News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by JW_00000 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:06AM (#37801393)
What I don't really understand is, do people really have than many physical documents that they need to keep track of, that such a system is worth it? E.g. to file my taxes (in Belgium), I think I only ever need a few (maybe even only 1 or 2) digital documents. Or is this more a mentality thing? I know my parents have folders and folders, e.g. my father kept all expense notes from his work even after retirement... I throw everything away once it's handled.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by dividedbyzero on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:38AM (#37801603)
Definitely, Germany strongly believes that a document that hasn't been a physical piece of paper at least once can't be real. That makes for folders upon folders of documents and it's actually worse than back in the 20th century because generating and mailing documents has become way easier and cheaper, so things that would have been a one-page typewritten letter back then now are five ten-page ones full of automatically generated crap. One lengthy illness in the family alone filled hundreds of pages and it can be very hard to know what can be thrown away at which point.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by schlowmo on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:20AM (#37802461)
> Definitely, Germany strongly believes that a document that hasn't been a physical piece of paper at least once can't be real.

I'm sorry to tell you that is a an oversimplification and especially for documenting expenses as a company/freelancer it's kind of worse.

Last time I checked if you want to follow the tax law to the word you're not allowed to change the medium:

If an invoice came as a paper copy (e.g. by snail mail), this paper copy is the original. If you scan it the digital version isn't.

If an invoice came as a digital document (e.g. a PDF by email), this digital document is the original - a printed version of that digital document isn't.

So if a tax inspector asks for "originals" it's technically almost impossible to provide them in the sense of the law. If even a tax inspector would care is another question.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by germanier on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:28AM (#37802543)
It's perfectly legal (and common) for a decade now to scan documents and destroy the paper original as long as you follow some guidelines. Keyword is "ersetzendes Scannen".

And yes, they care about those rules and that you provide "originals" according to that definition - in particular that you didn't modify digital documents in any way. You can (and should) comply with that and there are service providers to help if you are to small to set that up yourself.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by schlowmo on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:04PM (#37803399)
Thanks, today I learned about "ersetzendes Scannen". I just checked and it's exactly a decade (2013) since it's allowed which coincidetally is the year when I started working as a freelancer (and I have to care about such rules).

I admit that my last paragraph was kind of hyperbole, but I never heard (at least from other freelancers) of a tax inspector which wasn't happy with either everything printed or everything digital. I guess they really start to care if they suspect something fishy.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by noAnswer on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:06PM (#37803427)
Another search/keyword is "Revisionssicher". If you storage/software has that, you a good to go.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by greenicon on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:40PM (#37804863)
Just a side note to this and the other replies: You can also keep the original documents and add scans to paperless for indexing, etc. Since I switched to paperless I keep my originals in binders just ordered by the paperless id, so I can retrieve the original when required.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by ipsi on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:45PM (#37803250)
Yeah, I'm also in Germany (although not German) and installed Paperless because of this!

I think more than a few of these projects are started and/or maintained by Germans due to the astonishing number of documents received - e.g., paperless-ng appears to have been done by a German, although neither the original Paperless nor Paperless NGX immediately appear to be.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by _frkl on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:18AM (#37801479)
Can't speak for physical documents in general, but personally I really appreciate paperless-ngx for it's general document indexing/storage. Being able to scan and ocr physical documents (usually using the camera on my mobile phone) is very nice, but I mainly use it with pdfs that paperless automatically fetches, ocrs (if necessary), and tags from my email inbox, or which I copy into a specific local folder which gets synced with paperless.

Getting all my invoices from last year to prepare taxes is now just a simple query in the paperless UI, the result would be about 95% digital and 5% physical documents, probably. Of course I could do all that old-school using filesystem folders, but having all my documents indexed and searchable in a single place was definitely worth the (small) effort of setting it all up and keep it running.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by kristofferR on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:23AM (#37801513)
I don't understand what you mean with prepare taxes.

I just add all purchases/sales right when they happen in my accounting app and attach the invoice PDF. Then when I have to file taxes, I export the correct numbers.

Are you doing your bookkeeping in Excel or something?

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by _frkl on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:37AM (#37802602)
This is just for my personal taxes, no accounting involved. I just get all the relevant stuff together once a year. Of course it's not 10s of 100s of documents, but still enough so it would take me some time to get everything together manually.

Also it was just meant as an example, paperless is generally useful (to me) in situations where I need to access somehow related documents, like traveling and such, or searching my documents for some information. As I said, there are other systems and ways to do this, but for me this is the one that stuck.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by viraptor on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:14AM (#37801451)
It's not just for physical documents. I have payslips which may be useful in the future, but are would be really hard to recover when I leave the company. Any invoices which come to my email. Any bank documents which exist in a vaguely named "account updates" email. And many other things which could be possible to find in the future, but are much better in paperless with appropriate tags and OCR.

But yeah, then there are for example the bank account contract updates which come by physical mail only.

