News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by randallsquared on Monday April 02, 2012 @08:57AM (#3787821)
It seems short sighted to say that some arbitrary and subjective personal belief system about technology makes one system inherently "better" / "superior" to another.

It's true that the FSF and those who support them are more concerned with the long-term future of computing availability than about whether they can GSD in the next few days or weeks. I'm assuming that that's what you mean by "short sighted"? Well, that's a bit snarky.

I chose OS X above (though I'm moving more and more in the direction of Linux on the desktop again). I guess it just struck me as odd to use "short sighted" to describe the people who, for idealistic reasons, are willing to take a short-term hit to productivity to ensure long-term capability.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by danudey on Monday April 02, 2012 @01:34PM (#3789193)
> It's true that the FSF and those who support them are more concerned with the long-term future of computing availability than about whether they can GSD in the next few days or weeks.

But what's the point then? If it's just an academic process then that's fine, but for the purposes of determining a useful day-to-day primary system, it seems like 'It's free software' is a terrible metric on its own. All else being equal, of course, I'd rather free than closed, but all else is not equal.

It feels sometimes like this sort of 'free therefore better' ideology blinds the people doing the actual development to the fact that if they made the system more productive and intuitive for people to use, then more people would use it, and that's a net benefit to everyone. Perhaps if they DID focus on 'whether they can GSD in the next few days or weeks', then their project would reach more people, and through that more people would be exposed to the (legitimate) benefits of free software.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by nileshtrivedi on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @08:13AM (#3792573)
Isn't that equal to always optimizing locally, as in a greedy algorithm, and therefore ending up at an suboptimal destination? Why isn't a short-term productivity loss acceptable if it improves things in the long-term?

I think it boils down to the difference between idealists and realists. Realists are always optimizing locally whereas long-term change is always brought by the persisting efforts of the idealists.

I also sense that you speak to FOSS as in "us vs them". You want to wait till their products become better than anything else while they are looking for comrades in their campaign to reach there.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by tseabrooks on Monday April 02, 2012 @11:41AM (#3788622)
Sorry, I didn't communicate well. The FSF movement is surely thinking "long term" and these people aren't necessarily "short sighted". What I do think is short sighted is using that as the primary metric for the quality of an Operating System; That leaves and awful lot of pretty important bits and pieces out. Admittedly, some people just prefer Linux / BSD... and thats fine. However, the parent comment I was replying to gave me the impression that, for them, the Free Software aspect was the "end-all, be-all" of metrics for measuring the quality of the OS.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by __abc on Monday April 02, 2012 @01:05PM (#3789052)
Use whatever metrics is most important to you when deciding which OS to run. Some is "free as in speech", some focus on "does this help me git shit down a lot faster" ... some, well, who knows. Who cares for that matter.

I pick a Mac laptop as I can run OSX, Windows, and any necessary flavors of Linux (Metric #1). Plus, it has a nice physical shell and for me, that's worth paying some extra cash (Metric #1). But that is me. I assume no cary over in what works for me with other people.

Laptops are as diverse and affordable as shoes (or any other commodity consumer product) and people pick these things based on whatever suits their fancy at that time.

In regards to getting shit done, I can pretty much get shit done on any distro for the most part once past any learning curve (if there is one).

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by thatjoshguy on Monday April 02, 2012 @10:57AM (#3788403)
Just out of curiosity, what is making you move towards Linux?

The huge appeal of OS X to me is, as someone said on here recently, it's basically *BSD with a fancy window manager and 1-to-1 hardware/software integration.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by randallsquared on Monday April 02, 2012 @12:39PM (#3788898)
The way OS X is being locked down. In 10.8, signing is optional and even if you tell your system not to allow unsigned, you can bypass it on a case by case basis. In the next OS X, we'll probably move a bit farther in that direction, and at one per year, the OS X of 2016 will probably refuse to run unsigned applications at all, for excellent reasons involving security and malware, etc. I'm sure there will be a way to turn it off, but when it's basically impossible to get more than a few users unless you submit to signing, applications like Bittorrent will either submit or find themselves reduced to developers-only status. If they submit, Apple will be able to remove them at any time (for the vast majority of users, who won't know how or want to "root" their Macs). Even if Apple never chooses to use this maliciously -- and I don't think they would for a long time, if ever -- it's going to be only a matter of time before some group sues them to use it to stop infringement or something.

