News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by gottorf on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:44AM (#37751844)
That's a curious position to take, and I expect a rain of downvotes on your comment. What makes you say that? Are you just opposed to high-density living?
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Eumenes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @09:49AM (#37751914)
My small rural town has setup a 'affordable housing council' and recently approved a 'general assistance fund for low income town residents'. I was under the impression that town governments work for the taxpayers, the homeowners, not non-residents wanting to move here from other places, who'll require subsidized housing and likely, dip into the general assistance fund (its just welfare, which they can claim on top of federal and state benefits). There are almost no employers/jobs here, so there's no push from business to attract workers who'll require cheaper housing. Its just bleeding hearts who moved here from cities and want to engage in activism.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Georgelemental on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:10AM (#37752231)
You can make housing legal to build without also subsidizing it with taxpayer money. The former doesn't require the latter.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Eumenes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:19AM (#37752337)
Some things I support, like legalizing accessory dwellings, but radical measures such as banning single family development, or recklessly allowing large multifamily homes on small lots, I do not, as it changes the character of the town and doesn't help existing residents.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:40AM (#37752594)
Has any jurisdiction in the US banned single family development? I am not aware of a single one.

Some have done away with single family zoning, but it's still perfectly legal to build SFH there; it's just not the only thing that's allowed to be built.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by danny_codes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:17PM (#37753915)
Nobody is banning SFH. The push is to change zoning to allow more variety in residential structures. People without kids may prefer an apartment / greater density.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Georgelemental on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:57PM (#37758158)
> changes the character of the town

What exactly do you mean by that?

- New arrivals bring crime and disorder? Enforce the law, lock criminals up, problem solved.

- Overcrowded schools/overused city services? Tax new residents as needed to support new services.

- Packed roads? Public transit is one option, there are others but I admit to not being an expert in this area

- Just want to keep your town's culture the same? Legitimate desire, but consider how achievable it is—if young families can't afford to live in your area, it will just die out eventually.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by softwaredoug on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:00AM (#37752061)
I think the challenge is non-residents will move to your town. Your only control is how you shape your town between suburban / sprawl / commuting or denser / urban / walkable.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Eumenes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:08AM (#37752203)
Why should property tax payers of a town subsidize people who don't even live in your town? There is no right to an affordable apartment/home in a place you don't live. Local governments should focus on being small and efficient, not inviting cost to the current property tax payers.

And I do believe you have control over how your town is shaped. You can shape zoning and ordinance laws to prevent certain types of projects - whether it be fast food, drive-thrus, strip clubs, or dispensaries. Housing developers are trying to make money, and if you make it difficult to make a profit, they won't build.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by softwaredoug on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:31AM (#37752488)
I would say they're not doing it so much for the new residents, but the current residents.

It truly is about the character of your town.

If your current residents wants to hire a teacher, firefighter, restaurant worker, etc that person may need to move in from out of town. So you can decide how / where people live through zoning.

You also decide how easy/hard it is for people to live in your town, and thus how much goods and services costs.

It's entirely in your hand...

I just think most people focus on one aspect (buildings near them) and don't think about other tradeoffs (all the consequences of how/where people your town 'hires' could live as the economy grows). It's complicated and the whole point is you get to work with your zoning board to make those decisions informed by the data and needs of the town.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by ecshafer on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:18AM (#37752320)
Wouldn’t removing zoning make the local government smaller and more efficient? While also allowing the free market to take effect, and also decrease the tax burden on residents by adding new ones?

You are arguing two completely unrelated topics as if they are connected: zoning and welfare.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by yunwal on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:15PM (#37753891)
Once every homeowner in your town is retired, how do you think this is going to end for you?
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Eumenes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:58PM (#37756748)
Retired people still pay property taxes on their homes.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by buttercraft on Wednesday October 04, 2023 @10:49AM (#37765985)
Who does the labor then?
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by gs17 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:28AM (#37752454)
> a 'general assistance fund for low income town residents'. > not non-residents wanting to move here from other places

Which is it? "Town residents" or "non-residents"?

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by mslate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:43AM (#37752639)
How is banning multi-family housing from being constructed on privately-owned land the same thing as your city’s subsidized housing commission? Ones banning humans from being able to physically move into town at all (or existing landowners from exercising their property rights), the other is using city funds to subsidize/incentivize some people’s housing costs. You seem to be equating the two.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:49AM (#37752718)
> I was under the impression that town governments work for the taxpayers, the homeowners

No. They work for the residents, independently if whether they are taxpayers or homeowners.

> not non-residents wanting to move here from other places, who'll require subsidized housing and likely, dip into the general assistance fund (its just welfare, which they can claim on top of federal and state benefits).

Yeah, the assistance fund for low-income residents is for residents, not non-residents.

> There are almost no employers/jobs here.

That is a common cause of low-income residents.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by smileysteve on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @11:42AM (#37753396)
Your anecdote sounds like much of America; Where subsidized housing is a bandaid on income inequality and stagnated wage growth, in addition to the US's largest demographic shift in a century.

Your town could seemingly cut out the middleman (the taxpayer) by raising minimum wage (which would either decrease opportunities or increase housing affordability). Ideally, increasing the highest margin progressive property and income taxes also to reduce income inequality and housing prices - while lowering the lower marginal brackets.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by malcolmgreaves on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @11:52AM (#37753523)
> the homeowners

Well, this is a very old racial dog whistle — so much so that I don’t think it’s only a dog whistle even today: only the (white) land owners get to vote and have a say in government! Make sure housing prices stay high so that they buy folks with generational wealth today can buy in my “small town”!

Absolutely fucking gross.

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by ZacNorth on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:18PM (#37753935)
Thank you for pointing out the undertone that is very apparent in this thread. Disgusts me to see some other posters hide behind “homeownership” to avoid speaking the truth about their reprehensible beliefs.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by Eumenes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:00PM (#37756781)
You're the weirdo who brought race into this. This is a serious forum, if you want to make inflammatory comments, you can go to twitter or reddit.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by mrcrumb1 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @11:55AM (#37753580)
Do you think your homeownership is unsubsidized?
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by danny_codes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:18PM (#37753923)
He probably believes he did it all by himself.
Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by danny_codes on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:14PM (#37753866)
It sounds like your town is not affordable to some residents, so your local government needs to help support those residents. Your non-resident/resident distinction is meaningless in the US, because we have freedom of movement. Anybody can move to your town if they feel like it, and would them be a resident.

Internal movement restrictions come with their own problems, so probably not the best solution.

Perhaps if your town allowed for development, there would be sufficient supply, and you wouldn't need to subsidize housing?

Re:Rent growth is slowing (where housing got built) by l33t7332273 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @12:38PM (#37754218)
>its just welfare, which they can claim on top of federal and state benefits

You say that like it’s a bad thing. Why shouldn’t people be getting help to afford homes?