News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @02:55PM (#37933060)
Not to change drastically from the subject matter of the original article, but I think really the most troubling thing to me listed here is how willing many men are to interacting with openly fake AI accounts on these apps. And this is not meant at all to mock these men, I'm genuinely concerned for the welfare of the kind of man who is so deprived and isolated of attention that he's ready to swipe his credit card for an AI-powered chat-bot with generated titties to tell him it loves him. It makes me think of all the Replika users who got (somewhat rightfully I feel) pissed off when they paywalled erotic/romantic engagement. Again, not judgement. Pity. I feel bad for these people who are so without any kind of social connections and/or the ability to get them that chat bots feel like their only options.

There are so many social sicknesses here that technical and market solutions are attempting to band-aid and it's genuinely depressing.

Also as an aside, using real people's faces for deepfake pornography should be prosecuted just like any other kind of sexual assault with similar consequences. That shit is disgusting and I will not respond to any comment saying otherwise, I don't care if you didn't actually touch her, or whatever excuse you have on offer. You have created exploitative material of a sexual nature without consent, that's assault, period, paragraph.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by lilboiluvr69 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:40PM (#37933713)
Not to be that guy but why is a fictional depiction of porn different than a fictional depiction of anything else? What makes sex so special?

If I made fake porn of Donald Trump under your explanation, that is considered sexual assault, even if I tell everyone it is fake. Why?

Would making a parody video of Donald Trump getting beaten up also be considered assault?

Would making a parody video of the pope denouncing god be considered the same?

I'm sure all three are genuinely offensive. I'm just trying to understand, maybe its because I have a background growing up in a clothing optional community and being in poly relationships so I just have a much less taboo view of sexuality. But how can a fake video of someone that everyone knows is fake by itself be assault? It sounds like you just want it to be illegal because it offends you.

Instead of making it illegal to generate AI porn of celebrities, maybe we should examine our culture and why we see sexualization as so threatening. Why do we freak out if our kids see two people having sex but don't blink an eye when they see violence in movies?

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by almatabata on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:51PM (#37933867)
Most countries have exemptions around satire. If you did not you could not do things like puppet shows for example. Hence you could distribute any AI generated image if it looks like satire. With porn however you have no such exemptions, as such the copyright law applies and you cannot simply duplicate somebodies likeness without their explicit approval.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:32PM (#37934395)
> the copyright law applies and you cannot simply duplicate somebodies likeness

In many countries (like the US), someone's likeness is not covered by copyright law in the first place (in some US jurisdictions, publicity/personality rights may apply, but these are state-law rights and more likely to apply to people, e.g. celebrities, with already-commercialized identities, and against commercial use; they are much more limited than copyright rights.)

For porn/nudes specifically, revenge porn laws (which mostly are aimed at unauthorized release of actual imagery of the targeted kind, but aren’t always narrowly crafted) might also apply.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:33PM (#37934402)
> If I made fake porn of Donald Trump under your explanation, that is considered sexual assault, even if I tell everyone it is fake. Why?

Because, as I said, you are using someone's likeness to make sexually explicit material without their consent. What are you not understanding here?

> Would making a parody video of Donald Trump getting beaten up also be considered assault?

No.

> Would making a parody video of the pope denouncing god be considered the same?

No.

> I'm sure all three are genuinely offensive.

It being offensive isn't the problem.

> I'm just trying to understand, maybe its because I have a background growing up in a clothing optional community and being in poly relationships so I just have a much less taboo view of sexuality. But how can a fake video of someone that everyone knows is fake by itself be assault?

I am also poly (though never been clothing optional) but the problem is the "if" in your statement there, if everyone knows it's fake, that's doing a hell of a lot of heavy lifting there. Do we know it's fake? Will we know the next model version of it is fake? If it is perfectly, completely realistically rendered, which as I understand it, is plus or minus the goal of generative art, to be completely and totally realistic?

We have a whole ass 63% of the United States who think angels are real, and that's based on nothing but the bible and indoctrination, do you think it's that big of a stretch for them to think that video of Trump pounding Obama in the backside is real, even if Obama has six fingers?

> Instead of making it illegal to generate AI porn of celebrities, maybe we should examine our culture and why we see sexualization as so threatening. Why do we freak out if our kids see two people having sex but don't blink an eye when they see violence in movies?

It's not about sex being threatening, it's about sex requiring informed, understood, and enthusiastic consent. Because if you don't own your own fucking face anymore, what do you own? If you can't even hold your own private bare ass naked form as something that is yours, only yours, and something no one else may have access to without your consent, what can you even say you do own anymore?

I posit the exact opposite question: why is it you are entitled to make pornography featuring the absolutely stunning likeness of Emma Watson? Because she's a "public figure?" Simply because you have the capability?

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by OfSanguineFire on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:13PM (#37933330)
Those sad men aren't necessarily interacting with AI-powered chat bots. OnlyFans models have been outsourcing their chatting with fans to workers in the developing world for years now. As anglophone countries, Nigeria and Kenya have been able to draw a lot of this outsourcing, and the person pretending to be the model is male probably more often than not.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:17PM (#37933390)
I mean, even the "best" version of this is men ready to put down money to interact with a performer which is some combination of AI/exploited overseas worker/exploited sex worker to attempt via the only way they see as viable to fill the yawning chasm of loneliness in their souls. That's still depressing.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by resolutebat on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:49PM (#37933854)
How exactly is the sex worker masterminding the operation being exploited?
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:41PM (#37934490)
I mean, in a perfect world, sex workers would choose sex work because it's work they wanted to do. However there are numerous factors that complicate this:

1) The existence of sex pests like Andrew Tate who openly recruit and exploit young women into working for them as adult performers

2) The socio-economic realities of where a given person grows up and is raised in, which greatly affects their prospects in life in general which may artificially make sex work a more appealing option

3) The overarching threat of starvation which may force someone with literally no other options to do it, lest they end up homeless and freeze to death.

