News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter / X is losing daily active users. CEO Linda Yacca... by louison11 on Sunday October 01, 2023 @12:10PM (#37727345)
I risk getting downvoted for this but we’ll see if HN is capable of politely entertaining discourse without automatically just silencing any voice that contradicts the politically correct: what if the science isn’t absolutely certain?

Surely, Musk isn’t dumb. From what I’ve seen, there are actually a lot of smart people who agree that climate change studies do not follow as precise a science as the media portrays.

I’m not saying the climate is not changing, but if you dig, there actually isn’t any solid, truly scientific proof that it’s human caused.

Of course, we have an ecological problem and we do need to address it: there is no question that we are responsible for deforestation, plastics in the ocean, and the extinction of species. We have a serious problem in our relationship to nature. And it must be fixed right now. We don’t even need climate change as a reason to do so. Animal lives and biodiversity is good enough of a reason.

But when it comes to climate change per se, it seems the evidence isn’t as strong as the drama would like us to believe. And there is definitely a way in which it’s become a bit cult-ish and has led to irrational decisions like the powering down on power plants that were still fully functional and carbon neutral.

Re:Twitter / X is losing daily active users. CEO Linda Yacca... by bdcravens on Sunday October 01, 2023 @12:28PM (#37727592)
Musk isn't dumb, but he's a visionary entrepreneur, not a scientist. Referencing "smart people" as an appeal to authority is a very weak argument. A brilliant attorney isn't qualified to work on my code either.

As for questioning science, that's literally the purpose of science. It should be done via better science, not hero worship.

Re:Twitter / X is losing daily active users. CEO Linda Yacca... by dpkirchner on Sunday October 01, 2023 @12:14PM (#37727402)
There isn't much here to discuss. What does "solid, truly scientific proof" look like to you, and what would researchers need to do to meet that standard?
Re:Twitter / X is losing daily active users. CEO Linda Yacca... by foogazi on Sunday October 01, 2023 @02:44PM (#37729073)
On what evidence do you base your thoughts on ?
Re:Twitter / X is losing daily active users. CEO Linda Yacca... by gremlinsinc on Sunday October 01, 2023 @05:44PM (#37731176)
> Of course, we have an ecological problem and we do need to address it: there is no question that we are responsible for deforestation, plastics in the ocean, and the extinction of species.

Deforestation alone has caused parts of climate change, so by that fact alone you contradict yourself. you can't say people are responsible for deforestation, deforestation causes climate change, but people are not a cause of climate change.

Plastics in ocean maybe affects plankton levels and other things that could take carbon out of the atmosphere, etc.

Scientists are lately claiming that we're moving even faster to bad situations than originally scheduled, most likely because to be more alarmist even if accurate would upset some people in powerful positions, like Galileo pissing off the Catholic Church etc...

What event would it take for your to say human caused climate change is real?