> expense notes (...) I throw everything away once it's handled.

Don't know about your location, but I need to keep the tax related documents for 5 years in case of an audit.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by kristofferR on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:11AM (#37801425)
In some countries like Germany, the government still communicates with its citizens by snail mail. Important documents are usually physical there. They are one of the least developed countries in Europe with digitalization, they are far behind.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by NoboruWataya on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:08AM (#37801825)
I'm quite paranoid about throwing stuff away so for me it's at least partly a mentality thing. I probably save a lot more than I need but it gives me piece of mind to know that it's all there. There are some things that it is very helpful to have easy access to, like utility bills and bank statements (which I occasionally need for KYC stuff) or ID documents.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by yunohn on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:21AM (#37801914)
In the Netherlands, government bodies are regularly pushing everything they can to a digital inbox - which I vastly prefer. My simple, single-employer yearly income tax is all pre-calculated. Further, deductions for mortgage interest, healthcare, studies, etc are all pre-filled as much as possible. I think you only need to upload documents for complicated sitations or audits?

Of course, I still quickly download my year-end bank/salary/mortgage statements and cross-verify the tax departments numbers. The whole process takes at most a few hours.

IME Germany has significantly more hard-copy requirements.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by t0mas88 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:26AM (#37801957)
You never need to upload the documents in the Netherlands, their software doesn't have such an option.

But technically you're expected to keep the documents at least until you receive the "definitieve aanslag" and if you're nitpicking I think there is a 7 year term for the tax services to come back on your filed taxes and change things or demand proof.

Practically that doesn't happen if you accepted their pre-filled numbers and they match your employers. But if you're a freelancer or other non-standard case I would keep digital copies for a few years just to be sure.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by yunohn on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:30PM (#37803111)
> You never need to upload the documents in the Netherlands, their software doesn't have such an option.

Ah, interesting. I just assumed my situation never triggered it.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by t0mas88 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:21AM (#37801921)
Depends on your tax situation. For my private taxes it's maybe 3 or 4 documents and those from the bank etc have all gone PDF anyway.

But when I was a freelancer I used a document scanning system provided by my bookkeeper. It worked similar to this open source thing, scan to PDF, automatic OCR and classification. Needed it because many invoices still arrived on paper, and receipts for restaurants etc I usually took a picture to upload.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by Macha on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:53AM (#37802202)
So here's an example where it came in useful to have back documents:

I recently purchased a house. As part of the process, I needed to apply for a mortgage. The bank wanted a statement from my employer about my income from them, along with my last 2 complete years tax documents.

The bank had an inquiry. My employer had said my salary + bonus was X, but in the first of these two years, my tax documents said my income from my employer that year was 2.5X. The extra 1.5X was due to the employer being bought out and some change of control terms in the RSUs causing immediate payout of what would normally have been paid out over 4 years. Since I kept the documents of the RSU terms and the payslips, I could provide these to the bank to clear the matter up.

Notably, had I not kept my own copy of these documents, I could not have gone back to my employer for new copies. Due to the change of control, they had changed payroll vendors, and had eventually terminated the contract with the old vendor, so I could not have gotten a payslip from 1.5 years ago. Similarly, in the move to the new owner's HR system, the company had lost many of their records of agreements with employee's, including contracts etc., so it's not clear they would still have the terms of the RSUs, especially since the change of control payout rendered this a "completed" transaction. And later events made it clear that they did not have, e.g. a copy of my employment contract.

Similarly, if I ever had had a dispute over the terms of those contracts - if I hadn't kept a copy of the contract, and the company definitely hadn't kept theirs, any dispute would have been my word against theirs.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by iamwpj on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:18PM (#37802988)
Companies are legally required to keep payroll records for multiple years (depends on where you live, though I doubt most places are less than 3-4). This is ok advice, but these systems don't just work like this. If you didn't have the documentation the bank would likely take your approved tax filings as evidence and move on with their day.

In a real contract dispute your copy of a contact from your documents isn't notably different in the eyes of the court than one from your employer. They're both notarized and if there's a dispute between them there is established processes. Aside from some titles or etc., historical filing ownership is typically relegated to the document originators.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by kstrauser on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:10AM (#37802361)
I guess it’s partly a mentality thing for me. I’ve had numerous cases of sadness that I couldn’t produce a necessary document, and gladness that I was able to pull up something presumed long lost. For me, it’s easier to save everything “just in case”. It all adds up to less than 50GB so it’s not an enormous amount of data to store by current standards.

