News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by guntherhermann on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:06AM (#37749144)
I don't consider 'tech workers', working class. We're higher paid, our jobs do not destroy our bodies, in my mind it's a purely middle class career. I agree with your actual point though, we are pampered.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by rwmj on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:11AM (#37749176)
Of course tech workers are working class. You either give your labour for a living or you invest capital in businesses, and almost every tech worker is doing the former.

> our jobs do not destroy our bodies

I've got news for you there.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by thathndude on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:42AM (#37749370)
this is a valid definition of “working class,” (I.e. non-owners), but it’s not how the phrase is typically used.

This phrase would include any non-owner professional like lawyers or doctors or even upper management.

On top of that many tech workers don’t fit even your definition because equity is often an important part of comp. That’s not the case for lawyers or doctors or management in other industries.

Using standard and customary vernacular, tech workers are not “working class.”

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by Izkata on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:20PM (#37757024)
Yeah, this group is called professional class, not working class.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by guntherhermann on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:36AM (#37749339)
By the definition you give then people who claim benefits and do not work are not "working class".

It is delusional to think our jobs are on the same level as someone who grafts all day with their hands and does back breaking work for minimum wage.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by rwmj on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:11AM (#37749532)
Not everyone who is working class is on minimum wage. Train drivers or boiler engineers or site foremen? All paid very well, in the UK as much or even more than tech workers.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by guntherhermann on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:32AM (#37749649)
I come from a working class background so I'm very aware of all of this. However my family (extended+) have all had poorly paying jobs, coal miners, nurses, pallet makers, warehouse, electricians, labourers, bakers. I'm the first to go to uni and do an easy job that pays well.

It is physically easy and it is very different from the other jobs I've listed.

Our jobs aren't working class.

Edit: by the by, boiler engineers are not paid well. A self-employed plumber with a gas cert can earn a good wage, but your average british gas tradie isn't bringing home half of what I earn

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:42AM (#37749712)
> By the definition you give then people who claim benefits and do not work are not “working class”.

Yes, people who do not rely on overwhelmingly on selling labor for their support are not working class (people who are working class might transitionally be on support without working, or might be on support while working, depending on the benefit structure, but if their principal source of support over an extended time is not selling labor, then they aren’t, as a matter of economic class, “working class”.)

Just as someone isn’t part of the capitalist class if over time they do get most of their support from working and don’t have capital holdings. Economic class is a description of how you relate to the economy.

> It is delusional to think our jobs are on the same level as someone who grafts all day with their hands and does back breaking work for minimum wage.

The proletarian class isn’t defined by the nature of labor, but by the fact of selling it as one’s overwhelming-majority means of support within the economy. Yes, there are important differences within the class as well as the broad common features and interests.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by pmulard on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @02:25PM (#37755669)
There are plenty of factory/labor jobs that don’t require people to wreck their bodies. Many of them provide workstations where people have the option to sit/stand or they are walking around most of the time. Occasionally bending over, not too much heavily lifting. Many of my ex coworkers who did these jobs were in fantastic shape. It’s disingenuous to pick out an extreme example.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by michaelt on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:10AM (#37749527)
> I've got news for you there.

Eh, compared to my relatives in the trades, construction, retail and warehouse work, and the jobs I had in high school, I'm on easy street here.

Negligible risk of trips or falls, no lifting anything heavy, no working around powerful machines or using dangerous tools, no dealing with chemicals, no need for hard hats or safety boots, no working in hot or cold or wet conditions, no working with knives, no splattering hot oil, no working in the dark, no loud noise, no working near moving vehicles, no standing on your feet 8 hours a day, no boss that gets mad if you're off sick, no mandatory overtime, very low stress.

The only thing that makes tech work more dangerous than sitting on my ass on the sofa is the office's free chocolate.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:39AM (#37749692)
> Of course tech workers are working class. You either give your labour for a living or you invest capital in businesses

I mean, you’ve left out the petit bourgeoisie entirely, describing only the proletariat and haut bourgeoisie. Its true that some tech workers are in the proletariat (part of the proletarian intelligentsia) but a whole lot of tech workers are petit bourgeois, having a mixed reliance on capital and labor (not, for tech workers as such, the classical pattern of applying their own labor to their own capital, but that’s not the only pattern of mixed reliance that puts people in the middle class that sits between the working class and pure capitalists.)

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by meheleventyone on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:13AM (#37749188)
They mean working class in the capitalist sense rather than social class sense.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by efaref on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:24AM (#37749243)
The more I think about it, the more I come to the conclusion that the "middle class" was a fiction invented by the capital class to divide the working class in two and pit them against each other. If you or someone in your family has to work so that you can survive, you are working class.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by generic92034 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:33AM (#37749319)
I am not sure putting people working from pay check to pay check or having to work two jobs to survive in the same category as people getting middle six-figures TC would be helpful for analyzing the social strata.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by pbmonster on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:37AM (#37749343)
> the "middle class" was a fiction invented by the capital class to divide the working class

Totally agree.

