News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by saalweachter on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:30PM (#37872405)
Broadening the definition of a crime isn't exactly unheard of.

To choose a less emotional subject, mattress tags.

The reason for a mattress tags is because historically people would sell mattresses stuffed full of all sorts of unsavory garbage. What we actually criminalized, or at least were trying to prevent, was some sort of fraud or public endangerment.

But we also along the way made it illegal for sellers to remove the tags from mattresses.

Removing the tag isn't inherently harmful; if you don't deceive the purchaser on the contents of the mattress, it's not even fraud.

But we broadened the definition of the crime to make it easier to enforce.

Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database by novok on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:37PM (#37875351)
You are going into forced labelling disclosure, which can have a lot of benefits beyond fraud prevention because it increases informed consent and all sorts of other net goods. It's the logic and ethics of nutrition labels, and IMO is probably one of the more good vs bad things that govts can mandate.