News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izacus on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:42AM (#37898365)
DMCA says so (and several such projects have been removed via DMCA takedown). youtube-dl also walked into that one.

In general, software engineers even on HN tend to agree with that - that using their paid service without paying is bad, yeah.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by boomboomsubban on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:55AM (#37898503)
I don't think the US has ruled over whether third party YouTube apps are DMCA violations yet.

The DMCA takedown of youtube-dl was complete nonsense, even if youtube-dl is violating the DMCA it is not copyright material subject to a takedown. And Germany has ruled that YouTube's rolling cipher is DRM, but that case may be being appealed and has nothing to do with the US DMCA.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izacus on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:27AM (#37898896)
And yet it was taken down, never to return.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by boomboomsubban on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:51AM (#37899147)
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Mindwipe on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:21AM (#37898811)
That's probably not relevant to Github hosting - Github would very much like to continue to operate in the EU.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by wzdd on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:54AM (#37898499)
> using their paid service without paying is bad

Software engineers on HN or anywhere else certainly do not tend to agree that stripping ads from freely-available content is equivalent to using a paid service without paying.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by nomel on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:10AM (#37898697)
> freely-available

It’s not freely available. It has very real costs associated with it, which is why YouTube was a money burn pit for decades.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by wzdd on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:27PM (#37902232)
> It’s not freely available

It is made available to the general public without cost. It is freely available.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by nomel on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:54PM (#37902697)
It's "free", but not without compensation, and why FreeTube exists: the user is compensated with a free video only after being forced [1] to watch ads, or they can pay [2]. I don't believe compensation, behind a required act, is involved with "free", which is why I would describe it to someone as "ad supported" or even "free, with ads" (which most marketing uses).

[1] https://cybernews.com/tech/youtube-crackdown-on-adblock-user...

[2] https://www.youtube.com/premium

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by HenryBemis on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:09AM (#37898669)
(not defending Google here) I believe that YT costs money to operate. So when I use it without watching ads (which is exactly what I do), I kinda cheat a few cents from them per day/month/year.

Also, having built IOS apps in the past: I love the idea that people use them I hate the idea that people use them without paying for them

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by wzdd on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:33PM (#37902348)
> I kinda cheat a few cents from them per day/month/year

You certainly do not. There is a very simple and legally-recognised way to recuperate costs associated with providing a service and that is to charge money for the service. Youtube is very happy to give you content for free; you're cheating nobody. Or do you think you're cheating if you watch the ads but don't buy any of the products too?

> I hate the idea that people use [my apps] without paying for them

Do you charge money for them?