> If you or someone in your family has to work so that you can survive, you are working class.

It's not so easy.

A dentist owning his own doctor's practice - the means of production, quickly worth several million dollars - does pretty clearly belong to the (petit) bourgeoise. His interest are often clearly opposed to that of the staff he employs. Every dollar saved on salaries, every day of vacation denied means more money in his pocket.

Yet he has to work every day.

The real difference are the means of production.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by interpenetrate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:47AM (#37749405)
You don't want to be divided from the miners who extract the minerals and the factory workers who assemble the crappy tech that we design? I do. It's absolutely squalid over there.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by Timon3 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:54AM (#37749444)
I sure don't! I want them to have it as good as I do, and I want to use my influence to make it so. This can only work if we are one group.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by interpenetrate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:29PM (#37756410)
You want to trade off positions with those 10 year olds in the quarries? That's fine. I'd rather go home at night to my family, watch The Wire with my wife for the tenth time, and then when everyone goes to sleep I'd like to come here and post on Hacker News. Please report back with your experiences.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by Timon3 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:38PM (#37756530)
I didn't say that, or anything close to it. Funny how in your eyes the only way to not separate yourself from them is to literally do their job. Maybe you can ignore those 10 year olds in the quarries, but I think it's our responsibility to use our positions to improve their situations. It would be kind of neat if there weren't 10 year olds in the quarries, and they could instead go to school, no?
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by interpenetrate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:35PM (#37757196)
Then who's going to do the mining? Adults? Do you want your iPhone, your car, your video games, your shoes, your plane trips, or not? All that stuff is gonna be "cost prohibitive" if all of these quarry kids go to school and all if these factory workers go home early. Cause: These unfortunate saps work 14 hours a day, eat straw, and have the philosophical thoughts whipped out of their brains. Effect: We live like kings and post all kinds of philosophy online. Don't believe me about this causality? Good, then we can go back to living like kings. You keep posting about ethics, and I'll keep posting about epistemology.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by Timon3 on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @04:45PM (#37757313)
Yes, it should be adults with good compensation. Child labor should never be acceptable to anyone, especially if you reap the rewards as described! I'd rather not live like a king quite as much, and have them have a better life. Or better yet, I'd rather have billionaires not exist and have both of us live like a king.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by interpenetrate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @10:38PM (#37760213)
I've crunched the numbers. They just don't work without me giving up video games. And I'm not giving up video games!!
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by hotpotamus on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:20AM (#37749577)
I wonder how senior tech executives see those below them? I suspect they'd say much the same about you.
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by interpenetrate on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @03:25PM (#37756360)
I don't know about that. I'm on a first name basis with my CTO. I hope to never see in person those wretched souls mining the cobalt for my Tesla. Ghastly!
Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by cracrecry on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @05:15AM (#37749553)
The man that invented the concept of classes to divide society in order to make them fight against each other was Marx. He created the concept of "class struggle" along the classes himself.

There was a very important reason for that. Early socialist leaders were usually selected among the best in any trade. The carpenters chose the best and most successful carpenter to represent them, and so on with most professions.

That was simply unacceptable for "intellectuals" like Marx or Lenin or Trotsky that never touched a tool or worked physically on their entire lives, something they were all the time being reminded by actual workers(something Lenin hated so much).

The new Frame made them the bosses on the new system.

Like Natzis could decide who was arian or jew, even if they had dark hair or jew parents, the marxist could decide who was working class and who did not. The children of rich jew merchants that were most marxist revolutionaries could became working class if they said so.

There are lots of people that do not accept the Marxist frame at all because they are not marxist.

>if you or someone in your family has to work so that you can survive, you are working class.

As someone who has lived in Africa , Asia, South America and Europe, I tell you that 90% of people in the US don't need work to survive. Unless by "survive" you mean things like buying a pickup truck.

There are kids in Africa in which "survive" means eating once a day and their minds being confused after two hours of work like learning to read.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by thiagoharry on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @01:43PM (#37755159)
Class is a very useful concept to understand societies. It's not even an exclusively Marxist concept. Weber also uses the term, but uses different metrics than Marx to distinguish between classes. How can you effectively have a good understanding of feudal society without understanding the division between feudal lords and serfs. Or between citizens, outsiders and slaves in classical Greek societies?

In discussions about philosophy ans philosophical concepts, one do not need to agree with all the interlocutor's assumptions: it is just required to understand them and discuss them in a balanced way.

Re:Meta's Mandatory Return to Office Is 'A Mess' by surgical_fire on Tuesday October 03, 2023 @06:11AM (#37749893)
Being well paid doesn't change the fact that I am providing labor for a salary. The very definition of "working class".