I don't want to run a system where, by design, the manufacturer can remove my ability to run applications I've installed after the fact. So, even though I'm happier in general with the polish and fit of OS X than current desktop linuxes, that's where I'm headed.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by rbarooah on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:35AM (#3792180)
This is a one sided narrative which ignores the possibility that code signing provides meaningful anti-malware benefits.

What would you have them do instead?

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by randallsquared on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @06:05AM (#3792253)
I did mention those benefits in passing: "for excellent reasons involving security and malware". I don't disagree that this can provide those benefits; I just don't feel that they're worth the cost to me, personally. Also, I don't have any notion of how they could provide what I and other technically savvy people want and what the main base of computer users need at the same time.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by rbarooah on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @06:13AM (#3792275)
The only thing you seem to be saying you want is to be free from the fear of unintended negative consequences of code signing.

It's tautological that nobody can both provide something and freedom from the fear of the unintended consequences of that same thing simultaneously.

On the other hand, since the only way to judge the trustworthiness of code is to know its provenance, I don't see how we can avoid some kind of signing becoming ubiquitous.

To me that means that free software must eventually develop a decentralized code signing scheme.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by kaolinite on Wednesday April 04, 2012 @03:39AM (#3796571)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the package managers of all popular Linux distros (except for Arch Linux, who are moving to bring it in soon) have had code signing for years now. It's not decentralised however the package management system isn't either.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by Natsu on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @06:57AM (#3792364)
I think his problem is with those people who would take away the user's freedom to choose who to trust.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by randallsquared on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @08:50AM (#3792676)
I don't really expect them to take it away completely. So, a simpler version is that I expect the capability to silently disable applications on user machines will be misused (through third-party insistence if nothing else; see the _1984_ debacle at Amazon). A similar system which could only throw up scary warnings when starting an unsigned application wouldn't bother me much, since it wouldn't be such attractive lawsuit bait. But I agree that I'm only speculating that Apple will carry this through to its natural end of being iOS-like. I can't imagine any reason for them not to do it, and I think that for the majority of their users, it will actually improve the experience.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by rbarooah on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @07:38AM (#3792476)
Slippery slope fallacies notwithstanding, Apple isn't proposing to take anything away.

My point is that the alternatives don't provide the user with the option to choose who to trust to begin with.

The ability to trust code is something that has to be created with engineering and design.

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by randallsquared on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @08:53AM (#3792686)
The only thing you seem to be saying you want is to be free from the fear of unintended negative consequences of code signing.

Yeah, I dislike negative consequences. :)

To me that means that free software must eventually develop a decentralized code signing scheme.

I wholeheartedly agree!

Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by technomancy on Monday April 02, 2012 @12:44PM (#3788919)
OS X has a few things going for it, but even Mac fans will tell you the window manager is not one of them; it's painfully primitive.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by sirclueless on Monday April 02, 2012 @03:31PM (#3789678)
Even if the WM itself is somewhat primitive, Exposé and integrated swipe gestures more than make up for its shortcomings.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by downx3 on Monday April 02, 2012 @01:47PM (#3789227)
Which WM do you prefer?
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by technomancy on Monday April 02, 2012 @04:00PM (#3789787)
Right now I'm using XMonad, but there are a number of other tiling WMs under X that actually manage windows for you instead of placing that burden on the user.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by jsz0 on Monday April 02, 2012 @06:40PM (#3790455)
There are a number of OSX utilities that do this well.
Re:Poll: What is your primary operating system by almost on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:19AM (#3792157)
Know any that don't really really suck?