Re:Margaret Atwood Reviews a Margaret Atwood Story by AI
by jfengel on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:07PM
(#37894877)
It's still doggerel. The rhymes are forced and the syntax stilted. The praise is vapid and lacks any sort of insight.
It reads like a college fight song. I'm good with replacing college fight song writers with a computer.
Re:Margaret Atwood Reviews a Margaret Atwood Story by AI
by michaelmrose on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:06PM
(#37895234)
Are you familiar with the level of writing on display in TV and movies? A lot of writing isn't exactly what high art.
Re:Margaret Atwood Reviews a Margaret Atwood Story by AI
by NateEag on Sunday October 15, 2023 @09:54PM
(#37895172)
good gracious. I think this poem might be worse than the original.
Indirection, subtlety, and allusion are absolutely critical elements in poetry - maybe even fundamental.
There is not a hint of that in this autocompleted piece of dreck. It's more blatant than the terrible evangelical preaching-"poems" I used to see forwarded on AOL in my teens.
Re:Margaret Atwood Reviews a Margaret Atwood Story by AI
by ACow_Adonis on Sunday October 15, 2023 @10:18PM
(#37895306)
It reads like a someone tried to commit poetry by rhyming dot points in a list. Except they got a discount bulk-rate on purchasing commas at the grammar store so they stitched it all together with 50 of them and called it done :P
Plus like allmost all of its output, it appears to have the amount of profundity, aesthetic pleasure, insight and interest usually found in corporate boardrooms and marketing brochures. That is to say, vanilla dross.
Here are some interesting results from literally feeding this article and prompting chatgpt to improve the poem and take into account her critique. They seem at least to my eyes a little better.
===========================================================
===========================================================