News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by photochemsyn on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @11:51AM (#37846064)
An additional issue is that a good fraction of 'organic nitrogen fertilizer' comes in the form of fish meal. This isn't a very environmentally friendly or sustainable approach, however - e.g. at peak extraction, 2/3 of sardine fishery production on the US west coast was being converted into crop fertilizer (mid 20th century).

Note however that modern industrial agriculture uses fertilizer fairly inefficiently, and a large fraction just runs off the fields into waterways. Here is where the AI robots could make a big difference, by crawling up and down farm fields and selectively applying fertilizer to individual plants as needed (while also removing weeds and treating pest infestations). Of course, this doesn't make agrichemical producers all that happy as it could greatly reduce demand.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @12:14PM (#37846382)
You don't need robots -- tractors already drive up and down the field, and the cost of the tractor is many times the annual cost of the worker, BTW -- you just need good application. Which is something farmers already attempt to do. Because why would you waste your $$ on bad deployment of expensive fertilizer? (Or pesticide, etc.)

This is my employer's bread and butter for many decades: https://www.ravenind.com/products/applications-booms

And yes, it's a lot of emphasis on autonomy now, but you'd be amazed at what just having better spray nozzles can do?

Cash crop farming is an incredibly capital intensive operation. Robots don't fix that.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by steve_adams_86 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @12:47PM (#37846853)
Your point about spray nozzles is a great one. Not many people realize how difficult it is to make such a small and seemingly unimportant component work well and reliably.

In my hydroponics system, spray nozzles are one of the more expensive (for the size and purpose) components and they fail the most often. You’d think a brass nozzle would last years, but it’s going to need to be disassembled and cleaned before a year is up. Now imagine a huge tractor with high pressure bars that are lined with dozens of nozzles operating in a dirty environment and moving huge volumes of fluid. You’re going to get clogs, you’re going to have to clean them, and the application will be non-ideal quite often if you don’t. And that’s just the nozzles.

This stuff is so much harder and more complicated than it seems on the surface. Adding automation almost makes it harder because you really do want a human observing the system and ensuring it’s actually working.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by foobarian on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @12:59PM (#37847053)
Neither here nor there, but why are specialized nozzles needed for fertilizer? Can't that go directly on the ground with a very basic pattern?
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:11PM (#37847230)
There all sorts of things that affect coverage. These things are done by booms with nozzles at all sorts of different points, and there's variables like pressure variance at different points in the pipes, spray radius per nozzle type, turning radius / position of the tractor, relative height of the boom to the crop / ground at different points, etc.

And it's not just fertilizer, but other sprays, too.

Here, this looks thoroughly boring, but this guy is going over configuring one of our systems for fertilizer application... You can get an idea of some of the variables involved, if you can make it through :-)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2rQJI7zz1q4

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by steve_adams_86 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:45PM (#37851328)
I don’t find it boring at all, haha. I have a feeling I chose the wrong career path.
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by cmrdporcupine on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @10:18PM (#37852773)
It's possible to combine an enthusiasm for spray nozzles with software development :-) https://www.ravenind.com/careers :-)

But I think we're kind of in a hiring freeze. I think I just barely squeaked in before that.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by bluGill on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @02:21PM (#37848249)
Because a basic pattern isn't easy to obtain. If there is wind it will blow your spray around. If there is dirt in the nozzle that changes your pattern (until you clean it - but now you need to check if it needs to be cleaned). Sprayer booms can be 130 feet (40 meters) long, and sprayers go over the field fairly fast: those booms are bouncing all over the place and that is changing the pattern. Which is worse - too much chemical on a given section of ground or too much - depending your answer (which will change for different chemicals!) sometimes you want the nozzles to overlap the next and other times now. What is the viscosity of the chemical - this changes the spray pattern. How much chemical do you spray - a low quantity through a high flow nozzle will just drip, while a high quantity through a low flow nozzle isn't possible. Do you want to spray the just ground, just the plants, or both - maybe you can get a nozzle focused on this. Soil is not consistent across a field, so farmers normally apply different amounts of chemical in different sections.

The above is not a complete list of all the nozzle considerations I know of (I work for John Deere, but I don't speak for them), it is what I can remember in a couple minutes.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by InSteady on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:09PM (#37850942)
>I work for John Deere

Mind telling your bosses to fuck off and let farmers repair their own equipment, please?

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by bluGill on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:43PM (#37851314)
No need, farmers can repair. What they can't to is change emissions or steel parts. So long as you are doing the regular repair work farmers do there is no problem. When you do things beyond that things get hard.
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by steve_adams_86 on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @06:49PM (#37851365)
Would it be possible to estimate viscosity using a calibrated pump and some kind of “time to spray” test (in which a specific amount of force is used to express the fluid through a nozzle), then use that viscosity measurement to set the pressure for the spray to get more consistent results?

Or does that make absolutely no sense? I’m not sure how you can reliably measure fluid properties in order to get consistent spray patterns. It seems like it would be useful here, though.

You can tell I’m not an engineer :)

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by bluGill on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @07:13PM (#37851583)
Yes, and there is manual calibration to do that sometimes. (Iirc for sprayers most chemicals are 99% water so the factory does that, but planters often do have a process where you dump seed for a minute and then measure what came out). However you still need different nozzles for different fluid rates.
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by searine on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @11:59AM (#37846188)
>Here is where the AI robots could make a big difference

Usually when someone says "AI will save the world because" it is followed by a bunch of naive hyperbole.

However, you are 100% right. A few robust robots with an AI to spot pests and poor nutrition could decimate input costs for a farm and solve several environmental issues in one go.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by snapcaster on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @01:10PM (#37847215)
What are you basing that on?
Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by searine on Wednesday October 11, 2023 @02:46PM (#37848609)
The reason chemical pest control and broadly spraying fertilizer on the top of fields are a thing is that they have low labor costs. You'd get more efficacy if you walked the field and removed pests by hand or sprayed fertilizer only where you need it.

It's the simple reason why a well-tended garden produces better produce than a corporate farm. There is simply more effort per plant in a garden. Tractors are currently too dumb to treat plants individually. They require plants to emerge, grow, harvest at the same time, and in the same way. Current modalities for pests/nutrition treat plants at the field level, not at the individual level. This creates lots of waste and externalities.

If there were a robustly built robot smart enough to deal with plant issues in and individual way then there is a huge slice of efficiency that could be gained. A field with the productivity of a garden. People have been trying to create this for a decade now and the limiting factor is the software. Maybe with the latest round of AI advances that will change.

Re:Farm in Kenya to produce fertilizer without using fossil ... by matthewdgreen on Thursday October 12, 2023 @08:11AM (#37856106)