News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by roc on Friday March 30, 2012 @10:51AM (#3776172)
The problem is that the copyright clock starts ticking the moment you've fixed an expression, not from any registration or publishing date. So a creation that is largely done but is being shopped around to publishers, or sitting in a drawer collecting small tweaks and edits is losing its monopoly.

And if you erode much off 14 years, it starts to sound unnecessarily short.

Just ask any writer, comedian or musician how long their original creations were kicking around before they got anyone interested in paying them for it. Several years is common for their pre-discovery work.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by randomdata on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:32AM (#3776422)
Copyright was setup by the people to give incentive to create new works for the people. If you can rest on the work you did decades ago, there leaves no reason to continue with the arts†, which goes against the whole spirit of copyright in the first place.

† Assuming profit is the driving motivator, as copyright does.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by roc on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:07PM (#3776641)
I think you're putting too much emphasis on trying to maximize output from each individual creator. When, in every case I've ever heard or read of, creators already go as fast as they can (provided they can afford to live off their creations). And, further, despite those efforts very few find subsequent success.

So worrying that creators might sit by the proverbial poolside instead of creating new works seems silly to me and completely at odds with reality, even under our current copyright regime where copyright is effectively perpetual.

What I take into consideration when thinking about copyright terms, is trying to balance a reasonable time from which a creator can make a living off their work (given what we know about how creation happens), against a reasonable time before which others can try to make their living from that work.

As that is also what the public domain is about: freeing up old works for others to extend, adapt and interpret in their own attempt to make a living.

And along those lines, it's worth recognizing that there's a very real risk to the rate of 'new' creation that would come from shorter copyright terms. Should Mickey Mouse fall out of copyright, wouldn't the corporate incentive be to put Mickey Mouse into every children's work? (Particularly given the state of our risk-averse creative industries.)

The 'new' works we got might well start looking even more familiar than they do today.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by jberryman on Friday March 30, 2012 @03:01PM (#3777540)
> So worrying that creators might sit by the proverbial poolside instead of creating new works seems silly to me and completely at odds with reality...

It seems equally silly to worry about squeezing every ounce of profitability out of every work of art that we can think of, and for every edge case.

Artists will keep creating whether copyright is infinite or only 14 years. Maybe 22.7 years is optimal, but this is a boring discussion to have

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by zmmmmm on Friday March 30, 2012 @06:27PM (#3778424)
> balance a reasonable time from which a creator can make a living off their work (given what we know about how creation happens), against a reasonable time before which others can try to make their living from that work.

Perhaps shift the perspective a little. What is reasonable time period for which others should be prevented from producing new work derived from the original? The problem I have is that copyright is at conflict with what we all know to be reality: most art is a product of our shared culture and only partly original. Copyright actually blocks the natural evolution of ideas and prevents society from benefiting from significant derived works.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by DannoHung on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:06AM (#3776254)
Just change it to "The moment the work is displayed, published, performed, or otherwise exhibited in a public venue under authorization from the creator" or whatever the equivalent legalese is.
Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by roc on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:28AM (#3776398)
If copyright doesn't begin until exhibition, then the outright theft of private works is legalized. [1] You'll have reintroduced the problems that implicit copyright existing at the moment of creation was intended to solve.

So to fix that, we can then either recognize the right of the author prior to publishing/exhibition with more complicated rules, or simply extend the term a little and maintain simplicity.

[1] Joe writes a book. He shows it to Bob for notes. Bob publishes it under his own name. The copyright would belong to Bob.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by sophacles on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:07PM (#3776643)
There is a sane middle ground. Copyright is granted upon creation, but infringement can only be pursued in cases where theft (or strongly probably) theft can be shown. Someone you don't know has the same idea? Tough cookies, you should have published. After public unveiling (registration, publication, etc), the timer starts. This puts some onus on the creator to not spread his work around willy-nilly, but allows him to shop publishers etc.
Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by angersock on Friday March 30, 2012 @11:12AM (#3776291)
Several years would still give you nine or ten under copyright.

Anyways, if you can't move product in a few years, you should be trying something new.

Re:Infinite Copyright Is Killing Culture by Avshalom on Friday March 30, 2012 @12:29PM (#3776753)
Hopefully this will be less of a problem going forward with ebooks but the internet is full of stories of writers with several profitable books published who ended up sitting on novels for years when the horror market collapsed, good well edited books that went on to be profitable when "Urban Fantasy" started selling.

Or just a case of publishers not wanting to publish more than X books a year from a given writer, regardless of output.

Those are books of course. Movie scripts are notorious for floating around Hollywood for years, sometimes decades.