It isn't consider a gift as you a gaining something (access to page) so you need to pay tax on that.
This is one thing that bothers me with patronite and other platforms. I wish I could simply send a gift (without acces to anything) and not to pay another tax on already taxed money.
Many EU states tax tips as well (all the way -> VAT/corporate/income/social tax)
If creators had to administer that stuff on an individual basis they'd have no time left for creating.
It doesn't ACT like 'a gift', it acts like a paycheck. If a guy gets paid by a car dealership because he's the owner's kid without having to do anything, the IRS doesn't care whether he has to work for real but it very much cares whether he pays his taxes on his income.
I also pay a writer (he goes by Wildbow) a couple of bucks a month, for posting weekly chapters of his webserial.
Both have no relation to rewards, it's just because I love the stuff they create for free and want to support them.
(Federal) gift tax isn't really a thing except for the exceedingly wealthy. Idk about all states
But your description is only one of the mental models for how Patreon works. E.g. the "traditional patron" idea financially supports the artist and not any particular work.
However, Patreon also has a more transctional style of financial interaction called "payment charge per creation". This alternative payment method is explicitly set up as an option within Patreon's billing UI: https://support.patreon.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002355991-H....
>There doesn't have to be any quid pro quo at all.
True, but many content creators do deliberately set up "quid pro quo" arrangements with paywall gates via Patreon membership levels. E.g. Patreon even helps creators with this by integrating various Discord member tiers based on Patreon payments. (https://support.patreon.com/hc/en-us/articles/213552323-Sett...)
Not everybody on Patreon uses your traditional meaning of "patron/artist".
To give example generalizations of the 2 mental models used by different creators...
Many musicians like the traditional patron model of financial support regardless if they write any new music that month.
On the other hand, the financial and real estate influencers on youtube are more transactional and will put Patreon paywalls on their instruction materials and Discord chat rooms.
They also had good timing since they allowed you to send your faves money before the creator platforms developed in-house solutions.
Platform that charges "per work" AND automatically does the paperwork for taxes that makes it a gift, not income.
I mean yes and no. I feel like I'm getting a fairer deal from some Artists than others that I support. So I admit I sometimes only subscribe for 1-3 months, and then unsubscribe, when Output is low, or variance in content themes is too high. The price then isn't really justified.
Also, for some artists, Patreon serves as an ad-hoc subscription platform. If I'm essentially being promised 3-4 units of "Art" per month, you bet I'm going to unsubscribe if the Artist doesn't post at all, unannounced. It's also not fair to call these "gifts" - I get exclusive access to most of the content on Patreon and with one exception, all Artists advertise it as a service. I'd be different if I could consume their content on another platform for free, but often times I can't.
Tbf though, I still don't have a reliable income, so maybe I'd change my habits once I got that taken care of.
Being a Patron (which is what Patreon was trying to do) traditionally meant supporting someone, no matter what their output. If your tortured genius put out one work a year, so be it. If they popped out Sunflowers then even better!
There doesn't have to be any quid pro quo at all.
It's what we now call Basic Income financed by someone's surplus.
Don't overthink it. It's not a tip, it's a gift, an expression of support. It may be something more, but in the end you're giving money to someone, period.
As an aside, it's really unclear if Patreon payments should be considered income in the US. It's a gift, but it's up to the giver to handle that. I doubt creators would need a 1099 in that case either.