This is where some feminists and "anti-porn" activists have problems with it, because in an exploitative system that demands you work in some way to survive, there is an argument to be made that no sex work can be truly thought to be entirely devoid of some form of coercion, and therefore the sex involved in that sex work cannot, in turn, be entirely devoid of coercion, which makes it, by definition, rape. I don't particularly subscribe to that belief as I believe it trivializes the free will and agency of performers, but like, I also can't entirely say that it's incorrect. I see the bones of the reasoning and it does make sense to me, and there surely are a ton, an absolutely stressful amount of sex workers out there right now, who are doing it because it is the only path to a decent quality of life available to them (or worse, their sole method of survival due to systemic or more direct threats). And if I found out a given performer who's content I enjoy was one of those people, I can't say I wouldn't be uncomfortable with it.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by brazzy on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @04:55PM (#37934644)
> This is where some feminists and "anti-porn" activists have problems with it, because in an exploitative system that demands you work in some way to survive, there is an argument to be made that no sex work can be truly thought to be entirely devoid of some form of coercion, and therefore the sex involved in that sex work cannot, in turn, be entirely devoid of coercion, which makes it, by definition, rape.

The part where they completely discredit themselves is where they (almost invariably) draw from this the conclusion that paying for sex work must be made illegal.

If women turn to sex work as the only available means to survive, how exactly does it help them to take away that option?

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @06:10PM (#37935453)
> The part where they completely discredit themselves is where they (almost invariably) draw from this the conclusion that paying for sex work must be made illegal.

Agreed.

> If women turn to sex work as the only available means to survive, how exactly does it help them to take away that option?

Well I don't think the goal is to help them, I think the goal is to take away the ability for people to pay to rape them with legal cover. Like it's one thing for sex workers to be selling access to their bodies if it's under the table and illegal, even technically. It's quite another for the justice system of your particular country to go on the record and, in writing, state that you are allowed to coerce sex from another person in exchange for money. And like, again, I don't entirely disagree with that, if you accept the underlying logic that goes:

- Anything done for survival is coerced

- Sex work for survival is therefore coerced

- Sex during sex work done for survival is coerced sex

- Coerced sex is rape

- Therefore, no sex work done within a system where it is required for survival is consensual.

Like, there is a there there. It's uncomfortable but I can't argue it down. Making it illegal surely doesn't help them, but making it entirely legal means you are basically legalizing the ability for people with money to rape women who cannot say no, lest they starve to death. And like... that doesn't feel great either.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by lilboiluvr69 on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @08:17PM (#37936606)
Under this argument wouldn't any type of paid labor be coercive? Hell, it seems like any interpersonal activity in a capitalistic society be considered coercive since every activity is just X number of steps away from 'survival'.
Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @11:26PM (#37937979)
I mean, you say that like it isn't a well-worn meme that people loathe the companies they work for but have no real choice to get different jobs. I know dozens of people who work for companies they believe are actively worsening the world because they literally don't have a choice. If they quit, they would die. And that's just like, the basic money problem. If you happen to be in the United States, your ability to access healthcare is also extremely tightly tied to your employment status.

Would anyone at all work food service if the alternative wasn't starvation? I don't know a single person who's worked that sort of job that would do it if they didn't need to to eat, not because it's antithetical to the human experience to serve food, but because it pays like garbage and the customers treat you like shit.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by brazzy on Thursday October 19, 2023 @04:50PM (#37948543)
I don't care for all that "logic" which is not logical at all, just a bullshit attempt to avoid confronting that reality doesn't work the way you wish it would and you have no way to change that.

>Well I don't think the goal is to help them, I think the goal is to take away the ability for people to pay to rape them with legal cover.

In other words: you are willing to make life worse for people in order to protect your own sensibilities.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by ToucanLoucan on Thursday October 19, 2023 @11:31PM (#37952107)
> I don't care for all that "logic" which is not logical at all, just a bullshit attempt to avoid confronting that reality doesn't work the way you wish it would and you have no way to change that.

I am so very curious which part of this is breaking with reality in your mind. But given you aren't refuting any particular assertion I'm guessing you're just uncomfortable with the conclusion and don't have a logical refutation for any part of it, so you're just discarding it.

To be clear, I do not fully agree with this either which I spelled out quite plainly above. I'm just saying I do understand how they get to the point they're at, which like, you're allowed to do that. You're allowed to understand why people think a certain way without agreeing with it, but just saying "well that's not how reality works!" as though our modern world, legal system and basis of governance was handed down to us by the Almighty on Mount Sinai is the epitome of intellectual cowardice. Most everything about our "reality" is malleable should we will it.

> In other words: you are willing to make life worse for people in order to protect your own sensibilities.

I literally outlined that I don't agree with this conclusion because I feel it discards too much of the given sex worker's autonomy! I am completely fine with sex work, as long as it's safe for all involved.

Re:Inside the booming AI-generated porn industry by OfSanguineFire on Wednesday October 18, 2023 @03:56PM (#37933932)
It’s not always the sex worker masterminding the operation. Especially in Eastern Europe and Southeast Asia, the models are often under the exploitive control of pimps, and it is the pimps who outsource the model’s chatting for the sake of greater income.