You’re lost in the weeds. I know that’s the point it’s why the whole song on the radio thought experiment got brought up. The question was, if an AI model trains on public radio waves, and hears a copyrighted song, is that infringement? My position is no, it’s not because the radio station had a license to broadcast that song on the radio.

Similar, if all the books used to train a model are available in the library, so long as someone rents the books, then they can be used to train a model.

The question was directed at you. I don’t know why you’re repeating it back to me like I didn't know what I was asking…

Feel free to chat with a lawyer on copyright