(And if it were an "independent" agency like statistics are in some countries, that would provide more shielding but not necessarily perfect either.)
Asking for specific evidence of a specific BLS personel filing a grievance or similar because of pressure is placing the bar way into the "blind" territory. This is not how influence works. I mean sometimes it is and we get to see it laundered in public, but that's not the common way. In the case of BLS it may be there, I haven't searched.
Oh hey, there is someone who got caught with his hand in the cookie jar: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1988/09/11/b...
As usual what would help is ever more work from the producers to justify their work. BLS comes short. They are not the only ones but still.
Except for e.g. the small print in an EULA, or the XXXX pages Congress spending bills. There is definitely a bureaucratic technique of 'obfuscate through sheer volume of irrelevant information'.
On top of my head:
* basic breakdown: grains, meat, veggies
* processed vs. unprocessed
* grocery sourced vs. eating out, largely fast food
* sourcing, binned by log distance travelled
* scenarios: Med diet? carnivore? vegetarian?
On reflection, the core objection is that there is a subjective hidden parameter: the relative weights of different components. See e.g. https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cpi/calculation.htm#item-replac... I'd rather use my own weights.
And you're free to use your own weights in your own calculations, since they provide all of the formulas and data that they use, including the breakdown of how they select the relative weights.
Yes [1][2].
[1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/
[2] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/home.htm
Except it's not. It's how we calculate inflation, which in turns drives how we measure GPD growth. It's also how we measure productivity and purchasing power. This measure has a very big impact.
Off course there can be no absolute value for such a thing, but the problem is that economists[1] have been obsessed with “real” prices and disregarding “nominal” values (you'd notice the irony of naming the constructed thing “real”), and so almost every economic analysis includes CPI and now everything depends on it so its measurement become included everywhere indirectly. And it is in fact a big problem.
They actually do describe this "If the BLS data collector is forced to replace a short-sleeve cotton/poly shirt in the CPI sample with a long sleeve 100% cotton shirt..." but they provide no answer aside from [well the one on the shelf now is better].
So that the buyer of the "common" shoe, shirt or TV pays more.
It's easy to argue that it's possible to dig deep and find that "older" cheaper item but that doesn't change that the "basic basket" is now more expensive.
The second problem is one of perception - and perception really matters in this case. And CPI doesn't solve that problem.
While I do agree with many of the points you raised, for me those point to the uselessness of the CPI as a matric. If the dataset is so complex you can only boil it down so far before too much context is lost. The CPI is an attempt to create a single number of off the entire economy, a task that is impossible made only more clear by complaints over the obvious and egregious tradeoffs made.
Statistics can be useful, it can also be a pointless game of manipulating so much data that you can make it say whatever you want. I think you'd be hard pressed to find an average American that would feel like prices have only gone up by ~4-5% over the last few years.
Unless you're setting federal policy, it probably is useless to you. For personal forecasting, you're better off using the CPI calculated for your state or metropolitan area. (If you're procuring at a national scale, you're looking at a producer index.)
The BLS goes into excruciating detail about their methodology, which is not something often find scams doing.
The Consumer Price Index is just that, an index. It seeks to distill the complexities of the consumer economy into a single number, and to do so reliably over time. It's impossible to do this without a whole bunch of compromises and trade offs. It's trivial to rip apart any such methodology because of these trade offs - just find a trade off you don't agree with and argue it should be the opposite.
If someone attempted to make a t-shirt using the weighted dimensions of every American, the result would be a t-shirt size that would not fit any individual. But, over time, that t-shirt could be used to understand changes to the American physiology over time.
> For example, they attention to adjust the new price to account for what they consider to be added value.
They cover this in their FAQ [1]. But again, this is a trade off. If laundry detergent becomes more concentrated, thus can do 20% more loads for 10% more price, then how should that be handled? If $1000 Nike shoes become popular, does that mean that the price of shoes increased 10x even if cheaper alternatives are still the same price?
[1] https://www.bls.gov/cpi/quality-adjustment/questions-and-ans...