Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by compressedgas on Sunday October 08, 2023 @02:26AM
(#37808297)
The article actually says that sour receptors detect ammonium chloride. This means that there is no new taste. For there to be a new one, there would need to be a kind of receptor which is activated while the rest of them are inactive.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by A_No_Name_Mouse on Sunday October 08, 2023 @08:35AM
(#37809905)
If the same receptor can distinguish between 2 distinct tastes I would consider it a different basic taste. In my experience ammonium chloride does not taste sourat all, so this might be the case. The article does not mention that though.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by GolDDranks on Sunday October 08, 2023 @03:22AM
(#37808533)
In Finland, we call this taste the taste of "salmiakki" or "salmiak salt" in English. It's a popular taste in gummy-like candies, but it's an acquired taste. Most people who taste it for the first time as adults, hate it.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by globular-toast on Sunday October 08, 2023 @04:49AM
(#37808877)
I love it. It's my favourite type of sweet but it's quite hard to find in the UK (not that I go to great lengths to find such things).
I find it funny that in British English we would call such a thing a "sweet" even though it's not actually very sweet (which is why I like it). Sweet is roughly equivalent to candy in American English, but with a notable exception: chocolate is not considered a sweet but falls instead into the broader category of confectionery.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by qball on Sunday October 08, 2023 @05:24AM
(#37809044)
>It's a popular taste in gummy-like candies
It's also the "salt" in salted licorice.
>but it's an acquired taste
Yes, because it's objectively unpleasant (if it tasted good there would naturally be no need to acquire a taste for it). Of course, that's not to say it's pointless to add it- provided it's done properly you can add a salty flavor to places it can't normally be (chocolate covered black licorice being one of those places)- but it's also a taste that imposes a relatively small n where (enjoyment gained from eating n+1 pieces) < (enjoyment gained from eating n pieces) compared to candy that's actually designed to taste good.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by truculent on Sunday October 08, 2023 @03:39AM
(#37808587)
> which gives it its distinct flavor: bitter, salty, and a little bit sour.
Doesn't describing it in terms of the other basic tastes undermine the main point somewhat?
Is this a limitation of using language to describe a new sensory channel? Or is it somehow different to the other basic tastes (it seems like the mechanism is slightly different)?
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by graypegg on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:21AM
(#37810689)
Yeah it does to me at least. When people try to describe umami without being self-referential, they’ll say “meaty” which in my mind, really does stand separately from the rest of the other tastes. I don’t really have a good sense of a unique taste from salty liquorice in the same way I do something “meaty”.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by eps on Sunday October 08, 2023 @04:28AM
(#37808784)
The very notion of "base tastes" is confusing. It's not like you can decompose every taste into just these 5 base tastes, i.e. a strawberry taste. Yes, they are omnipresent and prominent, but why single them out?
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by akdor1154 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @04:30AM
(#37808801)
They are singled out because there are identifiable receptors for them on your tongue. Strawberry is distinct from honey because of your olfactory sense, which is separate.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by Brian_K_White on Sunday October 08, 2023 @06:41AM
(#37809364)
It's the same as rods and cones in the eye. You don't just see by magic, there are few specific and finite sensors, which you process into a combined perception.
When you see a chair or a lake, no matter how different those things are, the sensory mechanism is the same and quite limited in a way.
It's also like language, or arabic numerals. You can express any number or any idea, to infinity, but they are all composed out of a tiny alphabet of only 10 digits or 26 letters.
And it's not some desire to reduce or deconstruct anything, because anyone just hates calling a strawberry a strawberry for some reason. It's simply what actually IS. Our perception of the taste of strawberry, and everything else, IS composed of only a few "base tastes". You don't have a whole sensor cell just for strawberries, and an infinite number of others for the infinite number of other things. You have a few senor types which are general purpose, and can compose a perception for strawberry, or anything else, even if strawberries were invented today and none of your evolutionary history never encountered a strawberry before.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by lesam on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:59AM
(#37811067)
Except you do have hundreds of distinct smell receptors that can detect complex chemical signals, which contribute greatly to what we colloquially call ‘taste’.
