Could you elaborate?
Essentially Kahneman ended up being super confident ("disbelief is not an option" he said) about the findings he cited, some of which have been shown to suffer from lack of rigor.
If you're wondering "well, just some of them right?" I will ask you to ponder for a minute over the fact that this is not supposed to be some impulse aisle magazine article but a book applied epistemology ("behavioural economics" is to me just what gave this and related books some sales wheels).
[1] https://replicationindex.com/2020/12/30/a-meta-scientific-pe...
[2] https://slate.com/technology/2016/12/kahneman-and-tversky-re....
[0] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/warren-buffett-has-underperfo...
https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/220
This is an interview with two academic researchers into active fund managers who can indeed beat the market consistently sometimes. One factor why they exist is that they have access to better information than the average individual investor. However, (1) excess returns tend to mostly get absorbed by higher fees and (2) it's very difficult to scale it up, funds who beat the market tend to lose this edge when more funds go into them. Thus, market-beating funds, if they want to maintain their edge, have to severely limit who can invest in the fund and how much they can put into it.
The episode also goes into the effect of security selection (which stocks are picked) vs market timing, which is relevant to TFA.
Is this like "60% of the time it works every time"? The fact that there are a few individuals that have beaten the market on occasion is a strong indicator that the chances of any retail trader doing this are slim to none.
I suspect poker has more skill involved than stock trading.
This is just like the startup founder argument. Every one which succeeds ends up having a tremendously interesting background demonstrating unique interest and capability.
In the Black Swan he talks about his endeavor with the stock market and how lucky he got by chance, and not by using some pseudo scientific formulas and whatnot to "predict" how his stocks would do. He also gave some pretty good advice when it comes to the stock market
The whole book is just awesome, I'd recommend giving it a read
- He isn't a stock trader, he is a bond trader. The kind of bets you need to make to be succesful are different.
- "how lucky he got by chance" - He doesn't say this. He talks about how we can even better model uncertainties.
>He talks about how we can even better model uncertainties.
Where does he say this? What chapter? Thanks in advance.
edit: were you alluding to his barbel strategy?
There's very little skill involved, which isn't to say there is no skill involved whatsoever - but at the end of the day it really is just luck
The following excerpts are from Thinking, Fast and Slow:
"The illusion of skill is not only an individual aberration; it is deeply ingrained in the culture of the industry. Facts that challenge such basic assumptions—and thereby threaten people’s livelihood and self-esteem—are simply not absorbed. The mind does not digest them. This is particularly true of statistical studies of performance, which provide base-rate information that people generally ignore when it clashes with their personal impressions from experience."
"Finally, the illusions of validity and skill are supported by a powerful professional culture. We know that people can maintain an unshakable faith in any proposition, however absurd, when they are sustained by a community of like-minded believers. Given the professional culture of the financial community, it is not surprising that large numbers of individuals in that world believe themselves to be among the chosen few who can do what they believe others cannot."