Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database
by usrnm on Friday October 13, 2023 @11:55AM
(#37872017)
And I absolutely want both parties to have to prove crime/innocence and have an opportunity to argue. The current situation, where anything involving CSAM is so toxic that lives are ruined without trial is not healthy and isn't good for anybody
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database
by Hizonner on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:01PM
(#37872072)
Point of order: victims are not "parties" in criminal cases, not in remotely modern legal systems. The parties are the accused and the state.
For the same reason, victims don't get to pardon crimes committed against them.
... which is the way it should be, because criminal punishment should not be seen as a form of revenge, but as a deterrent.
Re:Tainting the CSAM client-side scanning database
by qingcharles on Friday October 13, 2023 @12:23PM
(#37872310)
Right. Most crimes are essentially ones that "the people" found unsavory.
For instance, there is no "victim" if I got caught enjoying cannabis in my own home in a jurisdiction where such a thing is illegal, but "the people" have made a decision that they don't like it and I should be punished for committing an anti-social act.
That is one of the fundamental aspects of democracy at work.