News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by stkdump on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:25AM (#37799745)
The modern insistence on (absolute) memory safety feels like another symptom of regression. It is like going back to insisting you can and should be absolutely safe from HIV by making certain lifestyle choices. In the '80s we knew that the answer was being safer, not being safe.

I am all for making C and C++ safer by adding mitigations for the most common security relevant bugs. Either on language level, or on tooling level or on OS level or on CPU level. Or a combination of them. But since making a language absolutely memory safe doesn't make it automatically impossible to have bugs at all (even security relevant bugs), we should consider everything a trade-off.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by hurril on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:39AM (#37799818)
This is a silly argument. Making a language _memory safe_ protects against one class of bugs and that has merit in and of itself. The fact that there are more classes does not negate the value of that. To borrow(lol!) your own analogy here: it makes $language Safer. Not safe.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by dwnvotee on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:39AM (#37799814)
Yup, keep the zero-days comin
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by _dain_ on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:40AM (#37799822)
>It is like going back to insisting you can and should be absolutely safe from HIV by making certain lifestyle choices. In the '80s we knew that the answer was being safer, not being safe.

This is a singularly bad analogy. HIV used to be a death sentence, but now we have effective treatments and prophylactics.

What's the PrEP equivalent for buffer overflows? There isn't one.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by stkdump on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:49AM (#37799866)
Oh, there are lots of PrEP equivalents. For example NX. Or virtual memory more in general. Or static analysis. Etc etc. If you think the modern ecosystem is as memory bug prone as it was in the 80s, you are being incredibly naive.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by hurril on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:43AM (#37799838)
I'm new to properly native languages, but having worked with Rust for 6 months, I've yet to encounter a single crash that wasn't on part of my error handling.

I _love_ C and I've written one C program every year for the last decade or two. I generally write something really stupid, but there's going to be crashes that "prints the stack pants." As in: I'll fudge up returning the stack from a function, basically.

This proves nothing, of course. But Rust won't even let me fudge things up that way. This means that I have more time to spend fixing those other classes of bugs and that is the win!

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by stkdump on Saturday October 07, 2023 @03:56AM (#37799892)
I have been full time in C++ development for >15 years. I can count the number of times I had memory correctness issues that weren't discovered and fixed trivially on one hand, all of them very early in my career. As your adage, of course mine doesn't prove anything.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by lpapez on Saturday October 07, 2023 @04:40AM (#37800093)
I don't want to sound like I'm downplaying your carreer, but what kinds of projects did you work on for 15 years to have this positive experience?

For instance I find it incredible that you never had to debug and workaround a third party vendor DLL that you didn't have source for but that was leaking memory like crazy. Whenever I talk to colleagues in embedded development such stories always come up.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by stkdump on Saturday October 07, 2023 @06:02AM (#37800443)
I have been working on a monorepo C++ codebase with on the order of 1000 person years of development on it.

And no, we didn't have major issues with memory leaks either. About on par with what I have seen in garbage collected languages. RAII works quite good most of the time.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by lpapez on Saturday October 07, 2023 @08:50AM (#37801303)
I take it that your project being a monorepo means you have access to the code and can change it when deemed neccessary?

I get how that would be characterized as "trivially fixable", but I assure you that this is not the kind of projects people complain about when they discuss memory safety issues.

Consider that some people need to send emails to vendor companies begging them to stop segfaulting, writing the stack or leaking memory. You're lucky if it gets fixed in a few months, because that means you wouldn't have to seek alternatives which would be even more time consuming. In conclusion, there are many people out there dealing with memory safety issues which are anything but "trivially fixable".

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by stkdump on Saturday October 07, 2023 @09:58AM (#37801739)
See now what I mean by calling this a trade-off? Not everyone is in the same boat. I don't understand how this can even be a controversial stance.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by vacuity on Saturday October 07, 2023 @07:21PM (#37806358)
Microsoft and Firefox have cited around 70% memory bugs, and they probably have tooling and whatnot. There are a few languages with good C/C++ FFI that are a better choice for memory safety, and so the tradeoff there isn't very high. I grant there may be ABI edge cases or whatever, but C/C++ is no longer viable or necessary for a good portion of software.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by hasmanean on Saturday October 07, 2023 @07:07AM (#37800717)
Well 3rd party libraries that are sloppy may be fixed by a psychological method…if you had an autotest environment that fuzzed the inputs and checked for correctness, you could label each library as “robust” or “weak” and leave it at that.

Then people could decide which ones to use based on the label alone. This would be an incentive for people to fix their libraries.

Then the process of normal attrition would take care of all the sloppy libraries.

Evolution at its finest.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by imtringued on Saturday October 07, 2023 @07:08AM (#37800726)
The thing is, you can't know that unless you go out of your way to exploit your own code.
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by jjnoakes on Saturday October 07, 2023 @10:54AM (#37802205)
I've been working in a similar environment, and once a month (or more) someone comes to me with a crash they don't understand. It usually takes a couple of days to debug (since the easy bugs don't make it to me), and every single one is some kind of undefined behavior (temporary lifetime confusion, dangling reference, callbacks modifying containers during caller iteration, ...)
Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by pjmlp on Saturday October 07, 2023 @04:31AM (#37800045)
It isn't modern, UNIX folks decided to ignore what was being done outside Bell Labs.

Had UNIX not been free beer, history would have been quite different for C and C++.

Re:Could we make C arrays memory safe? Probably not, but let... by imtringued on Saturday October 07, 2023 @07:06AM (#37800710)
Your analogy would work if every person having sex gets HIV. Buffer overflows are deeply rooted into C to the point that in the past some standard functions made buffer overflows mandatory.