News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by lilboiluvr69 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:40PM (#37933713)
Not to be that guy but why is a fictional depiction of porn different than a fictional depiction of anything else? What makes sex so special?

If I made fake porn of Donald Trump under your explanation, that is considered sexual assault, even if I tell everyone it is fake. Why?

Would making a parody video of Donald Trump getting beaten up also be considered assault?

Would making a parody video of the pope denouncing god be considered the same?

I'm sure all three are genuinely offensive. I'm just trying to understand, maybe its because I have a background growing up in a clothing optional community and being in poly relationships so I just have a much less taboo view of sexuality. But how can a fake video of someone that everyone knows is fake by itself be assault? It sounds like you just want it to be illegal because it offends you.

Instead of making it illegal to generate AI porn of celebrities, maybe we should examine our culture and why we see sexualization as so threatening. Why do we freak out if our kids see two people having sex but don't blink an eye when they see violence in movies?

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by almatabata on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:51PM (#37933867)
Most countries have exemptions around satire. If you did not you could not do things like puppet shows for example. Hence you could distribute any AI generated image if it looks like satire. With porn however you have no such exemptions, as such the copyright law applies and you cannot simply duplicate somebodies likeness without their explicit approval.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:32PM (#37934395)
> the copyright law applies and you cannot simply duplicate somebodies likeness

In many countries (like the US), someone's likeness is not covered by copyright law in the first place (in some US jurisdictions, publicity/personality rights may apply, but these are state-law rights and more likely to apply to people, e.g. celebrities, with already-commercialized identities, and against commercial use; they are much more limited than copyright rights.)

For porn/nudes specifically, revenge porn laws (which mostly are aimed at unauthorized release of actual imagery of the targeted kind, but aren’t always narrowly crafted) might also apply.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:33PM (#37934402)
> If I made fake porn of Donald Trump under your explanation, that is considered sexual assault, even if I tell everyone it is fake. Why?

Because, as I said, you are using someone's likeness to make sexually explicit material without their consent. What are you not understanding here?

> Would making a parody video of Donald Trump getting beaten up also be considered assault?

No.

> Would making a parody video of the pope denouncing god be considered the same?

No.

> I'm sure all three are genuinely offensive.

It being offensive isn't the problem.

> I'm just trying to understand, maybe its because I have a background growing up in a clothing optional community and being in poly relationships so I just have a much less taboo view of sexuality. But how can a fake video of someone that everyone knows is fake by itself be assault?

I am also poly (though never been clothing optional) but the problem is the "if" in your statement there, if everyone knows it's fake, that's doing a hell of a lot of heavy lifting there. Do we know it's fake? Will we know the next model version of it is fake? If it is perfectly, completely realistically rendered, which as I understand it, is plus or minus the goal of generative art, to be completely and totally realistic?

We have a whole ass 63% of the United States who think angels are real, and that's based on nothing but the bible and indoctrination, do you think it's that big of a stretch for them to think that video of Trump pounding Obama in the backside is real, even if Obama has six fingers?

> Instead of making it illegal to generate AI porn of celebrities, maybe we should examine our culture and why we see sexualization as so threatening. Why do we freak out if our kids see two people having sex but don't blink an eye when they see violence in movies?

It's not about sex being threatening, it's about sex requiring informed, understood, and enthusiastic consent. Because if you don't own your own fucking face anymore, what do you own? If you can't even hold your own private bare ass naked form as something that is yours, only yours, and something no one else may have access to without your consent, what can you even say you do own anymore?

I posit the exact opposite question: why is it you are entitled to make pornography featuring the absolutely stunning likeness of Emma Watson? Because she's a "public figure?" Simply because you have the capability?