Which is why food tastes very different if you lose your sense of smell, and why making artificial flavours is not just a matter of mixing a few base flavours.
Re:A new basic taste joins sweet, salty, sour, bitter and umami
by Brian_K_White on Sunday October 08, 2023 @12:18PM
(#37811792)
This isn't an exception. Smell is smell not tase, and hundreds or even thousands is still nothing next to infinite. It is still a tiny finite alphabet, like the amino acids everything is built out of.
Yes when we eat something we are experiencing more than just tatse, but so what? The fact that our full perception of a strawberry includes smell is as irrelevant to the validity of the concept of "a few base tastes" as the fact that it also includes sight and texture and memories of that summer job you had picking strawberries one year when you were 12.
There is no Van Gogh sensor gene in your retina. There are just a very few types of light sensor, which all sight is composed of. Taste is the same. Smell is the same. Smell just has a bit larger alphabet, but it's still finite. The original comment questioned the validity of the very idea that there was any such finite alphabet. There is no possible question about that.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41637-4
I would have thought this is about how tasting sour works not about a completely new taste.
> baseless
heh.
The proton channel OTOP1 is a sensor for the taste of ammonium chloride
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41637-4 (web layout)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-41637-4.epdf (print layout)
But this is the stuff I was talking about, thanks.
I find it funny that in British English we would call such a thing a "sweet" even though it's not actually very sweet (which is why I like it). Sweet is roughly equivalent to candy in American English, but with a notable exception: chocolate is not considered a sweet but falls instead into the broader category of confectionery.
It's also the "salt" in salted licorice.
>but it's an acquired taste
Yes, because it's objectively unpleasant (if it tasted good there would naturally be no need to acquire a taste for it). Of course, that's not to say it's pointless to add it- provided it's done properly you can add a salty flavor to places it can't normally be (chocolate covered black licorice being one of those places)- but it's also a taste that imposes a relatively small n where (enjoyment gained from eating n+1 pieces) < (enjoyment gained from eating n pieces) compared to candy that's actually designed to taste good.
Who gets to decide what is "objectively unpleasant"?
I'm surprised there hasn't been a rush to claim the rights to naming this basic taste something more "palatable" <ducks>
Doesn't describing it in terms of the other basic tastes undermine the main point somewhat?
Is this a limitation of using language to describe a new sensory channel? Or is it somehow different to the other basic tastes (it seems like the mechanism is slightly different)?
When you see a chair or a lake, no matter how different those things are, the sensory mechanism is the same and quite limited in a way.
It's also like language, or arabic numerals. You can express any number or any idea, to infinity, but they are all composed out of a tiny alphabet of only 10 digits or 26 letters.
And it's not some desire to reduce or deconstruct anything, because anyone just hates calling a strawberry a strawberry for some reason. It's simply what actually IS. Our perception of the taste of strawberry, and everything else, IS composed of only a few "base tastes". You don't have a whole sensor cell just for strawberries, and an infinite number of others for the infinite number of other things. You have a few senor types which are general purpose, and can compose a perception for strawberry, or anything else, even if strawberries were invented today and none of your evolutionary history never encountered a strawberry before.
Which is why food tastes very different if you lose your sense of smell, and why making artificial flavours is not just a matter of mixing a few base flavours.
Yes when we eat something we are experiencing more than just tatse, but so what? The fact that our full perception of a strawberry includes smell is as irrelevant to the validity of the concept of "a few base tastes" as the fact that it also includes sight and texture and memories of that summer job you had picking strawberries one year when you were 12.
There is no Van Gogh sensor gene in your retina. There are just a very few types of light sensor, which all sight is composed of. Taste is the same. Smell is the same. Smell just has a bit larger alphabet, but it's still finite. The original comment questioned the validity of the very idea that there was any such finite alphabet. There is no possible question about that.