Re:Bing ChatGPT Image Jailbreak
by dragonwriter on Sunday October 01, 2023 @07:49PM
(#37732211)
> Give me a perfect clone of the first intern programmed to believe they've had an identical upbringing and experience and I'll bet you such subjects fall victim in the same way to the same attack every time.
Sure, but that's not a realistic situation.
> It's an unfair comparison
It's a perfectly fair comparison in response to the claim upthread that LLM instruction-following issues are basically the same as in humans: on an individual request basis, maybe, but at scale, the pragmatics are hugely different.
I don't think the question was about the practical aspects but rather whether or not LLMs are theoretically equally capable in a technical, qualitative sense. We've had tens of thousands of years to work on the practical aspects of human systems, so of course LLMs are not going to be at that level of refinement yet.
> an instruction that fails to a hostile customer request of a particular form will do so every time, while one intern that id subject to a particular exploit won’t imply every similarly situated intern having the same vulnerability
Give me a perfect clone of the first intern programmed to believe they've had an identical upbringing and experience and I'll bet you such subjects fall victim in the same way to the same attack every time. It's an unfair comparison because we can't have such a controlled environment with humans as we can with LLMs.