Seriously, a couple cases of “sorry, I don’t have proof to back up that tax deduction” or “hey, here’s the receipt proving that our TV is still covered by warranty!” make it all worthwhile.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by krupan on Saturday October 07, 2023 @11:43AM (#37802657)
In my experience, no, you don't need this. The few things I keep just go in folders named for the year under my Documents folder, and they are given descriptive filenames like paystub-2022-10-15.pdf, or companyA-w-2.pdf. In the rare cases where I need to go back to those (like for a loan application or doing taxes) it's easy enough to find them.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by esafak on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:08PM (#37802890)
I used to be more of a pack rat, perhaps because I grew up around parents that never threw anything away; my mother still has her clothes and shoes from the 70s. Now I throw away things as soon as possible. It is so liberating!

So I would be in favor of not scanning them, forgetting about them, then throwing them away when I eventually see them again and deciding I did not miss them.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by catlover76 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:13PM (#37802936)
Seriously. People in this thread are describing some setups that momentarily seem cool in theory, but are almost certainly overkill for personal use.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by whateveracct on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:57PM (#37803970)
Luckily, running paperless-ngx on my NixOS desktop is trivial. And it was also trivial to make it accessible over an avahi name on my local network. So it was kind of a "why not" sort of thing.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by nh2 on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:13PM (#37806975)
Indeed, the NixOS module works well. I just tried it:

    services.paperless.enable = true;
In contrast to Docker, it composes well with other things on the same system (e.g. the Samba server already set up to receive documents from my scanner), and I get automatic security updates for it.
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by MrVandemar on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:32PM (#37807385)
It depends.

We had this ridiculous money-making scheme from the Federal Government a few years back called "Robodebt", which basically amounted to sending demands to pay back welfare money that they claim was incorrectly claimed ... long after the retention period for the paperwork. Conveniently they declined to show their working for the so-called incorrect claims.

Most people didn't keep their timesheets and records, and then couldn't prove they weren't overpaid, and were supposedly liable for the "debt".

Some people comitted suicide over it.

If you had your records, you probably wouldn't have lost any sleep over it, much less your life.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by ipsi on Saturday October 07, 2023 @12:32PM (#37803127)
Kinda - at the moment I'm receiving _a lot_ of documents, mostly as PDFs via E-Mail (some the original digital version, some scans of physical copies), but some via post as well.

I've only added documents I've received this year (plus a couple of dozen documents going further back), and I've got ~250 in there, with a total of ~2.5m words (although I think word-count is a fuzzy concept in German).

I've posted a top level comment in more detail, but yeah, it's helpful to me.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by faiD9Eet on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:08PM (#37803441)
You are right, you do not want to lookup documents that old, it is a waste of time... ... unless you are a German and the state asks for your time sheets three years in the past because you've gotten child support and are requested to prove your working hours. ... unless you happen to have an accident and your insurance is fighting with another insurance who's gonna pay and they ask you about the incident two years later ... unless you end up in a contract fight with the postal operator, that can take a year of mailing before being settled.

Some correspondences take years and only add a mailing every few months. You would like to have a thread-like view -- as in an electronic mail. That is the strength of document management systems.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by djbusby on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:34PM (#37803702)
I have a small business in USA. For federal business taxes I need 6-7 documents. Then that process creates other documents I need for personal taxes, which also requires 6-8 more documents. So, I'm roughly 20 important documents per year for federal taxes. Nexus in 3 states, adds more. And save them all for 7 years.

The other end of the spectrum in USA is filling with the 1040-EZ which is like a 3-4 document process.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by whateveracct on Saturday October 07, 2023 @01:54PM (#37803935)
It's nice to throw papers away without worrying about it. Or to archive instruction manuals for stuff I own - paperless is the first place I look (its search is nice).
Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by SoftTalker on Saturday October 07, 2023 @08:59PM (#37806916)
> I throw everything away once it's handled

That's the Marie Kondo approach. I feel the same way. I'm not sure that digitizing everything really removes clutter. It removes the physical paper, yes. But not the mental overhead of knowing that you have all those documents.

Some people obviously have a need to retain documents for things like business expenses that will be deducted from income. I don't have any of that. I get my W2s and 1099s and do my taxes. I throw all that in one folder and put it in a box in the closet. That's good enough for my purposes; I see no need to expend the time and mental energy necessary to scan and tag (even automatically) every receipt, utility bill, and other statements I receive. Why? I'll never look at them again.

Re:A Clutter-Free Life: Going Paperless with Paperless-Ngx by bradknowles on Sunday October 08, 2023 @05:03PM (#37814382)
In the US, the IRS can audit your taxes going back at least seven years. So, you should keep at least seven years worth of the documents that you might need to produce during an audit.

And there are some important documents you want to keep longer than that -- birth certificates, wedding certificates, death certificates, documentation around the house you buy, documentation around your car, any personal health documents you keep, etc....

So, you'll want to have electronic copies of all that, and ideally backed up to an offsite location, in case you have a fire in your house. If you at least have electronic copies of those documents, even if you lose the original document in a fire, there's a good chance you can use that information to get new certified copies sent to you by the appropriate city/state government in question.

So, yeah, this can become a thing that needs to be carefully monitored and managed over the decades.