This comes across as rude, especially in response to someone that did not themselves say anything warranting a rude response. You can disagree and make your point without doing this. I'm pointing it out because you genuinely may not be aware and I want to give the benefit of doubt (something I myself too often do not do online).
The only universally used tech on this list is SSL, because end users don't need to "install SSL and learn to use it" - we had to put in the work to upgrade or shitty servers, and they get the benefits.
Time had proven that the "don't you care about your privacy" argument doesn't work, so it's up to us to make the privacy-respecting tools better than the alternatives
If you're of above average intelligence, remember that you're likely biased to assume the average person is more intelligent than they actually are.
To me, the sociological aspect is in the way we act together as a society, helping others do what we think is good, providing support. Not simply how one is expected to somehow learn and do everything out of nowhere.
The decentralized nature of the technologies mentioned contributes substantially to their resilience. Re-centralizing them opens new avenues of attack and new targets to silence and corrupt for the state.
All kinds of technical difficulties can be fixed with effort and talent of a few people, but if something requires will of the masses and there's a lack of will, that thing is simply not going to happen no matter what you do - because there's no "just" with respect to lack of will, that's lack of something necessary that you can't easily create.
Yes, I agree that everyone should have access to those technologies by default. I also think that the implementation for the layperson will make the projects almost unrecognizable.
E.g., People for whom significant, immediate, unexpected mechanical feedback in operating something simple, like window blinds, wouldn't cause them to consider whether they might be doing something wrong, and instead continue operariting the blinds in the wrong direction until they snap and break, genuinely being unaware that they were doing it wrong.
People who are genuinely lacking the common sense you'd expect a human to have, not even with any cognitive disability or learning disorder of any kind - just genuinely stupid but otherwise ordinary people.
Ironically, that's a stupid assumption to have. You might be in your own bubble, but I know many very intelligent people who do not have the time or interest in gaining digital privacy. It's not as easy or without compromise as you seem to think.
People who care will figure it out, and those who don't will be left behind.
But no, thats not acceptable because you have to gouge everyone to make as much money as possible nowadays.
I often have trouble convincing people to install Signal, which requires about two minutes for people who barely know how to use their smartphones and under one for people who know where the app store is. If a majority people don't have the motivation to do that much, we have a very uphill battle.
People who care will figure it out, and those who don't will be left behind. Is that not the case for most of history? Atleast apps as you say are accessible to everyone without them having to invest a second thought.
Why should the average joe have to consider a second thought? If my Dad wants to watch his favourite TV show, he should be able to do that in the most accessible way possible.
Perhaps Microsoft shouldn't have built a GUI and should've kept the CMD line around so that we would've all had to learn to "do it the hard way" and wouldn't have been infantilizing us with buttons, graphics, file explorers, hyperlinks and applications.
This lack of ability to be able to control your emotions undercuts my ability to take the rest of the comment seriously at all. It's not any kind of seriously considered rational comment, weighing the pros and cons of the thoughts presented -- it's bad commentary.
If those tools cease to require arcance incantations and work seamlessly like every other thing everyone else is already using, then I don't think it's unrealistic at all.
The fact is that developers very (very) rarely have to interface directly with TLS or the Signal protocol, yet billions of non-technical users implicitly use them in our browsers and via Signal or WhatsApp.
In my view, the challenge in the adoption of secure/private-by-design tech is the simplicity and usability of the interfaces and the capabilities these tools provide.
We need secure tools to compete on capability in order to garner mass usage. Without (significant) feature superiority there's little reason for users to make the switch. I'm actively trying to solve some of these problems at Backbone [0]; aiming to build a usable, secure experience for end users and a simple, robust end-to-end-encryption interface for developers.
Problem is – if you can't trust any server, end-to-end encryption naturally often leads to feature inferiority in the context of multi-device usage.
At some point, going to the moon was unrealistic. Right now, ending wars is unrealistic, but it's also absolutely necessary.
However, that doesn't mean it can't be a gradual process that takes years or generations even.
> We should all use PGP, SSL or equivalent tools; VPNs, Tor and/or SSH tunnelling; IPFS, or other distributed file systems — and ditch proprietary OS's in favour of Linux or truly free Android distros... Those tools and techniques should cease to be arcane nice-to-haves for nerds: we must get more non-technical people onboard.
This is so unrealistic and impractical, it undercuts my ability to take the rest of the piece seriously at all. It's not any kind of seriously considered ethical analysis, weighing the pros and cons of what's actually best or most effective in the real world -- it's a pipe dream.