DOI's are far, far more centralized in that CrossRef issues many orders of magnitude more DOI's than all of the others.
The cite-and-be-cited-by use case for scholarly articles is way more compelling than any other use case devised for DOI's.
Also, some agencies sell the numbers range to publishers (I believe the US is in that case) and others give them away at no cost (France). As a result, some small publishers get ISBNs from more liberal agencies than their own country: one can never be 100% sure a French ISBN matches a French publisher for example.
It's also possible some publishers re-use old numbers or affix the same number to different releases/editions of a book.
It's a mess.
But a global centralized system would probably be way worse, so we have to live with that mess.
People never enter ISBNs manually, anyways. So it might as well be longer string. Or a QR code.
I mean, if IT can do anything, it is to solve this problem.
https://www.bowker.com/siteassets/files/pdf-files/datasubmis...
Since this is the second time I've mentioned Bowker, let me just say that I do not and have never worked for them or with them, although I did meet with their reps several times when I worked in a different part of digital publishing. It's just that they're inescapable when you're talking about ISBNs.
If that sounds sloppy...I went to publishing conferences fairly regularly from the late 90's into the teens, and I never saw a program that didn't have at least one session or panel titled something like "Publishers must improve their metadata practices."