by esperent on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:46AM (#37944496)
Would taking a fiber supplement or some psyllium before eating sugary snacks help, I wonder?
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by BiteCode_dev on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:00PM (#37944667)
Measure your blood insulin level while doing so and you'll get the answer.

Works for me to eat a banana before I eat white pasta: I get less tired.

YMMV. But it's always better to stick to healthier meals if you can.

I know I can't. I got a sweet tooth.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by gruez on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:59AM (#37944657)
> Fruits contains a lot of dietary fibers which lower the side-effect of fructose.

Are they actually mitigating the side effects, or adding bulk/satiety so you don't eat as much? It's unclear how dietary fibers mitigates the following:

>fructose reduces the active energy (adenosine triphosphate) in the cell, while blocking its regeneration from fat stores. This is mediated by intracellular uric acid, mitochondrial oxidative stress, the inhibition of AMP kinase and stimulation of vasopressin. Mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation is suppressed, and glycolysis stimulated.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by BiteCode_dev on Thursday October 19, 2023 @01:02PM (#37945460)
Mitigating. They slow down fructose absorption, and nourish the macrobiotic that in return also help.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:23AM (#37944154)
Nobody is saying that; it's not an either/or, or a dichotomy. The issue, as always, lies in overconsumption.

Part of that is down to manufacturers, who especially in the US put loads of sugar in pretty much everything. Part of that is down to the consumer, which chooses convenience over awareness; part of that is things like take-out or drinking culture, but part of that is also diet culture, a diet telling you "stop eating this, only eat that". That too is convenience.

As is calling certain foods "healthy" vs "unhealthy", because that's no absolute either, and it's a lazy descriptor - as in, "please explain to me why it is healthy / unhealthy". The crux of it is, nothing is healthy or unhealthy unless it's literal poison, it's more about calorific content and quantities.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by boredpeter on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:56AM (#37944622)
You can’t seriously be blaming consumers for this. It’s not consumers’ job to be scientists and understand whether some factory made ultra processed food is good for them or not. This is entirely because the government is bought and paid for by capitalists that lobby it to allow large corporations to sell garbage to people.

The solution is a simple number on food (1-100) that tells a consumer how healthy (or not) a product is and takes into account caloric content, additivies, sugar content, etc. This is something the government should be doing but since the US is governed by radical conservatives that are immensely corrupt it’s likely not going to happen. There is an app I’ve recently started using called Yuka that does this.

I’m also not opposed to banning certain categories of unhealthy products entirely.

Your point about overconsumption is valid but again, I don’t believe this is the fault of consumers, this is just a result of the capitalist system which encourages overconsumption in order to keep the system from falling apart.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by gruez on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:02PM (#37944693)
>The solution is a simple number on food (1-100) that tells a consumer [...]

What's the evidence on interventions like this? We tried adding calorie counts on packaging and menus, but obesity rates are still going up.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by dopidopHN on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:59PM (#37945409)
Nutriscore exists since a while in France. It’s rate food from A to F.

Not sure of the utility of that.

But I rely very much on the calorie count!

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by danaris on Thursday October 19, 2023 @12:54PM (#37945343)
This makes the demonstrably false assumption that what's good for you, today, is good for everybody, all the time.

Different bodies need different things, and no single dumbed-down number like that can ever take that into account.

What we need is better ways of making clear just what those needs are to people, which ultimately comes down to better education. Is it a quick solution? Absolutely not. But it's the only one that can genuinely help people to improve their own health through nutrition.

That said, we can also improve our regulation around these things based on the best science we have available, to do things like ban or require labeling and appropriate disclosure of substances that are known to be universally or commonly harmful.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by stuff4ben on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:26AM (#37944200)
Not fruit, but rather fructose and other diets contributing to fructose production. In the article and linked abstract (in a comment here), it said "process is initiated by the ingestion of fructose or by stimulating endogenous fructose production via the polyol pathway". I was curious about the "polyol pathway" and found this other study on "endogenous fructose production", https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6684314/.

Key takeaways: also avoid high glycemic and high salt diets. Basically avoid fast-food. Make your own meals. Eat less or no heavily processed foods. Watch your sugar and salt intake. Keep staying away from HFCS or corn syrup in general.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by panarky on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:27AM (#37944221)
Apples, grapes, pears, and watermelon are particularly high in fructose. You could substitute low-fructose fruits like berries, cantaloupe, and oranges.

Many "healthy" snacks and desserts don't want HFCS on their labels so they use cane sugar, but that's a mix of glucose and fructose.

And foods with a high glycemic index like white bread, potatoes, and rice might stimulate endogenous fructose production.

You might think this study exonerates paleo diets, but there's evidence that excessive protein intake may contribute to gluconeogenesis, potentially increasing fructose production endogenously.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by taeric on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:32AM (#37944299)
And even though apples are high in it, you have to eat a silly number of them to get the same sugar as in one drink.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by bentt on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:28AM (#37944239)
Stop drinking a lot of fruit juice. We are outsmarting nature's packaging by doing that. Eat the whole fruit and the fiber comes along with it.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by imjonse on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:29AM (#37944261)
No, but we should probably stop eating or cut back seriously on cookies, cakes, and other non-fruit sources of sugar.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by oldgradstudent on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:16AM (#37944030)
Avoid sugar, regardless of whether it is added sugar or not.

Sucrose is effectively 50% fructose.

And the supposed benefits of fruits are pretty much non-existent.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by Cthulhu_ on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:24AM (#37944165)
This is lazy either/or thinking; sugars are fine, excess sugar causes issues over a longer timespan.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by oldgradstudent on Thursday October 19, 2023 @07:57PM (#37950420)
That's a tautological statement.

Excess of anything is harmful by definition (otherwise it is not in excess).

The only question is how much is too much.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by r2_pilot on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:19AM (#37944102)
Fruits, when consumed in moderation, also contain fiber and phytonutrients, hardly non-existent benefits.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by oldgradstudent on Thursday October 19, 2023 @07:54PM (#37950407)
Humans can thrive on meat alone without any problem.

No fiber and no phytonutrients. The supposed benefits of both are basically hypotheses with really crappy observational data to support them.

Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by r2_pilot on Friday October 20, 2023 @07:54AM (#37954938)
If anyone is still reading this, I would not suggest taking dietary advice from this poster. Talk to a nutritionist about your specific needs instead.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by nirav72 on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:20AM (#37944109)
Even citrus fruits for Vitamin-C?
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by oldgradstudent on Thursday October 19, 2023 @07:50PM (#37950373)
There are plenty of sources for vitamin C, and there are better sources for significantly less sugar.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by devmor on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:22AM (#37944148)
tl;dr - Limit processed sugars, eat significant amounts of fiber.
Re:Fructose is the main culprit of the obesity epidemic, stu... by 876978095789789 on Friday October 20, 2023 @12:17AM (#37952334)
No: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6518666/

> Conclusions: Current evidence suggests that whole, fresh fruit consumption is unlikely to contribute to excess energy intake and adiposity, but rather has little effect on these outcomes or constrains them modestly. Single-meal RCTs, RCTs lasting 3–24 weeks, and long-term observational studies are relatively consistent in supporting this conclusion. Whole, fresh fruit probably does not contribute to obesity and may have a place in the prevention and management of excess adiposity.