Going without a smartphone entirely is more than most people need, but a lot of people experience unattributed health effects from having constant distraction and stimulation in their pocket. We've almost certainly evolved to rest and just stare at the horizon throughout the day, in a way that many people can no longer even imagine.
There was a meme on Twitter/Reddit a little while back where people were absolutely astonished that some guy was traveling without a phone or book or anything. In a world beseiged by depression, anxiety, obesity, etc the inconceivability of "just chilling" certainly seems like a related point of concern.
Fundamentally, I really really like having GPS on me at basically all times, I like having access to pretty much every song ever written wherever I go, I like being able to read and compose emails on the fly, I like having my TODO tasks synced between my computer and my phone. While not perfect, I do think that smartphones increase my quality of life.
We just don't have the cultural experience for anybody's specific suggestions to have much weight yet.
I mean, you can for sure still buy a cheap MP3 player like you could back in the day. Sure, they're less popular but they definitely still exist.
But I don't really think `Dumbphones` will ever make a real comeback... it's more like a specific niche, that has to exist for specific people.
I utterly hated it. I didn't like not being able to check my email when necessary, I didn't like the fact that I had to find clever workarounds for 2FA, I didn't really have a way of listening to music portably without Youtube music. Even though I'm not huge fan of the Pixel 7, I was still able to breath a huge sigh of relief once I activated it.