[1] https://www.patreon.com/en-GB/policy/community-guidelines
And as far as I remember, Patreon also had similar issues with terminating accounts of people that they (not judges !) have decided to have violated (IIRC) hate speech laws ? (This wouldn't be an issue if antitrust was working properly and Patreon hadn't become so big that alternatives aren't even on people's radars (GP's ignorance about Tipeee being an example), but here we are...)
(also, you've missed all the points in the original article which crypto does not provide!)
The real feature of crypto is decentralization, which does not need to mean fraud—in the same way that end-to-end encryption does not only facilitate criminal behaviour.
Of course still lying into the face of potential users about "decentralzing things" while trapping them into the platform - what a joke!
On the opposite, you have ultra-centralized governance and zero democracy.
You should erase the idea from your head that cryptocoins bring anything valuable to the payment world.
Users (non-devs) have agency through the software they choose to run. If mainnet was seriously affected by some attack, users could choose to migrate to a healthier network run by honest nodes. This agency happens with every hard fork: the DAO, but also the PoS merge.
You can't autobill.
Every time you want a payment, you need a signature from the sending wallet. The closest you can get is a smart contract where someone pre-loads a certain amount of money and it trickles out as the months/works roll out, but it will eventually deplete. Then what? Subscription over? Start the nagging emails?
It's not "set and forget" like a credit card where you settle the debt after the creator receives their payment.
There are disadvantages to using Layer 2 of a blockchain, and you are ignoring the costs of on-boarding and off-boarding from cryptocurrency.
> - Users of the platform could be given more control such as forking the OSS protocol if the core devs go off the rails or try to extract more than what users feel it’s worth. This is especially interesting given the recent polarizing changes to Patreon and Bandcamp’s business structures.
In this case you're speaking of doing Patreon on the blockchain, not merely using cryptocurrency transactions? How would that work and how wouldn't it be cheaper and easier to do with a public, possibly federated, server running a FOSS Patreon software?
> - Settlement times can be measured in minutes or hours rather than days, weeks, or months.
Are settlement times going down with FedNow? And even CC transactions take seconds, do the content creators care that much about getting the money immediately and isn't that a greater fraud risk?
> - Anonymity and local-first data privacy could be achieved, at least theoretically. Practically, very few L2s have yet to reach complete privacy using zero knowledge proofs and related cryptography.
I admit to not being familiar with the situation but aren't all transactions public on the blockchain? How that can be anonymous unless you're using something like Monero? And I'm not sure what local-first data there is, you meaning having the paywalled content downloaded to your device if you subscribe?
> - Mitigating centralizing factors such as Patreon’s control over what is a morally acceptable revenue stream. Content like NSFW art might be currently acceptable, but this could change on a dime if the company decides to change its values.
What about illegally acceptable revenue streams? How would such a platform stop being banned due to illegal content?
Yes, it's not a panacea, but has the potential to be far lower than the current status quo.
> In this case you're speaking of doing Patreon on the blockchain, not merely using cryptocurrency transactions? How would that work and how wouldn't it be cheaper and easier to do with a public, possibly federated, server running a FOSS Patreon software?
It can be both; using smart contracts to facilitate payments and identity, and some form of federated or decentralized protocol for communication and discovery (e.g. Farcaster).
> Are settlement times going down with FedNow? And even CC transactions take seconds, do the content creators care that much about getting the money immediately and isn't that a greater fraud risk?
Not everybody lives in the USA, and yes creators would likely appreciate lowering payout schedules from days to hours.
> I admit to not being familiar with the situation but aren't all transactions public on the blockchain?
Yes, like Monero but with smart contracts and verifiable computation via ZK-SNARKs. It is possible, but in its infancy: see Aztec and Aleo.
> What about illegally acceptable revenue streams? How would such a platform stop being banned due to illegal content?
The primary hosts can choose not to serve the illegal content; it would redirect the behaviour to alternative platforms. Similar to a popular Mastodon server choosing not to allow NSFW, but other servers might allow NSFW.
A person who is completely non-technical would be even less likely to use Crypto than me.
the port to fiat is the problem
someone somewhere will need to change USDC / USDT (eek) to fiat
either all visitors of the platform or the platform forms those relationships
this is the weakness of crypto enthusiasts’ arguments. they live in the world where crypto won and you can buy goods within their ecosystem.
this is simply not true… yet?
i’m actually a fan of crypto, but these naive or bond header arguments are not useful to convince anyone. it’s like saying you can lose weight eating mcdonald’s, you can but will most?
i’ve personally never had a problem with them or circle but my transaction volume is low. the normie can’t and won’t figure out the metamask to coinbase to fait part.
it’s painful for those deep in crypto let alone the average patron supporter
stop painting a rosy picture of shitty crypto ux
- Instead of 4-7% payment processing fees, it can be effectively zero[1]
- Instead of 8-12% fees (or 15% in case of Bandcamp), crypto industry standards tend to be in the 0-5% range. It’s not always clear to me as a creator and patron why such a significant amount of value needs to be captured for a digital asset sale.
- Users of the platform could be given more control such as forking the OSS protocol if the core devs go off the rails or try to extract more than what users feel it’s worth. This is especially interesting given the recent polarizing changes to Patreon and Bandcamp’s business structures.
- Settlement times can be measured in minutes or hours rather than days, weeks, or months.
- Anonymity and local-first data privacy could be achieved, at least theoretically. Practically, very few L2s have yet to reach complete privacy using zero knowledge proofs and related cryptography.
- Mitigating centralizing factors such as Patreon’s control over what is a morally acceptable revenue stream. Content like NSFW art might be currently acceptable, but this could change on a dime if the company decides to change its values.
Subscription and recurring payments are notoriously difficult in crypto, but “by-work” as the author puts it, i.e. “microtransactions per each published digital object” is already happening in crypto and with much lower rates than Patreon et al[2].
[1] https://l2fees.info/
[2] https://teia.art/about