News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by shafyy on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:36PM (#37755051)
I've used Arc as my main browser for a few months, and loved the Spaces feature that lets you sandbox cache and cookies. Very similar to Firefox Multi-Account Containers, but the UI is better because you can swipe to the next Space and only see the relevant tabs open.

I've switched back to Firefox for a few reasons:

1) Arc is based on Chromium, and I don't want to support Chrome

2) I just couldn't get used to the layout with the tabs on the side instead of the top. It makes the the window narrower, and I found that this worsened my experience on many websites. Yes, you can hide the sidebar, but it's a pain in the ass to always toggle it.

3) I don't think they'll be around in a few years. They're heavily VC-backed, and while they say that they want to monetize via paid team features, I don't see how they could generate enough money to justify VC-style growth. Most likely they will be sold and integrated/closed, or they will shut down.

4) They're "quirky" CEO that does all these videos and weird product updates really irks me in the wrong way. I realize that this is subjective and others might like it, but still.

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by tapoxi on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @02:35PM (#37755797)
As a counterpoint from someone who's been daily driving Arc since this summer:

1) Most sites are designed for Chrome these days, and our customers also use Chrome or Edge. I get not wanting to support Google itself, but Chromium has become the de-facto standard at this point, and Firefox is actively declining with 6% desktop and 3% overall share.

2) This is a preference thing for sure, I'm a fan of vertical tabs and was previously a Vivaldi user. I really like the design of pinned tabs too, it makes me actually use them. This is a workflow thing and I'd just avoid Arc if you don't like vertical tabs.

3) Who knows, Vivaldi and Brave manage to stick around. The Google integration money doesn't seem to be bad. They also don't need their engineering team to encompass developing the rendering engine, they can focus on the UI.

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by yborg on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @02:57PM (#37756032)
>Firefox is actively declining with 6% desktop

It's been dying for at least a decade, and I'll put up my entire NFT stash and bet you it will be here long after Arc has been forgotten.

Remember RockMelt? Yeah, nobody else does, either.

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by tapoxi on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:50PM (#37757382)
It's not going to become zero, just irrelevant for developers to test against.
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by gisely on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:31PM (#37757842)
I bet my entire Beanie Baby stash that your NFT stash won't be worth anything by the time you're ready to judge this bet.
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by shafyy on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @05:20AM (#37762770)
> I get not wanting to support Google itself, but Chromium has become the de-facto standard at this point, and Firefox is actively declining with 6% desktop and 3% overall share.

That's exactly the reason why I want to support alternative engines like Firefox's.

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by treyd on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @02:35PM (#37755800)
> They're heavily VC-backed, and while they say that they want to monetize via paid team features

This alone is a huge reason not to use it. After the OS/kernel, the browser is probably the most important and security-sentitive program on your computer. Being not free software should be an automatic nonstarter. I don't know why the W3C doesn't fund development of Servo or similar as a foss project given how absolutely essential maintaining a neutral browser (/engine) is for the health of the web.

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by Ncarpentieri4 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @02:40PM (#37755853)
I also think the quirks/cheeky stuff is a little too much. But I will say I have no desire to go back to any other browser. The side bar, pinning, spaces, favorites have revolutionized the way I use the internet. I think this is the most well thought out product I've seen in years, I would be very sad to not see them survive.
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by dmazzoni on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:00PM (#37756059)
I'm not sure I understand concerns about not wanting to support anything based on Chromium.

Chromium is 100% open-source, and there are Chromium committers from Microsoft, Opera, Samsung, Igalia, Electron, and dozens of other companies, plus some who are affiliated.

I understand not wanting to use Google Chrome, but why throw out the whole open-source browser engine?

If the argument is that you don't want Google to benefit, then are you going to similarly boycott any other open-source technology that Google created or uses? Are you going to boycott the Linux kernel because Google heavily uses it? Are you going to boycott Kubernetes, Flutter, and Go as well? Are you going to boycott every Electron app too?

Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by theshrike79 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:39PM (#37756540)
[delayed]
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by asadotzler on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:06PM (#37757581)
Gonna guess you weren't online in the early 2000s when we fought like hell to disrupt Microsoft Trident's 95% browser monopoly that it was using to stall the web so .Net and other MS Windows platforms could hopefully catch up and not be disrupted. We're there again with Chromium, another Trident.
Re:Arc browser built-in AI features [video] by shafyy on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @05:19AM (#37762765)
True, Chromium is open source. But as others have stated: Google is the main driver and benfactor of Chromium, and we need more diversity in the browser engine game.

The examples you mentioned don't suffer from the same quasi-monopoly structure in the market.