Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by ckastner on Monday October 09, 2023 @07:34AM
(#37819280)
Granted, the merit of some of the awards is questionable, but I think e.g.: Nash's work on game theory or Kahneman/Tvservky's on the pyschology of judgment definitely fall under the umbrella of "science".
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by oldgradstudent on Monday October 09, 2023 @07:44AM
(#37819363)
There are plenty of awards granted for great work in computer science, electrical engineering, or any number of other fields.
It doesn't make them Nobel prizes.
At least the ACM never attempted to hang on the coattails of the the Nobel Prize by naming the Turing award for Alfred Nobel.
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by Hamuko on Monday October 09, 2023 @09:34AM
(#37820313)
>At least the ACM never attempted to hang on the coattails of the the Nobel Prize by naming the Turing award for Alfred Nobel.
Aren't they riding on the coattails of Turing instead?
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by oldgradstudent on Monday October 09, 2023 @02:09PM
(#37823339)
Turing wasn't nearly as well known as he is now. The cryptoanalysis of the Enigma remained classified until the early 1970s, long after the Turing award was established (the first award was given in 1966).
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by VHRanger on Monday October 09, 2023 @08:06AM
(#37819561)
Arguably Goldin winning for pure empirical work falls under science just as much or more than the Khaneman prize
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by mrguyorama on Monday October 09, 2023 @10:53AM
(#37821064)
No, a newly named award shouldn't really have any existing clout associated with it, and can make it's own reputation. The Turing award is not treated like a nobel prize by pretty much anyone, though it is respected.
Economics decided that kind of thing, say a "Smith award" wouldn't get them enough clout, so better to abuse a brand name for it's value. How classic.
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by VHRanger on Monday October 09, 2023 @11:08AM
(#37821246)
Im sorry but to a normal person the Fields medal or Turing award is treated the exact same as the Nobel prize in whatever discipline.
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by mrguyorama on Monday October 09, 2023 @12:48PM
(#37822330)
Are you sure? How many normal people even know the Fields medal or Turing award even exists?
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by aragonite on Monday October 09, 2023 @08:23AM
(#37819681)
Note that neither of your two examples is carried out by people who think of themselves as economists.
Re:2023 Nobel Prize in economics awarded to Claudia Goldin
by subtypefiddler on Monday October 09, 2023 @09:04AM
(#37820056)
Very interesting examples. For Nash, Von Neumann contributions to the field were orders of magnitude more important. For Kahneman and Tversky let's not forget that the foundations are quite shaky to quote [0]
[0] https://replicationindex.com/2020/12/30/a-meta-scientific-pe...